Aristotle’s definition of oligarchy and oligarchic regimes in Athens, 5th–4th centuries bc

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

Aristotle’s Politics contains a non-traditional and even unexpected definition of oligarchy that pictures it, unlike the conventional interpretation (which proceeded from the transparent etymology of the term itself), not as the ‘rule of the few’ but as the ‘rule of the wealthy’. Accordingly, one of the main signs of oligarchies for the philosopher is the property qualification. The article analyzes how the political practice of Athenian oligarchs correlated with these theoretical theses. It appears that the two stages of the oligarchic movement in Athens (late fifth century BC and late fourth century BC) substantially differ precisely in this regard. In the first case, the question of a qualification was not even raised, and an entirely different principle was applied: creation of a citizen body restricted in number (5000 in 411 BC, 3000 in 404 BC). As to the second case, they used the idea of qualification in its full sense (2000 drachmas in 322 BC, 1000 drachmas in 317 BC). So oligarchic regimes of the first period are closer to the traditional definition of oligarchy, whereas oligarchic regimes of the second period are closer to Aristotle’s definition (and were undoubtedly created under ideological influence of the Peripatetic school).

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Igor E. Surikov

Institute of World History of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Russian State University for the Humanities

Author for correspondence.
Email: isurikov@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-2603-6146

доктор исторических наук, главный научный сотрудник отдела сравнительного изучения древних цивилизаций, профессор кафедры истории и теории культуры факультета культурологии

Russian Federation, Moscow; Moscow

References

  1. Badian, E. 1995: The Ghost of Empire: Reflections on Athenian Foreign Policy in the Fourth Century BC. In: W. Eder (ed.), Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert v.Chr.: Vollendung oder Verfall einer Verfassungsform? Stuttgart, 79–106.
  2. Boulton, A.O. 2021: Democracy and Empire: The Athenian Invasion of Sicily, 415–413 BCE. Lanham.
  3. Bourriot, F. 1976: Recherches sur la nature du genos: Étude d’histoire sociale athénienne. Périodes archaïque et classique. Lille–Paris.
  4. Brock, R. 1989: Athenian Oligarchs: The Number Game. Journal of Hellenic Studies 109, 160–164.
  5. Brock, R., Hodkinson, S. 2000: Introduction: Alternatives to the Democratic Polis. In: R. Brock, S. Hodkinson (eds.), Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece. Oxford–New York, 1–32.
  6. Carawan, E. 2013: The Athenian Amnesty and Reconstructing the Law. Oxford.
  7. Danzig, G. 2014: The Use and Abuse of Critias: Conflicting Portraits in Plato and Xenophon. Classical Quarterly 64/2, 507–524.
  8. Davies, J.K. 1971: Athenian Propertied Families 600–300 B. C. Oxford.
  9. Davies, J.K. 2004: The Concept of the ‘Citizen’. In: S. Cataldi (ed.), Poleis e politeiai: Esperienze politiche, tradizioni litterarie, progetti costituzionali. Alessandria, 19–30.
  10. Day, J., Chambers, M. 1967: Aristotle’s History of Athenian Democracy. Amsterdam.
  11. Diggle, J. (ed.) 2004: Theophrastus: Characters. Cambridge.
  12. Dovatur, A.I. 1965: Politika i Politii Aristotelya [Aristotle’s Politics and Polities]. Moscow–Leningrad.
  13. Duke, G. 2020: Aristotle and Law: The Politics of Nomos. Cambridge.
  14. Finley, M.I. 1971: The Ancestral Constitution. Cambridge.
  15. Frank, J., Monoson, S.S. 2009: Lived Excellence in Aristotle’s Constitution of Athens: Why the Encomium of Theramenes Matters. In: S. Salkever (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek Political Thought. Cambridge, 243–270.
  16. Frolov, E.D. 2003: [Critias, Son of Callaischros, the Athenian, – a Sophist and Tyrant]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 4, 67–89.
  17. Gagarin, M. 2002: Antiphon the Athenian: Oratory, Law, and Justice in the Age of the Sophists. Austin.
  18. Gehrke, H.-J. 1978: Das Verhältnis von Politic und Philosophie im Werken des Demetrius von Phaleron. Chiron 8, 149–194.
  19. Giangiulio, M. 2018: Oligarchies of ‘Fixed Number’ or Citizen Bodies in the Making? In: A. Duplouy, R. W. Brock (eds.), Defining Citizenship in Archaic Greece. Oxford, 275–294.
  20. Gomme, A.W. 1986: The Population of Athens in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries B. C. Westport.
  21. Gottesman, A. 2020: The Sōphrosynē of Critias: Aristocratic Ethics after the Thirty Tyrants. In: D. C. Wolfsdorf (ed.), Early Greek Ethics. Oxford, 243–261.
  22. Hahm, D.E. 2009: The Mixed Constitution in Greek Thought. In: R. K. Balot (ed.), A Companion to Greek and Roman Political Thought. Oxford, 178–198.
  23. Hansen, M.H. 1993: Aristotle’s Alternative to the Sixfold Model of Constitutions. In: M. Piérart (éd.), Aristote et Athènes. Actes de la table ronde de l’Université de Fribourg, 23–25 mai 1991. Paris, 91–101.
  24. Hansen, M.H. 2004: Attika. In: M. H. Hansen, T. H. Nielsen (eds.), An Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis: An Investigation Conducted by the Copenhagen Polis Centre for the Danish National Research Foundation. Oxford, 624–642.
  25. Hansen, M.H. 2010: The Concepts of demos, ekklesia, and dikasterion in Classical Athens. Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 50, 499–536.
  26. Harding, P. 1977: Atthis and Politeia. Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 26/2, 148–160.
  27. Harris, E.M. 2019: Rev.: Simonton M. Classical Greek Oligarchy: A Political History. Journal of Hellenic Studies 139, 256–257.
  28. Heftner, H. 2001: Der oligarchische Umsturz des Jahres 411 v.Chr. und die Herrschaft der Vierhundert in Athen: Quellenkritische und historische Untersuchungen. Frankfurt am Main.
  29. Hornblower, S. 2006: Pindar and Kingship Theory. In: S. Lewis (ed.), Ancient Tyranny. Edinburgh, 151–163.
  30. Kennedy, G.A. 2003: Oratory. In: P. E. Easterling, B.M.W. Knox (eds.), The Cambridge History of Classical Literature. Vol. I. Greek Literature. Cambridge, 498–526.
  31. Krentz, P. 1982: The Thirty at Athens. Ithaca–London.
  32. Lehmann, G.A. 1995: Überlegungen zu den oligarchischen Machtergreifungen im Athen des 4. Jahrhunderts v.Chr. In: W. Eder (Hrsg.), Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert v.Chr.: Vollendung oder Verfall einer Verfassungsform? Akten eines Symposiums 3. –7. August 1992, Bellagio. Stuttgart, 139–150.
  33. Lehmann, G.A. 1997: Oligarchische Herrschaft im klassischen Athen: Zu den Krisen und Katastrophen der attischen Demokratie im 5. und 4. Jahrhundert v.Chr. Opladen.
  34. Lintott, A. 2000: Aristotle and the Mixed Constitution. In: R. Brock, S. Hodkinson (eds.), Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece. Oxford, 152–166.
  35. Loening, T.C. 1987: The Reconciliation Agreement of 403/2 B.C. in Athens: Its Content and Application. Stuttgart.
  36. Loraux, N. 1997: La cité divisée: L’oubli dans la mémoire d’Athènes. Paris.
  37. Marcaccini, C. 2013: Rivoluzione oligarchica o restaurazione della democrazia? I Cinquemilia, la πρόκρισις e la patrios politeia. Klio 95/2, 405–428.
  38. Marr, J.L., Rhodes, P.J. (eds.) 2015: The ‘Old Oligarch’: The Constitution of the Athenians Attributed to Xenophon. Oxford.
  39. Mitchell, L. 2006: Tyrannical Oligarchs at Athens. In: S. Lewis (ed.), Ancient Tyranny. Edinburgh, 178–187.
  40. Montanari, F. 2022: History of Ancient Greek Literature. Vol. I. The Archaic and Classical Ages. Berlin–Boston.
  41. Müller, S. 2017: Demetrios von Phaleron pompe und Demochares’ Kritik. In: H. Beck, B. Eckhardt, C. Michels, S. Richter (Hrsg.), Von Magna Graecia nach Asia Minor: Festschrift für Linda-Marie Günther zum 65. Geburtstag. Wiesbaden, 243–254.
  42. Nails, D. 2002: The People of Plato: A Prosopography of Plato and Other Socratics. Indianapolis–Cambridge.
  43. Osborne, R. 2003: Changing the Discourse. In: K. A. Morgan (ed.), Popular Tyranny: Sovereignty and Its Discontents in Ancient Greece. Austin, 251–272.
  44. Ostwald, M. 2000: Oligarchia: The Development of a Constitutional Form in Ancient Greece. Stuttgart.
  45. O’Sullivan, L. 2001: Philochorus, Pollux and the Nomophulakes of Demetrius of Phalerum. Journal of Hellenic Studies 121, 51–62.
  46. Piepenbrink, K. 2018: Demokratische Implikationen in der “Politik” des Aristoteles. In: I. Jordović, U. Walter (Hrsg.), Feindbild und Vorbild: Die athenische Demokratie und ihre intellektuellen Gegner. Berlin–Boston, 249–268.
  47. Poddighe, E. 2002: Nel segno di Antipatro: L’eclissi della democrazia ateniese dal 323/2 al 319/8 a.C. Roma.
  48. Poddighe, E. 2014: Aristotele, Atene e le metamorfosi dell’idea democratica: Da Solone a Pericle (594– 451 a.C.). Roma.
  49. Raaflaub, K.A., Ober, J., Wallace, R.W., Cartledge, P., Farrar, C. 2007: Origins of Democracy in Ancient Greece. Berkeley.
  50. Regan, R.J. (ed.) 2007: Commentary on Aristotle’s Politics. Indianapolis–Cambridge.
  51. Rhodes, P.J. 1985: A Commentary on the Aristotelian Athenaion Politeia. Oxford.
  52. Rhodes, P.J. 2000: Oligarchs in Athens. In: R. Brock, S. Hodkinson (eds.), Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece. Oxford, 119–136.
  53. Robinson, E.W. 1997: The First Democracies: Early Popular Government outside Athens. Stuttgart.
  54. Roller, D.W. 1989: Who Murdered Ephialtes? Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte 38/3, 257–266.
  55. Rubinstein, L. 2004: Ionia. In: M. H. Hansen, T. H. Nielsen (eds.), An Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis: An Investigation Conducted by the Copenhagen Polis Centre for the Danish National Research Foundation. Oxford, 1053–1107.
  56. Rutter, N.K. 2000: Syracusan Democracy: ‘Most Like the Athenian?’. In: R. Brock, S. Hodkinson (eds.), Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece. Oxford, 137–151.
  57. Saldutti, V. 2022: The Mixed Constitution of Demetrius Phalereus. Klio 104/1, 159–190.
  58. Saunders, T.J. 1991: Penal Law and Family Law in Plato’s Magnesia. In: M. Gagarin (ed.), Symposion 1990: Vorträge zur griechischen und hellenistischen Rechtsgeschichte (Pacific Grove, California, 24. –26. September 1990). Köln–Wien, 115–132.
  59. Scheibelreiter, P. 2013: Atheniensium vetus exemplum: Zum Paradigma einer antiken Amnestie. In: K. Harter-Uibopuu, F. Mitthof (Hrsg.), Vergeben und Vergessen? Amnestie in der Antike. Wien, 95–126.
  60. Schjøtt, P.O. 1906: Studien zur alten Geschichte 2: Die athenische Aristokratie. Christiania.
  61. Schmitz, W. 1995: Reiche und Gleiche: Timokratische Gliederung und demokratische Gleichheit der athenischen Bürger im 4. Jahrhundert v.Chr. In: W. Eder (Hrsg.), Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert v.Chr.: Vollendung oder Verfall einer Verfassungsform? Akten eines Symposiums 3. –7. August 1992, Bellagio. Stuttgart, 573–597.
  62. Schütrumpf, E. 1994: Aristotle on Sparta. In: A. Powell, S. Hodkinson (eds.), The Shadow of Sparta. London–New York, 323–345.
  63. Shear, J.L. 2011: Polis and Revolution: Responding to Oligarchy in Classical Athens. Cambridge.
  64. Simonton, M. 2017: Classical Greek Oligarchy: A Political History. Princeton.
  65. Simpson, P.L.P. 2013: Aristotle. In: H. Beck (ed.), A Companion to Ancient Greek Government. Oxford, 105–118.
  66. Stockton, D. 1982: The Death of Ephialtes. Classical Quarterly 32/1, 227–228.
  67. Strauss, B.S. 1993: Fathers and Sons in Athens: Ideology and Society in the Era of the Peloponnesian War. London.
  68. Surikov, I.E. 2018: Antichnaya Gretsiya: Politogenez, politicheskie i pravovye instituty (Opuscula selecta II) [Ancient Greece: State Formation, Political and Legal Institutions (Opuscula selecta II)]. Moscow.
  69. Surikov, I.E. 2021: [Towards the Chronology of the Life and Work of the Historian Hellanicus]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 81/4, 837–862.
  70. Surikov, I.E. 2022: [Athens in the Periods of Sedition and in the Periods of Stability: Some Comparative Observations]. In: F. A. Mikhailovsky (ed.), Drevniy mir: istoriya i arkheologiya. Sbornik nauchnykh statey [Ancient World: History and Archaeology. Collection of Scientific Articles]. Moscow, 218–228.
  71. Taylor, M.C. 2002: Implicating the demos: A Reading of Thucydides on the Rise of the Four Hundred. Journal of Hellenic Studies 122, 91–108.
  72. Ungern-Sternberg, J. von 2000: ‘Die Revolution frißt ihre eignen Kinder’: Kritias vs. Theramenes. In: L. Burckhardt, J. von Ungern-Sternberg (Hrsg.), Große Prozesse im antiken Athen. München, 144–156.
  73. Usher, S. 2007: Lysias and His Clients. In: E. Carawan (ed.), Oxford Readings in the Attic Orators. Oxford, 27–36.
  74. Wallace, R.W. 2013: Councils in Greek Oligarchies and Democracies. In: H. Beck (ed.), A Companion to Ancient Greek Government. Oxford, 191–204.
  75. Whitehead, D. 1993: 1–41, 42–69: A Tale of Two Politeiai. In: M. Piérart (éd.), Aristote et Athènes. Actes de la table ronde de l’Université de Fribourg, 23–25 mai 1991. Fribourg–Paris, 25–38.
  76. Williams, J. 1997: Ideology and the Constitution of Demetrius of Phalerum. In: C. D. Hamilton, P. Krentz (eds.), Polis and Polemos: Essays on Politics, War and History in Ancient Greece in Honor of Donald Kagan. Claremont, 327–346.
  77. Wolpert, A. 2006: The Violence of the Thirty Tyrants. In: S. Lewis (ed.), Ancient Tyranny. Edinburgh, 213–223.
  78. Wolpert, A. 2017: Thucydides on the Four Hundred and the Fall of Athens. In: R. K. Balot, S. Forsdyke, E. Foster (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Thucydides. Oxford, 179–191.
  79. Wolpert, A. 2019: Xenophon on the Violence of the Thirty. In: A. Kapellos (ed.), Xenophon on Violence. Berlin–Boston, 169–187.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download

Copyright (c) 2024 Russian Academy of Sciences