About industry accessories housing legal relations

Purpose: since housing legal relations are a classification group in the classification of legal relations according to a sectoral criterion, the problem of understanding them is essentially the problem of determining their legal status. Its solution issue is closely related to the solution of another equally significant issue - determining the place of housing law in the system of branches of Russian law. Both of these issues are debatable in the contemporary legal literary and need to be better understood. The opinions of legal experts about the role of housing law in the system of Russian law range from the recognition of housing law by the institution of civil law to providing it the status of a branch of law - either complex or non-complex (“independent”). Scientists who consider housing law as an institution of civil law solve the issue of determining the status of housing legal relations by recognizing them as civil legal relations, but at the same time, they cannot explain why such an institution of civil law as housing law has administrative legal relations. Scientists who address housing law to be a complex branch of law solve the issue of determining the status of housing legal relations by recognizing them as complex ("collective") legal relations, but concurrently they are not able to explain how the multi-branch powers "coexist" in the content of the housing legal relationship. Scientists who consider housing law a non-complex ("independent") branch of law, decide the issue of determining the status of housing legal relations either by creating a construction of "public-private legal relations", or by differentiating according to the content criterion of legal relations arising from residential premises into "legal relations in the housing sphere » and the actual housing legal relationship. As a result The article substantiates the conclusions that, firstly, neither the concept of recognition of housing law by the institution of civil law, nor the concept of recognition of housing law as a complex branch of law can be accepted due to immanent contradictions, and secondly, the construction of "public-private relations" should be rejected due to its dubious theoretical nature and, thirdly, the concept of recognition as housing only those legal relations arising from residential premises that have their own specific content that are not proper in either civil or administrative legal relations deserves support.

legal status of housing law, branch classification of legal relations, housing legal relations, content of housing legal relations