Vol 4, No 3 (2015)

Articles

SAMARA EXPEDITION TO EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF ANCIENT POTTERY (SEEIDG): 25 YEARS

Vasil'yeva I.N., Salugina N.P.

Abstract

The article is devoted to presenting a brief history of the organization and carrying out for 25 years Samara expedition to the experimental study of ancient pottery. Organization of this expedition was due to the need to solve problems related to the study of ancient pottery techniques. The authors examined the concept of «cultural tradition» in the pottery and is designed structure of the experiment in the field of pottery technology. The main task of technological research in the framework of historical and cultural areas developed A.A.Bobrinskim, is the study of traces of in fractures and on the surface of archaeological vessels arising from the use of certain methods of the ancient potters work. The result of technological research is the reconstruction of the cultural traditions that have existed among the study population. Methods of studying pottery technology is based on a binocular microscope, trasologii and experiment in the form of physical modeling and assumes the reference series. The objectives of the expedition was to create a basic reference collections for all the stages of pottery production, as well as experiments on the problems arising in the analysis of particular archaeological ceramics. The article analyzes the realized expedition general and individual programs in two areas: research and education, and provides a list of reference collections of feedstock, molding compositions and methods for treating surfaces that are available for study.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):8-27
pages 8-27 views

THE EXPERIENCE IN THE APPLICATION OF ZONAL PATCHWORK MODELING IN THE RECONSTRUCTION OF THE METHODS OF MANUFACTURING THE NEOLITHIC PERIOD'S LARGE VESSELS

Vasil'yeva I.N., Salugina N.P.

Abstract

The article presents the results of experimental works, namely the application of zonal patchwork modeling in the manufacturing of large vessels, the shape and dimensions of which are similar to the Neolithic pitcomb vessels of the Volga region. It is dealt with the problems of identifying methods of designing archaeological ceramics techniques and of the findings verification. The experiment was carried out on the basis of the Samara expedition on the study of ancient pottery. The moulding compound with animal manure and gruss was prepared. Two ways were used: 1) the manufacture of the vessel in the shape of the container in accordance with a bottomcapacitive program of filling designing, with zonal patchwork modeling. Flat squashed lumps of mass in the form of «flat cake» in size of 4x4 cm and 5x8 cm were used as construction elements; 2) the manufacture of the vessel on the basis-form, the bottom-capacitance filling, small pre-element. The scraps 2.5-3 cm long were applied as «building elements»; they broke away from the braid 2-2,5 cm in diameter. The building was continuously carried out uninterruptedly in a path similar to the spiral. The experiment demonstrated the possibility and the maximum convenience of manufacturing of round-bottom and sharp-bottom vessels of large sizes with zonal patchwork modeling with the use of different form-models.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):28-37
pages 28-37 views

OVEN OR FIREPLACE? (EXPERIMENTAL FIRINGS OF THE VESSELS)

Volkova Y.V.

Abstract

The paper contains the results of the field experimental firings in fireplaces and in ovens made on the basis of Samara pottery experimental expedition (Dr N.P. Salugina is the leader of the expedition) in 2013. The author put forward two goals: one is to discover the basic knowledge on firing process with various kinds of fuel, and second is to find out the specific features to discern the vessels fired in fireplaces from the vessels fired in ovens. 20 vessels were prepared to the experiment. The first 10 pots were made of natural clay and the second 10 vessels were made of pottery paste (clay + grog + cow dung). Five simultaneous firings with various kinds of fuel were organized in fireplace and in oven. The author describes in detail the program, main steps, and maximum temperature of firings, the photos of the vessels, and the results of their analytical studies. After the experiments the author came to the next conclusions: firstly - there are absent the reliable features to distinguish the vessels fired in fireplace and in oven, secondly - there is one dependence between a kind pottery paste and a color of fired vessels and another relation between pottery paste and a degree of high-temperature baking of vessels.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):37-55
pages 37-55 views

SOME ISSUES OF EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF CLAY VESSELS' FIRING PROCESS

Volkova Y.V., Tsetlin Y.B.

Abstract

This paper is dedicated to the study of clay vessels' firing treatment. It is one of the most important scientific tasks in the field of ancient ceramic investigations which is low provided by the reliable methods till now. The next questions are described here: first - the history of study of firing process under historical-and-cultural approach to the ancient pottery production; second - the organization and results of field experimental study of clay vessels' firing in fireplace and in oven made by the authors on the basis of Samara pottery experimental expedition (N.P. Salugina is a head of the expedition), third - the results of the laboratory research of firing temperature on experimental vessels by Bobrinsky's color method. We concentrate our attention on the study of firing vessels in oxidizing and reducing conditions, on analysis of oxidizing firing at the first step and special chemical-and-thermal treatment of vessels in reducing conditions by blacking at the second step. In the results of laboratory tests of vessels sherds' firing temperature we came to the conclusion that the method is need to improve. At the end of paper the authors put forward some kind of ways to decide the problem and a plan of future experimental study of pottery firing process.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):56-62
pages 56-62 views

UNPACKING THE EARLY NEOLITHIC?

Dzhanfezova T., Doherty C., Elenski N.

Abstract

The preliminary analysis of Early Neolithic pottery from North Central Bulgaria, and the site of Dzhulyunitsa specifically, yielded surprising results which affect a number of aspects related to the study of the Neolithisation processes. Not all characteristic features traditionally considered as key signal of the Neolithisation processes were confirmed by our mineralogical and chemical analysis. A number of specifics related to the presence of engobe for instance, indicate a considerably more complex picture. In some cases the observations show no additional slip, just a simple burnish of the brownish ware, whereas in others a true slip covers both the inner and the outer surface of the vessels (white or cream-slip ware). With regard to the red engobe specifically, the majority of studied fragments actually have just red-colour surface that results from the oxidation or the rubbing of ochre, and not from the addition of a true slip. These observations raise the following question: do we actually compare same technological approaches, traditionally seen as signal for the spread of the Neolithic way of life? Furthermore, as regards the provenance of the vessels, materials expected to have local origin proved to be imported whereas others, seen as more specific and coming from distant territories were actually made on the spot by local row-materials. Even at this stage the preliminary results do not confirm some of the traditional views on this early material, raise a series of new questions and represent a ground for further interpretations and discussions regarding an eventual fragility of some models suggested for the Neolithisation processes in this part of South-East Europe.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):63-71
pages 63-71 views

RECONSTITUTION DES CHAINES OPERATOIRES DE FABRICATION DES CERAMIQUES NEOLITHIQUES DANS LE BASSIN PARISIEN RECONSTRUCTION OF THE PROCESS TECHNIQUES OF THE NEOLITHIC POTTERY IN PARIS BASIN: A RESEARCH ASSESSMENT

Giligny F.

Abstract

Depuis une quinzaine d'années, les travaux de reconstitution des chaînes opératoires de façonnage de la céramique ont été réalisés sur des corpus néolithiques du Bassin parisien et du nord de la France. Ces travaux sont menés par le biais de mémoires universitaires ou de programmes de recherches et sont encore largement inédits. Ils sont basés sur les principes énoncés dès les années 1950 par les archéologues et ethnologues des techniques sous l'égide en France d'A. Leroi-Gourhan et d'Hélène Balfet (1953) et ont été connu un regain d'intérêt dans les années 1990 à 2000 (Astruc et al. 2004, Giligny and Méry 2010). Ils sont également fondés sur une tradition des études de matériaux céramiques menés en parallèle dès les années 1980 (Constantin and Courtois1980). Le principe de ces travaux est basé sur une approche double : une analyse et description des stigmates et macrotraces de façonnage ainsi que des reconstitutions expérimentales afin de tester les chaînes opératoires. Les premières données nous permettront une approche trans-culturelle et une reconstitution de l'histoire des méthodes de production des premières céramiques dans le nord de la France. Ils permettent aussi d'appréhender de manières anthropologique les relations entre technique et société. Abstract : Since about fifteen years, works of reconstruction of the pottery operational sequence of manufacturing were realized on corpuses of the Neolithic of Paris Basin and the North of France. These works were led within the framework of university memoirs or of research programs and are still widely unpublished. They are based on the principles expressed from the 1950s by archaeologists and ethnologists of techniques trained in France by A. Leroi-Gourhan as Hélène Balfet (1953) [1] renewed in the 1990s to 2000 [2; 3]. They also lean on a tradition of the ceramic materials studies led in parallel since the 1980s [4]. The principle of these works bases on a two-pronged approach: an analysis and a description of stigmas and shaping fabric marks and the experimental reconstructions to test the hypotheses of operational sequences. The first data repository will have to allow later a cross-cultural approach and a reconstruction of the history of the production methods of the first potteries in northern France. They also allow to work on the anthropological analysis of the relationship between technique and society.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):72-90
pages 72-90 views

HOUSEHOLD AND SACRED USE OF THE POTTERY BY THE SARMATIAN TRIBES OF THE SOUTHERN URALS AND WESTERN KAZAKHSTAN

Kraeva L.A.

Abstract

The article deals with the pottery from the Sarmatian burial grounds of the Southern Urals and Western Kazakhstan. Pottery was placed in the graves of the representatives of all social stratums of the nomadic population. In more expensive imported dishes were usually placed. Sarmatian ceramics was actively used both in household and in religious ceremonies. Specially produced vessels for burial rites are found in the graves, as well as utensils already used in the household, including those repaired. The author points out the signs which prove that the pottery had been in household use before being placed in the grave: the presence of soot on the inner and outer walls of the vessels; grease stains and traces of boiling over liquid food; repair marks; (broken handles, chipped edges of the vessels, etc.); scuff marks and homemade polishing; the change of color on the surface the vessel and on the layers of the potsherds. The characteristics proving that the pottery was specially manufactured burial rites include: the use of raw materials with rough natural impurities; poor quality battering (uneven distribution of tempers); negligence in the moulding; short-term exposure to temperatures below 450 ° C during firing;) the absence of soot on the walls of the vessel; the absence of repair marks. The examination of the surface of the vessels and experimental work let the author make an assumption about the functional use of some types of pottery.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):90-100
pages 90-100 views

PETROGRAPHY FOR ASSESSMENT OF MOULDING COMPOUND OF ANCIENT POTTERY

Kulkova M.A.

Abstract

Ancient ceramics are the valuable artifacts which saves the information about ancient people and their traditions. The process of making pottery is begun with the choosing and preparation of raw clay and temper material and further applying of different techniques (moulding of vessel, decoration etc.) and finally firing. Petrographical analysis of ancient pottery allows to determine the mineralogical composition of ceramic matrix, the features of their technology and to identify the raw mineral sources (Feliu et al. 2004, Papadopoulou et al. 2006, Bastie et al. 2006). Such kind investigations expand the frames of our knowledge about ancient technological traditions in pottery making. The following characteristics could be determined in thin-sections of ceramic shards: nature and features of plastic and aplastic inclusions; textural and optical characteristics of clay matrix; shape, amount and orientation of pores; features of surface treatment, decoration. This information is animportant for understanding of principles of ancient technologies. The different temper materials inside clay matrix such as sand, crushed rocks, organic materials, shells, grog can be identified accurately using petrography. The ceramic structure and characteristics of mineral changes during the firing are indicators of firing temperatures and atmosphere. A distribution of clay particles and porous inside of ceramic matrix is useful for reconstruction of moulding methods. The study of ceramic collection of the same cultural tradition and from the same region using petrography gives the possibility for differentiation of the natural and cultural factors influenced on the choose of raw materials, variations in the ceramic composition and techniques. This method is one the most precise for identification of an import pottery.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):100-107
pages 100-107 views

THE INVESTIGATION OF METHODS TO APPLY OF «TEXTILE» IMPRINTS ON D'YAKOVO CULTUR CERAMICS

Lopatina O.A.

Abstract

The article contains the results of reconstruction of techniques and instruments, which made «textile» imprints appear on surface of D'yakovo pottery. The following techniques could cause the appearence of such imprints: 1) constructing in relief concave-forms, 2) paddling, 3) rouletting, 4) punching Experimental evidence allowed to prove that the «textile» imprints were mainly the result of rouletting. Special research permitted to establish some srecific signs of roueletting by the example of pottery wholly coverd with impressions of cord («nitochnyje»). The difference between the similar instruments - the roller winded with thread and the plate paddle winded with tread - were revealed. The technique of rouelling was revealed concerning one more group of pottery - the «speckled» («ryabchatyje») one. The instrument which was used to apply such imprints was also reconstructed. It is the fir cones with partly removed scales. The scales of the cone could be intentionally removed by a human or eaten round by the rodents. Specifity of the traces of the partly removed scales consists in the special outline of the scales, the imprints of the fibre, the traces of rodents' teeth, the imprints of the longitudinal edge of the scales. The amount of the examined imprints allows to talk about the existence of a certain cultural tradition in the sphere of D'yakovo pottery.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):107-113
pages 107-113 views

ABSOLUTE CHRONOLOGY OF UPPER VOLGA-TYPE POTTERY: MORE EVIDENCE FROM ZAMOSTJE 2

Meadows J., Losovski V.M., Lozovskaya O.V., Chirkova S.S., Craig O., Lucquin A., Spataro M.

Abstract

Zamostje 2, on the Dubna River, c.100km north of Moscow, appears to offer an ideal opportunity to understand the relative and absolute chronology of Upper Volga Early Neolithic pottery. More than 100 radiocarbon (14C) dates are available from a stratigraphic sequence which spans from the Late Mesolithic to the Middle Neolithic. All typological stages are represented among over 18,000 sherds of Early Neolithic pottery, and many of these sherds bear deposits of carbonised food remains (food-crusts), which can be dated directly by 14C; more than 30 food-crusts have been dated directly. Nevertheless, there remains considerable uncertainty about the date range of Upper Volga pottery at Zamostje 2, and many of the issues raised are relevant to dating early pottery at other sites. Moreover, the absolute chronology of Upper Volga pottery must have some bearing on the interpretation of 14C dates for pottery from adjoining regions. In this paper, we discuss alternative interpretations of the Zamostje 2 evidence.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):113-121
pages 113-121 views

THEORY AND PRACTICE OF RESEARCH ANCIENT CERAMICS: TRADITIONAL AND THE LATEST METHODS

Molodin V.I., Mylnikova L.N.

Abstract

Presents traditional and new methods of studying ancient pottery. Stressed that in the world literature there is practically no standard (or at least consistent) approach to the study of ancient ceramics samples using the methods of the natural sciences. Was marked severities and shortcomings and the main is: lack of access for archaeologists to use physical and chemical methods; unsystematic and randomness of the results; the inability to compare results. Lack of specialists among archaeologists and weak interest «natural scientists» led to the fact that have not yet been generalized instructional techniques of individual tests. The methods used for the study of ceramics, do not become the subject of training in higher educational institutions. That's why many archaeologists who study the technology of ancient pottery do not accept these methods because of considering them formal. Noted that the instrumental analysis using the methods of the natural sciences is aimed primarily at identifying those features that allow you to identify the technical and technological traditions and techniques of ancient pottery: raw materials strategy formulation and molding compounds. We propose a set of analytical methods that can be used for the reconstruction of pottery technology. On the example of the ceramic collections of the forest-steppe zone of Western Siberia, the transition time from the Bronze Age to the early Iron Age shows the possibility of some of the methods of the natural sciences: petrography, X-ray powder diffraction (XRD) and thermal analysis. It is concluded that the use of physical and chemical methods for the study of ancient ceramics can significantly enhance the ability of research material compared to traditional methods and increase the level of evidence and the objectivity for the historical and cultural situation.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):122-127
pages 122-127 views

EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES ON ERTEBØLLE POTTERY: FOOD PREPARATION AND RADIOCARBON DATING

Philippsen B.

Abstract

This article summarizes my experimental and archaeological research about the earliest pottery in Northern Germany and Denmark, belonging to the Ertebølle culture, a Late Mesolithic hunter-gatherer-fisher culture. I will present firing and cooking experiments with copies of Ertebølle pottery and how a reference collection of experimental food crusts can be used to understand issues of radiocarbon reservoir effects and stable isotope measurements in food crusts. It will be shown that cooking food resources with a reservoir age, such as marine or freshwater fish, leads to the same reservoir age in the pottery. The results from the experiments will be compared to the archaeological record. I will discuss the implications of the experimental studies for radiocarbon dating of archaeological pottery, and for studies of style and function of ceramics.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):128-132
pages 128-132 views

THE COMBINATION OF DIFFERENT MODELING TECHNIQUES TO ARCHAEOLOGICAL VESSELS, DATA TRASOLOGICAL EXPERIMENTAL AND ETHNOGRAPHIC

Poplevko G.N.

Abstract

The study of technological methods of manufacturing ceramic materials is considered by the example of the Maikop culture in the North Caucasus and the data of ethnography. As an example the experimental simulation of round-the Maikop culture vessels, made by several methods. Trasological study of the structure of the test pieces of ceramics in the fracture showed that it is possible to determine the area of joints tapes. External and internal ceramic surface smoothed, but you can define a manual molding of thin lines multidirectional polishing. Manual molding can also be defined and some fragments of ceramics on its inner surface, to maintain the following bands modeling and smoothing the surface of joints by hand. Some fragments have a very dense homogeneous structure, which is formed as a result of receiving use knockout, using a wooden spatula or forging of vessel walls using stone tools on both sides. Some techniques for making vascular managed modeled by experiments. Research data on the manufacturing technique of ethnography round bottom flask showed that the modeling techniques such vessels much more. The paper presents the archaeological, ethnographic and experimental data on manufacturing as the flat-bottomed and round bottom flask using a technique manual molding, punch and forging (forging the walls of stone tools from both sides). Recently, using the technique of punch it was carried out a series of experiments on modeling the round bottom flask. Trasological study technology of round bottomed flask with two knockout techniques, not previously considered.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):132-142
pages 132-142 views

FIRST IMPRESSIONS OF EARLY NEOLITHIC RUSSIAN POTTERY TECHNOLOGY

Spataro M.

Abstract

Ceramics appeared in southern Russia at about the same time as in southern Europe, at ca. 6000 cal BC, but whilst pottery was introduced into southern Europe, together with plant and animal domesticates, from southwest Asia, early Neolithic pottery in eastern Europe was probably developed locally by hunter-gatherers, or derived from other pre-agricultural societies in northern Eurasia. In this paper, four sherds from four different regions of central and southern Russia are analysed using the same methods previously employed in two large-scale research programmes on early Neolithic pottery from the Adriatic and the central Balkans. The four pots were made with different tempering agents and were generally low-fired, but while they may represent different technological traditions to the southern European pottery, the overall technical quality of the hunter-gatherer pottery is no less developed than that of the early farmers.

Samara Journal of Science. 2015;4(3):142-153
pages 142-153 views

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies