The Principle of the Social State in the Russian Federation: The Evolution of the Content and Application in the Decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Abstract

Purpose. To analyze the evolution of the principle of the social state, various interpretations of the concept of the social state depending on the level of social responsibility of the state to the population, signs of the social state. Tasks. To analyze the interpretation of the Russian Federation as a social state. To reveal the content of the main features of the welfare state. Consider the principles-requirements of the welfare state. To reveal the features of modern trends in improving legislation and the mechanism of protection of social rights. To analyze the doctrine of the welfare state from the perspective of the concept of the «welfare state»; constitutional principles and norms defining the requirements of the welfare state and social human rights. Conclusions: The interpretation of the Russian Federation as a social state is analyzed in detail, an incomplete characteristic of the main features of the social state is revealed, an additional criterion based on the principle of social justice is proposed. The basic principles and requirements of the welfare state are substantiated. It is noted that the principles and requirements of the welfare state are expanded by the new Article 75.1 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, where the interpretation of the welfare state is given through two main criteria: the creation by the state of conditions ensuring a decent life and free human development. As one of the main criteria of the welfare state, the legal norms regulating social human rights and the role of the state in finding a balance between a person's social activity and his ability to satisfy his social needs are noted. The conclusion is formulated about the existence of a wide range of social rights, and their security is noted as a key indicator of the implementation of the principle of the welfare state and the resulting principles-requirements. Modern trends in improving legislation and law enforcement are mainly aimed at increasing the effectiveness of the protection of social human rights in their violation, where the main role is assigned to the judiciary. The authors noted that to date, there are no unified views in the science of constitutional law on the admissibility, limits and conditions of judicial protection of social rights. First of all, the resolution of this situation depends on the place of social rights in the human rights system, the normative content of each specific right, their legal nature, as well as the scope of the powers of judicial bodies to invade the sphere of activity of legislative and executive bodies of state power. The concept, legal nature, normative content of the constitutional principle of the social state and social rights are investigated; examples from the practice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation on the protection of social rights are given. Attention is drawn to the integration application of the principle of the social state in unity with other principles of law (free development, decent life, equality (equality), justice (social justice), legal certainty, proportionality (proportionality of restrictions on rights and freedoms), balance of public and private interests, etc.).

About the authors

Irina A. Umnova-Koniukhova

Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice

Email: ikonyukhova@yandex.ru
Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Director of Constitutional Law Studies at the Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice Moscow, Russian Federation

Elena D. Kostyleva

Сenter of Justice Research in the Russian State University of Justice

Email: helen161969@rambler.ru
Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Senior Researcher of the department constitutional and legal research Moscow, Russian Federation

References

  1. Andrichenko L.V. Problems of judicial protection of social rights of citizens of the Russian Federation // Journal of Russian Law. -2016. -No. 9. -pp. 5-17.
  2. Aristov E.V. The social state in the context of social rights // Law and law. -2020. -No. 5. -pp. 15-19.
  3. Vasilevich S.G. The concept and essence of the social state//Bulletin of Economic Security. -2017. -No. 3. -pp. 95-100.
  4. Goncharov P.K. The social state / The Sociological Encyclopedia: In 2-V. V. 1. Moscow: Mysl, 2003.
  5. Zorkin V. D. The social state in Russia: problems of implementation // Comparative Constitutional review. -2008. -№ 1 (62). -p. 50.
  6. Locke J. Two treatises on the board / Op.: In 3 vols. 3. M.: Thought, 1998.
  7. Laptev G.S. The role of the European Court of Human Rights in protecting the social rights of citizens of the Russian Federation // Bulletin of Omsk University. The series «Law». -2009. -№ 1 (18). -Pp. 69-71.
  8. Kochetkova L.N. The social state: goals and functions // Socio-humanitarian knowledge. 2008. No. 3. pp. 68-79.
  9. Miloserdov A. S. Constitutional and legal foundations of the formation of a social state in Russia // Legal science. -2017. -No. 6. -pp. 19-23.
  10. Sidorina T.Y. Operation welfare state: has the welfare state solved the problems of an ideal state? // Terra economicus. -2012. -Vol.10, No. 3. -pp. 84-99.
  11. Chirkin V. E. Social justice as a factor of sustainable development of society (constitutional issues) // Actual problems of economics and law. -2017. -Vol. 11, No. 1. -pp. 89-97.
  12. Ana Gómez Heredero Social security as a human right// Human rights files, No. 23. -Council of Europe Publishing, 2007. -P. 39.
  13. Dixon R., Landau D. Transnational constitutionalism and a limited doctrine of unconstitutional constitutional amendment//International journal of constitutional law. 2015. № 13(3). P. 606-638.
  14. Feldman S., Steenbergen M.R. The Humanitarian Foundation of Public Support for Social Welfare // American Journal of Political Science. 2001. Vol. 45. No. 3.
  15. Gelissen J. Popular support for institutionalized solidarity: a comparison between European welfare states // International Journal of Social Welfare. 2000.Vol. 9. No. 4.
  16. Hasenfeld Y., Raferty J.A. The Determinants of Public Attitudes Toward the Welfare State // Social Forces. 1989. Vol. 67. No. 4.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML


This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies