Toxicological ReviewToxicological ReviewТоксикологический вестник0869-7922Federal Scientific Center of Hygiene named after F.F. Erisman64101010.36946/0869-7922-2017-4-13-18ArticlesСтатьиCONCERNING COORDINATION BETWEEN THE GENERALLY ACCEPTED PRACTICE OF ASSESSING HEALTH RISKS DUE TO MULTI-METALLIC EXPOSURES AND THE THEORY OF COMBINED TOXICITYО СООТНОШЕНИИ МЕЖДУ ОБЩЕПРИНЯТОЙ ПРАКТИКОЙ ОЦЕНКИ РИСКА ДЛЯ ЗДОРОВЬЯ ПРИ ПОЛИМЕТАЛЛИЧЕСКИХ ЭКСПОЗИЦИЯХ И ТЕОРИЕЙ КОМБИНИРОВАННОЙ ТОКСИЧНОСТИMinigalievaI. A.МинигалиеваИ. А.
Russian Federation
KatsnelsonB. A.КацнельсонБ. А.
Russian Federation
GurvichV. B.ГурвичВ. Б.
Russian Federation
PrivalovaL. I.ПриваловаЛ. И.
Russian Federation
PanovV. G.ПановВ. Г.
Russian Federation
VaraksinA. N.ВараксинА. Н.
Russian Federation
SutunkovaM. P.СутунковаМ. П.
Russian Federation
The Medical Research Center for Prophylaxis and Health Protection in Industrial Workers of RospotrebnadzorФБУН «Екатеринбургский медицинский - научный центр профилактики и охраны здоровья рабочих промпредприятий» РоспотребнадзораInstitute of Industrial Ecology, the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of SciencesФБУН «Институт промышленной экологии» УрО РАН280820174131804112024Copyright ©; 2017, Minigalieva I.A., Katsnelson B.A., Gurvich V.B., Privalova L.I., Panov V.G., Varaksin A.N., Sutunkova M.P.Copyright ©; 2017, Минигалиева И.А., Кацнельсон Б.А., Гурвич В.Б., Привалова Л.И., Панов В.Г., Вараксин А.Н., Сутункова М.П.2017Minigalieva I.A., Katsnelson B.A., Gurvich V.B., Privalova L.I., Panov V.G., Varaksin A.N., Sutunkova M.P.Минигалиева И.А., Кацнельсон Б.А., Гурвич В.Б., Привалова Л.И., Панов В.Г., Вараксин А.Н., Сутункова М.П.https://journals.eco-vector.com/0869-7922/article/view/641010

Assessment of cumulative health risks associated with the widely observed combined effects of two or more metals and their compounds to the organism has the toxicology of mixtures as its scientific basis although there is no full match between such assessment and this basis though some of the contradictions between them are of a fundamental nature. This state of things may be explained not only by simplifications characteristic of the generally recognized methodology of risk assessment but also by extreme complexity of the theory of combined toxicity, the most essential issues of which are considered by authors on the basis of literary and, mostly, their own previously published data.

Хотя токсикология смесей является научной базой оценки кумулятивных рисков для здоровья, связанных с широко встречающимся комбинированным действием двух или более металлов и их соединений, однако, полного соответствия между ними нет, причём некоторые противоречия являются фундаментальными. Такое положение дел может быть объяснено не только упрощёнными подходами, характерными для методологии оценки риска, но и крайней сложностью теории комбинированной токсичности, основные аспекты которой авторы рассматривают на основе литературных и, главным образом, собственных ранее опубликованных данных.

toxic metalstypology of combined toxicitymathematical modelinghealth risk assessmentтоксичные металлытипология комбинированной токсичностиоценка рисковVaraksin A.N., Katsnelson B.A., Panov V.G., Privalova L.I., Kireyeva E.P., Valamina I.E., Beresneva O.Yu. Some considerations concerning the theory of combined toxicity: a case study of subchronic experimental intoxication with cadmium and lead. Food Chem. Toxicol. 2014; 64: 144–156.Кацнельсон Б. А., Вараксин А. Н., Панов В. Г., Привалова Л. И., Минигалиева И. А., Киреева Е. П. Экспериментальное моделирование и математическое описание хронической комбинированной токсичности как основа анализа многофакторных химических рисков для здоровья. Токсикологический Вестник. 2015; 5 (134): 37-45./ Katsnelson B.A., Varaksin A.N., Panov V.G., Privalova L.I., Minigalieva I.A., Kireyeva E.P. Experimental modeling and mathematical description of the chronic combined toxicity as a basis of multi-factor chemical health risks analysis. Tox. Vestnik. 2015; 5 (134): 37-45 (in Russian).Goldoni M., Johansson C. A. Mathematical approach to study combined effects of toxicants in vitro: evaluation of the Bliss independence criterion and the Loewe additivity model. Toxicol. In vitro. 2007; 21: 759–7Yeh P.J., Hegreness M.J., Aiden A.P., Kishony R. Drug interactions and evolution of antibiotic resistance. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 2009; 7: 460–466.Кацнельсон Б. А. Комбинированное действие химических веществ. В кн.: Курляндский Б. А., Филов В. А., ред. Общая токсикология. М.: Медицина; 2002: 497–520./ Katsnelson B.A. The combined action of chemicals. In: Kurlyandsky B.A., Filov V.A., eds. General Toxicology. Moscow: Meditsina Publishers; 2002: 497–520 (in Russian)Katsnelson B.A., Privalova L.I., Varaksin A.N., Kazmer J.I., Kireyeva E.P., Panov V.G. An approach to characterizing the type of combined environmental toxicity based on epidemiologically assessed exposure-response relationships. Open Epidemiol. J. 2010; 3: 113–122.Howard G.J., Webster T.F. Contrasting Theories of Interaction in Epidemiology and Toxicology. Environ. Health Perspect. 2013; 121: 1-6.Loewe S. The problem of synergism and antagonism of combined drugs. Arzneimittelforschung. 1953; 3: 285–290.Meek M.E., Boobis A.R., Crofton K.M., Heinemeye G., Kleiner J., Lund B.-O., Olin S., Pavittranon S., Rodriguez C., Van Raaij M., Vickers C., Waight-Sharma N. Assessment of combined exposures to multiple chemicals. Assessment of cumulated exposures to multiple chemicals. In: Report of a WHO/IPCS International Workshop. World Health Organization. Geneva, 2009; 11–Panov V.G., Katsnelson B.A., Varaksin A.N., Privalova L.I., Kireyeva E.P., Sutunkova M.P., Valamina I.E., Beresneva O.Yu. Further development of mathematical description for combined toxicity: A case study of lead–fluoride combination. Toxicol. Rep. 2015; 2: 297–307.Panov V.G., Varaksin A.N. Identification of combined action types in experiments with two toxicants: a response surface linear model with a cross term. Toxicology mechanisms and methods. 2016; 26 (2): 139–150.Katsnelson B.A., Minigaliyeva I.A., Panov V.G., Privalova L.I., Varaksin A.N., Gurvich V.B., Sutunkova M.P., Shur V.Y., Shishkina E.V., Valamina I.E., Makeyev O.H. Some patterns of metallic nanoparticles’ combined subchronic toxicity as exemplified by a combination of nickel and manganese oxide nanoparticles. Food Chem. Toxicol. 2015; 86: 351-364.Katsnelson B.A., Panov V.G., Minigaliyeva I.A., Varaksin A.N., Privalova L.I., Slyshkina T.V., Grebenkina S.V. Further development of the theory and mathematical description of combined toxicity: an approach to classifying types of action of three-factorial combinations (a case study of manganese-chromiumnickel subchronic intoxication). Toxicology. 2015; 334: 33-44.Minigalieva I.A., Katsnelson B.A., Privalova L.I., Sutunkova M.P., Gurvich V.B., Shur V.Y., Shishkina E.V., Valamina I.E., Makeyev O.H., Panov V.G., Varaksin A.N., Grigoryeva E.V., Meshtcheryakova E.Y. Attenuation of combined nickel (II) oxide and manganese (II,III) oxide nanoparticles’ adverse effects with a complex of bioprotectors. Int. J. of Mol. Sci. 2015; 16 (9): 22555-225Minigaliyeva I.A., Katsnelson B.A., Panov V.G., Privalova L.I., Varaksin A.N., Gurvich V.B., Sutunkova M.P., Shur V.Ya., Shishkina E.V., Valamina I.E., Zubarev I.V., Makeyev O.H., Meshtcheryakova E.Y., Klinova S.V. In vivo toxicity of copper oxide, lead oxide and zinc oxide nanoparticles acting in different combinations and its attenuation with a complex of innocuous bio-protectors. Toxicology. 2017; 380: 72-93.Hernàndez A.F., Tsatsakis A.M. Human exposure to chemical mixtures: Challenges for the integration of toxicology with epidemiology data in risk assessment. Food and Chem. Toxicol. 2017; 103: 188-1