FROM DEMONIZATION TO VENERATION: JOAN OF ARC IN ENGLAND IN THE 15th–19th CENTURIES (ORGELFINGER G. JOAN OF ARC IN THE ENGLISH IMAGINATION, 1429–1829. University Park: the Pennsylvania State University Press, 2019. 230 p.)
- Authors: Togoeva O.I1
-
Affiliations:
- Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences
- Issue: Vol 83, No 1 (2022)
- Pages: 234-242
- Section: Articles
- URL: https://journals.eco-vector.com/0131-8780/article/view/628682
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.7868/S0131878022010147
- ID: 628682
Cite item
Abstract
The article undertakes a detailed analysis of the first monographic study devoted to the problem of describing the history of Joan of Arc in the English sources of the 15th–19th centuries. The book of Gail Orgelfinger, to a certain extent, filled a crucial gap in the études johanniques that existed for several centuries. It analyzed texts of various genres: official correspondence, chronicles, historical writings, fiction and poetry. On this material, the author tries to demonstrate how the attitude towards Joan of Arc of her yesterday’s enemies has changed, what epithets they awarded her, what figures of silence and fiction they used describing the events of the Hundred Years’ War, how they argued their position. Despite the significant shortcomings noted in the review, the appearance of this monograph can be welcomed: it will serve as a basis (both in source studies and in historiographical terms) for subsequent studies of the proposed issues.
About the authors
O. I Togoeva
Institute of World History, Russian Academy of Sciences
Email: togoeva@yandex.ru
References
- Калмыкова Е.В. Образ войны в исторических представлениях англичан позднего Средневековья. М., 2010.
- Тогоева О.И. Еретичка, ставшая святой: Две жизни Жанны д’Арк. М.; СПб., 2016.
- Тогоева О.И. Первый памятник Жанне д’Арк и проблема сакральности ее образа во Франции Нового / Вестник РГГУ. Серия «История. Филология. Культурология. Востоковедение». 2018. № 7 (40). С. 104–125.
- Clermont-Ferrand M. Joan of Arc and the English Chroniclers: Monstrous Presence and Problematic Absence in The Chronicle of London, The Chronicle of William of Worcester, and An English Chronicle, 1377–1461 // Medieval Chronicle. 2001. T. 7. P. 151–165.
- Contamine Ph., Bouzy O., Hélary X. Jeanne d’Arc: Histoire et dictionnaire. P., 2012.
- Heimann N.M. Joan of Arc in French Art and Culture (1700–1855): From Satire to Sanctity. Aldershot, 2005.
- Krumeich G. Jeanne d’Arc à travers l’Histoire. P., 1993.
- Lanéry d’Arc P. Livre d’or de Jeanne d’Arc: Bibliographie raisonnée et analitique des ouvrages relatifs à Jeanne d’Arc. P., 1894.
- Orgelfinger G. Joan of Arc in the English Imagination, 1429–1829. University Park, 2019.
- Sullivan K. La justice magnanime des anglais: Les biographes brittaniques de Jeanne d’Arc // Jeanne d’Arc entre les nations / Etudes réunies par T. Hoenselaars et J. Koopmans. Amsterdam, 1998. P. 115–132.
- Warren N.B. French women and English men: Joan of Arc, Margaret of Anjou, and Christine de Pizan in England, 1445–1540 // Exemplaria. 2004. Т. 16 (2). Р. 405–436.
- Waugh W.T. Joan of Arc in English Sources of the Fifteenth Century // Historical Essays in Honor of James Tait / ed. by J.G. Edwards, V.H. Galbraith, E.F. Jacob. Manchester, 1933. P. 387–398.
- Winock M. Jeanne d’Arc // Les lieux de mémoire / Sous la dir. de P. Nora. III: Les France. T. 3: De l’archive à l’emblème. P., 1992. P. 675–733.
Supplementary files
