On Docetic Christology in Early Christianity. Pt. 3.1

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

According to the doctrine of the so-called docetic Christology, the earthly Jesus and the heavenly Christ were two different persons; it was Jesus who suffered on the cross, whereas Christ just entered Jesus’ body for a while and abandoned it before his death on the cross; consequently, the suffering of Christ was mere appearance. Based on some passages from Gnostic texts containing examples of docetic Christology, the author attempts here to trace the origin of that concept, starting with the New Testament (Pt. 1: Synoptic Gospels); in previous parts of the article (Pt. 2.1; 2.2; 2.3; 2.4), he analyzed such Paul’s passages as Rom. 1.3–4, Gal. 4.4–7, 1Cor 8.4–6, Phlp. 2.5–11, Col 1.15–20; in this part he is dealing with the writings of the so-called Johannine corpus, i.e., John and 1–2 John. To be continued.

About the authors

Alexander L. Khosroyev

Institute of Oriental Manuscripts Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: akhos@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-8406-8720

Dr. Sci. (History), Researcher-in-Chief of the Department of Middle Eastern and Near Eastern Studies

Russian Federation, 18, Emb. Dvortsovaya 191186, St. Petersburg

References

  1. Anderson, Paul N. Christology of the Fourth Gospel: Its Unity and Disunity in the Light of John 6. Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 1996 (WUNT, 2. Reihe 78) (in English).
  2. Ashton, John. Understanding the Fourth Gospel. 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007 (in English).
  3. Baur, Ferdinand Christian. Die christliche Gnosis oder die christliche Religions-Philosophie in ihrer geschichlichen Entwicklung. Tübingen: C.F. Osiander, 1835 (in German).
  4. Beasley-Murray, George R. John. Waco: Word Books, Publisher, 1987 (WBC, 36) (in English).
  5. Blass, Friedrich & Debrunner, Albert. Grammatik des neutestamentlichen Griechisch. Bearb. von
  6. R. Rehkopf. 17. Aufl. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1990 (in German).
  7. Böcher, Otto. “Das Verhältnis der Apokalypse des Johannes zum Evangelium des Johannes”. In: L’Apocalypse johannique et l’Apocalyptique dans le Nouveau Testament. Ed. par J. Lambrecht. Gembloux: J. Duculot, 1980, pp. 289–300 (BETL, 53) (in German).
  8. Boer, Martinus C. de. “Jesus the Baptizer: 1 John 5.5–8 and the Gospel of John”. JBL, 1988, vol. 107, pp. 87–106 (in English).
  9. Boer, Martinus C. de. “The Death of Jesus and His Coming in the Flesh (1 John 4.2)”. NT, 1991, vol. 33, pp. 326–346 (in English).
  10. Braun, Herbert. “Literar-Analyse und theologische Schichtung im ersten Johannesbrief”. ZThK, 1951, vol. 48, pp. 262–292 (in German).
  11. Brooke, A.E. A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Johannine Epistles. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1912 (in English).
  12. Brown, Raymond E. “Does the New Testament Call Jesus God”. TS, 1965, vol. 26, pp. 545–573 (in English).
  13. Brown, Raymond E. The Gospel according to John. Introduction, Translation, and Notes. Vol. 1–2. New York: Doubleday & Company, 1966, 1970 (Anchor Bible, 29, 29a) (in English).
  14. Brown, Raymond E. The Epistles of John. Translated with Introduction, Notes and Commentary. New York: Doubleday, 1982 (Anchor Bible, 30) (in English).
  15. Brox, Norbert. “ ‘Doketismus’ — eine Problemanzeige”. ZKG, 1984, vol. 95, pp. 301–314 (in German).
  16. Bultmann, Rudolph. Theology of the New Testament. Vol. 1. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1951 (in English).
  17. Charles, Robert Henry. A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Revelation of St. John with Introduction, Notes, and Indices, also the Greek Text and English Translation. Vol. 1–2. Edinburg: T&T Clark, 1920 (in English).
  18. Dodd, Charles Harold. The Johannine Epistles. New York [et al.]: Harper & Row, Publ., 1946 (The Moffat NT Commentary) (in English).
  19. Donahue, Paul J. “Jewish Christianity in the Letters of Ignatius of Antioch”. VC, 1978, vol. 32, pp. 81–93 (in English).
  20. Ehrman, Bart D. “1 John 4.3 and the Orthodox Corruption of Scripture”. In: Ehrman B.D. Studies in the Textual Criticism of the New Testament. Leiden–Boston: Brill, 2006 (in English).
  21. Goulder, Michael D. “Ignatius’s ‘Docetists’ ”. VC, 1999, vol. 53, pp. 16–30 (in English).
  22. Grillmeier, Alois. Jesus der Christus im Glauben der Kirche. Bd. 1: Von der Apostolischen Zeit bis zum Konzil von Chalkedon (451). 3. verb. u. erg. Aufl. Freiburg et al.: Herder, 1990 (in German).
  23. Haenchen, Ernst. Commentary on the Gospel of John. Chapters 1–6. Transl. et ed. by R.W. Funk. Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1984 (in English).
  24. Hamerton-Kelly, Robert G. A Study of the Idea of Pre-Existence in the New Testament. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1973 (SNTS, Monograph Ser. 21) (in English).
  25. Harris, Murray J. Jesus as God. The New Testament Use of Theos in Reference to Jesus. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1992 (in English).
  26. Howard, Wilbert Francis. “The Common Authorship of the Johannine Gospel and Epistles”. JTS, 1947, vol. 48, pp. 12–25 (in English).
  27. Jensen, Matthew David. “Jesus ‘Coming’ in the Flesh”. NT, 2014, vol. 56, pp. 310–312 (in English).
  28. Johnson, Luke Timothy. The Real Jesus. The Misguided Quest for the Historical Jesus and the Truth of the Traditional Gospels. San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1996 (in English).
  29. Kaestli, Jean-Daniel. “Valentinisme italien et valentinisme oriental: leur divergences à propos de la nature du corps de Jésus. Rediscovery of Gnosticism”. In: Proceedings of the Intern. Conf. on Gnosticism at Yale New Haven, March 28–31, 1978. Vol. 1: The School of Valentinus. Ed. by B. Layton. Leiden: Brill, 1980, pp. 391–403 (in French).
  30. Keener, G.S. The Gospel of John. A Commentary. Vol. I. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2003 (in English).
  31. Kelly, John N.D. Early Christian Doctrines. 5 rev. ed. London: Adam & Charles Black, 1980 (in English).
  32. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “Poslanie Petra Filippu (NHC VIII.2.132.10–140.27; CodTch 1.1–9.17). Vvedenie, perevod, kommentarii” [Letter of Peter to Philip (NHC VIII.2.132.10–140.27; CodTch 1.1–9.17). Introduction, Translation, Comments]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2014, vol. 11, no. 1 (iss. 20), pp. 5–30 (in Russian).
  33. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. Drugoje blagovestie II. Hristianskie gnostiki II–III vv.: ikh vera i sochineniia [A Different Gospel II. Christian Gnostics of the 2–3 Centuries: Their Belief and Texts]. St. Petersburg: Kontrast, 2016 (in Russian).
  34. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “O slove èvkM (loutrÒn? b£ptisma?) in Treat. Seth. 58.15–16 (NHC VII.2) i o rannekhristianskom kreshchenii voobshche. 4” [On the Word èvkM in Treat. Seth. Pt. 4]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2018, vol. 15, no. 3 (iss. 34), pp. 16–36 (in Russian).
  35. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “Doketicheskaia khristologiia v rannem khristianstve. 1” [Docetic Christology in Early Christianity. Pt. 1]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2019, vol. 16, no. 3 (iss. 38), pp. 27–53.
  36. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “Doketicheskaia khristologiia v rannem khristianstve. 2.1” [Docetic Christology in Early Christianity. Pt. 2.1]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2020, vol. 17, no. 4 (iss. 43), pp. 33–51 (in Russian).
  37. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “Doketicheskaia khristologiia v rannem khristianstve. 2.2” [Docetic Christology in Early Christianity. Pt. 2.2]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2021, vol. 18, no. 2 (iss. 45), pp. 24–35 (in Russian).
  38. Khosroyev, Alexandr L. “Doketicheskaia khristologiia v rannem khristianstve. 2.3” [Docetic Christology in Early Christianity. Pt. 2.3]. Pis’mennye pamiatniki Vostoka, 2021, vol. 18, no. 4 (iss. 47), pp. 31–52 (in Russian).
  39. Kinlaw, Pamela. The Christ is Jesus. Metamorphosis, Possession, and Johannine Christology. Atlanta: SBL, 2005 (Academia Biblica, 18) (in English).
  40. Klauck, Hans-Josef. Der erste Johannesbrief. Zürich [et al.]: Benziger, 1991 (EKK, XXIII/1) (in German).
  41. Koester, Craig R. Revelation. A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2014 (The Anchor Yale Bible, 38A) (in English).
  42. Kümmel, Werner Georg. Introduction to the New Testament. London: SCM Press Ltd, 1970 (in English).
  43. Kunath, Friederik. Die Präexistenz Jesu im Johannesevangelium. Struktur und Theologie eines johannischen Motivs. Berlin–Boston: Walter de Gruyter, 2016 (BZNW, 212) (in German).
  44. Kysar, Robert. “The Fourth Gospel. A Report on Recent Research”. ANRW, 1985, vol. II, no. 25(3), pp. 2389–2480 (in English).
  45. Kysar, Robert. Voyages with John: Charting the Fourth Gospel. Waco: Baylor University Press, 2005 (in English).
  46. Lieu, Judith. The Theology of the Johannine Epistles. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991 (in English).
  47. Lindars, Barnabas. The Gospel of John. Grand Rapids: W.B. Eerdmans, 1986 (in English).
  48. Lohmeyer, Ernst. Die Offenbarung des Johannes. Tübingen: Verl. J.C.B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 1926 (in German).
  49. Manson, Thomas Walter. Studies in the Gospels and Epistles. Ed. by M. Black. Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1962 (in English).
  50. Marshall I. Howard. The Epistles of John. Grand Rapids: W.B. Eerdmans, 1978 (in English).
  51. Marshall I. Howard. The New Testament Theology. Many Witnesses, One Gospel. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 2004 (in English).
  52. Martyn, J. Louis. History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel. London: Westminster John Knox Press, 2003 (in English).
  53. Mastin B.A. “A Neglected Feature of the Christology of the Fourth Gospel”. NTS, 1975, vol. 22, pp. 32–51 (in English).
  54. Menken, Maarten J.J. “The Opponents in the Johannine Epistles. Fact or Fiction?” In: Empsychoi Logoi. Religious Innovation in Antiquity. Studies in Honour of P.W. van der Horst. Ed. by A. Houtman [et al.]. Leiden–Boston: Brill, 2008, pp. 191–210 (in English).
  55. Menken, Maarten J.J. “The Secessionists of the Johannine Epistles and Docetism”. In: Docetism in Early Church. The Quest for an Elusive Phenomenon / Ed. by J. Verheyden [et al.]. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2018 (WUNT, 402), pp. 125–142 (in English).
  56. Minear, Paul S. “The Idea of Incarnation in First John”. Interpretation, 1970, vol. 24, pp. 291–302 (in English).
  57. Moffatt, James. An Introduction to the Literature of the New Testament. New York: Charles Scribners Sons, 1921 (in English).
  58. Molland, Einar. “The Heretics Combated by Ignatius of Antioch”. JEH, 1954, vol. 5, pp. 1–6 (in English).
  59. Morris, Leon. The Gospel according to John. The English Text with Introduction, Exposition and Notes. Grand Rapids: W.B. Eerdmans, 1971 (in English).
  60. Munier, Charles. “Où en est la question d’Ignace d’Antioche? Bilan d’un siècle de recherches 1870–1988”. ANRW, 1993, vol. II, no. 27(1), pp. 359–484 (in French).
  61. Painter, John. “The ‘Opponents’ in 1 John”. NTS, 1986, vol. 32, pp. 48–71 (in English).
  62. Parker, Pierson. “Two Editions of John”. JBL, 1956, vol. 75, pp. 303–314 (in English).
  63. Paulsen, David L. “Early Christian Belief in a Corporeal Deity: Origen and Augustine as Reluctant Witnesses”. HTR, 1990, vol. 83, pp. 105–116 (in English).
  64. Paulsen, Henning. Studien zur Theologie des Ignatius von Antiochien. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1978 (in German).
  65. Pollard, T.E. Johannine Christology and the Early Church. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970 (SNTS, Monograph Ser., 13) (in English).
  66. Porter, Stanley E. “The Date of John’s Gospel and Its Origin”. In: The Origins of John’s Gospel. Vol. 2. Ed. by S.E. Porter [et al]. Leiden: Brill, 2016, pp. 11–29 (in English).
  67. Prigent, Pierre. “L’hérésie asiate et l’église confessante: de l’Apocalypse à Ignace”. VC, 1977, vol. 31, pp. 1–22 (in French).
  68. Reim, Günter. “Jesus as God in the Fourth Gospel: The Old Testament Background”. NTS, 1984, vol. 30, pp. 158–160 (in English).
  69. Robinson, John A.T. “The Destination and Purpose of the Johannine Epistles”. NTS, 1961, vol. 7,
  70. pp. 56–65 (in English).
  71. Schnackenburg, Rudolf. The Gospel According to St. John. Vol. 1–2. Transl. K. Smyth. London: Burns & Oates, 1968 (in English).
  72. Schnackenburg, Rudolf. Die Johannesbriefe. 7. Auflage. Freiburg [et al.]: Herder, 1984 (in German).
  73. Schnelle, Udo. Einleitung in das Neue Testament. 5. Aufl. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2005 (in German).
  74. Schnelle, Udo. Theology of the New Testament. Transl. by M.E. Boring. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2009 (in English).
  75. Schnelle, Udo. “Die Reihenfolge der johanneischen Schriften”. NTS, 2010, vol. 57, pp. 91–113 (in German).
  76. Schoedel, William R. Die Briefe des Ignatius von Antiochien: ein Kommentar. Aus Engl. übers. von G. Koester. München: Kaiser, 1990 (in German).
  77. Schulz, Siegfried. Das Evangelium nach Johannes. 5. Aufl. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1987 (NTD, Bd. 4) (in German).
  78. Schweitzer, Albert. Geschichte der Paulinischen Forschung von der Reformation bis auf die Gegenwart. Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck), 1911 (in German).
  79. Slusser, Michael. “Docetism: A Historical Definition”. Second Century, 1981, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 163–172 (in English).
  80. Smalley, Stephen S. 1, 2, 3 John. Dallas: Word Inc., 1984 (WBC, 51) (in English).
  81. Smith, D. Moody. The Theology of the Gospel of John. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995 (in English).
  82. Stewart, Alistair C. “Ignatius’ ‘Docetists’: A Survey of Opinions and Some Modest Suggestions”. In: Docetism in Early Church. The Quest for an Elusive Phenomenon / Ed. by J. Verheyden [et al.]. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2018 (WUNT, 402), pp. 143–174 (in English).
  83. Strecker, Georg. “Die Anfänge der johannischen Schule”. NTS, 1986, vol. 32, pp. 31–47 (in German).
  84. Strecker, Georg. The Johannine Letters. A Commentary on 1, 2 and 3 John. Transl. by L.M. Maloney. Ed. by H. Attridge. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1996 (in English).
  85. Streett, Daniel R. They Went out from Us. The Identity of the Opponents in First John. Berlin–New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2011 (BZNW, 177) (in English).
  86. Stroumsa, Gedaliahu. “The Incorporeality of God. Context and Implication of Origen’s Position”. Religion, 1983, vol. 13, pp. 345–358 (in English).
  87. Sumney, Jerry L. “Those Who ‘Ignorantly Deny Him’: The Opponents of Ignatius”. JECS, 1993, vol. 1, pp. 345–365 (in English).
  88. Taylor, Vincent. “Does the New Testament Call Jesus God?” ExpT, 1962, vol. 73, pp. 116–118 (in English).
  89. Thyen, Hartwig. “Johannesbriefe”. TRE, 1988, vol. 17, pp. 186–200 (in German).
  90. Vielhauer, Philipp. Geschichte der urchristlichen Literatur. Einleitung in das Neue Testament, die Apokryphen und die Apostolischen Väter. Berlin–New York: Walter de Gruyter, 1975 (in German).
  91. Vorster, Willem Stephanus. Heterodoxy in 1 John // Neotestamentica, 1975, vol. 9, pp. 87–97 (in English).
  92. Wainwright, A.W. “The Cofession ‘Jesus is God’ in the New Testament”. SJT, 1957, vol. 10, pp. 274–299 (in English).
  93. Wahlde, Urban C. von. The Johannine Commandments. 1 John and the Struggle for the Johannine Tradition. New York: Paulist Press, 1990 (in English).
  94. Wahlde, Urban C. von. Gnosticism, Docetism, and the Judaisms of the First Century. The Search for the Wider Context of the Johannine Literature and Why It Matters. London [et al.]: Bloomsbury, 2015 (in English).
  95. Weigandt, Peter. Der Doketismus im Urchristentum und in der theologischen Entwicklung des zweiten Jahrhunderts. Inaug.-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Würde eines Doktors der evang.-theol. Fakultät der Ruprecht-Karl-Uni. zu Heidelberg, 1961 (in German).
  96. Wellhausen, Julius. Erweiterungen und Änderungen im vierten Evangelium. Berlin: Georg Reimer, 1907 (in German).
  97. Wengst, Klaus. “Probleme der Johannesbriefe”. ANRW, 1988, vol. II, no. 25(3), pp. 3753–3772 (in German).
  98. Wengst, Klaus. Der erste, zweite und dritte Brief des Johannes. 2. Aufl. Gütersloh: Gütersloher Verlagshaus Gerd Mohn, 1990 (in German).
  99. Whealey, Alice. “Pseudo-Justin’s De resurrectione: Athenagoras or Hippolytus?”. VC, 2006, vol. 60, pp. 420–430 (in English).
  100. Wilckens, Ulrich. Das Evangelium nach Johannes. Übersetzt und erklärt. 2. durchges. Aufl. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2000 (in German).
  101. Wisse, Frederick. “The Use of Early Christian Literature as Evidence for Inner Diversity and Conflict”. In: Nag Hammadi, Gnosticism, and Early Christianity. Ed. by Ch.W. Hedrick and R. Hodgson, Jr. Peabody: Hendrickson Publ., 1986, pp. 177–190 (in English).
  102. Yamauchi, Edwin M. “The Crucifixion and Docetic Christology”. Concordia Theological Quarterly, 1982, vol. 46, pp. 1–20 (in English).

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies