Does Russia need a domestic violence law?

封面

如何引用文章

全文:

开放存取 开放存取
受限制的访问 ##reader.subscriptionAccessGranted##
受限制的访问 订阅存取

详细

In Russia, there has been a long-standing effort to develop a special law against domestic violence, as well as a debate on the need for such a law. In 2016, such a bill was sent to the State Duma but received negative feedback and was withdrawn. In 2019, work on the adoption of such a law resumed and a draft was developed and posted on the official website of the Federation Council. However, this draft also received a lot of criticism. In this context, the author considered it important to address the issue and conduct an analysis. Objective: Analysis of the draft laws "On prevention of domestic violence in the Russian Federation" 2016 and 2019 in the context of the current legal regulation, international and foreign experience. Results: the author concluded that the existing legal regulation does not adequately address the issue of prevention of domestic violence and does not protect victims of such violence. A large number of measures which could help to solve this problem are absent in the Russian legal system.

全文:

受限制的访问

作者简介

Abdulkadyr Magomedov

Lomonosov Moscow State University

Email: abdulkadirmagomedov@gmail.com
postgraduate student at Criminal Law and Criminology Department, Faculty of Law Moscow, Russia

参考

  1. Aptikieva, L.Ya. Consequences of psychological violence for different age categories [Electronic resource] /L.Ya. Aptikieva // Bulletin of the Orenburg State University. 2020. N 1. Access mode: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/posledstviya-psihologicheskogo-nasiliya-dlya-raznyh-vozrastnyh-kategoriy
  2. Baranov, V.M. References (references) in lawmaking acts: technical and legal defects and ways to overcome their harmful consequences [Electronic resource] / V.M. Baranov // Journal of Russian Law. 2022. N 3. - Access mode: ATP "Consultant Plus"
  3. Baranov, P.P. Family as a constitutionally significant value // Bulletin of the Faculty of Law of the Southern Federal University. 2020. N 2. - P. 61
  4. Bachanova, V.V., Domestic violence against women in Russia: problem setting / V.V. Bachanova, T.P. Makashova // Victimology. 2021. N 4. - S. 293
  5. Borisova, L.V. Protection of the rights of citizens from violence in the family: the search for the optimal ratio of private and public interests [Electronic resource] / L.V. Borisova // Family and housing law. 2020. N 5. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  6. Vorontsov, S.A. On the prevention of corruption risks in the process of law-making / S.A. Vorontsov // Bulletin of the Faculty of Law of the Southern Federal University. 2020. N 2. - S. 18
  7. Golovko, L.V. Legal results - 2019 [Electronic resource] / L.V. Golovko // Law. 2020. N 1. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  8. Dozortseva, E.G. Delayed consequences of experienced domestic violence in women and girls [Electronic resource] / E.G. Dozortseva, M.A. Kachaeva, E.V. Nutskova // Psychology and Law. 2017. N 3. - Access mode: https://psyjournals.ru/psyandlaw/2017/n3/87537_full.shtml
  9. Dombrovsky, I.S. On the mental aspect of causing harm to human health [Electronic resource] / I.S. Dombrovsky // Bulletin of the St. Petersburg University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. 2012. N 4. - Access mode: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/o-psihicheskom-aspekte-prichineniya-vreda-zdorovyu-cheloveka
  10. Dunaeva, O.N. Overcoming Domestic Violence in Contemporary China. Law "On Combating Domestic Violence" (2016): preparation of the draft law and the first results of its application (2016-2021) (part 2) / O.N. Dunaeva // Victimology. 2021. N 4. S. 305
  11. Endoltseva, A.V. Protection of victims from domestic violent crimes: has everything been done in this direction? [Electronic resource] / A.V. Endoltseva // Magistrate. 2020. N 10. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  12. Zebnitskaya, A.K. On the issue of the procedure for obtaining a Protective Order (protective order) [Electronic resource] / A.K. Zebnitskaya // Magistrate. 2020. N 5. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  13. Zebnitskaya, A.K. Some issues of legal regulation of “domestic (domestic) violence in Russia and the USA” [Electronic resource] / A.K. Zebnitskaya // International criminal law and international justice. 2020. N 3. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  14. Zinovieva, O.P. The principle of voluntariness in the prevention of domestic violence: reality or fiction / O.P. Zinoviev // Bulletin of the Faculty of Law of the Southern Federal University. 2020. N 2. - S. 105
  15. Klimchuk, M.V. Separate measures for the prevention of violence against minors: a comparative legal aspect [Electronic resource] / M.V. Klimchuk // International criminal law and international justice. 2022. N 3. - Access mode: ATP "Consultant Plus"
  16. Koretsky, D.A. Family violence as an element of everyday crime / D.A. Koretsky // Bulletin of the Faculty of Law of the Southern Federal University. 2020. N 2. - S. 75
  17. Kosova, O.Yu. Prevention of violence or destruction of the family institution / O.Yu. Kosova // Socio-legal notebook. 2020. N 10. - S. 23
  18. Krutikhina, P.V. Decriminalization of domestic violence: three years later [Electronic resource] / P.V. Krutikhina // Law. 2019. N 12. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant plus"
  19. Moskaleva, E.N. Responsibility for mental torture in the family / E.N. Moskaleva // Bulletin of the Faculty of Law of the Southern Federal University. 2020. N 2. - S. 76
  20. Ravnyushkin, A.V. On the need to develop a national concept for the prevention of domestic violence in Russia / A.V. Ravnyushkin // Scientific Bulletin of the Omsk Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. 2021. N 3. - S. 230
  21. Rakhlina, E.V. Psychological work with men who use violence in intimate relationships. Experience of the psychologist of the St. Petersburg State Budgetary Institution "Center for Social Assistance to Families and Children" Aist "Pushkinsky District" [Electronic resource] / E.V. Rakhlin. - Access mode: http://www.homekid.ru/content/docs/izdaniya/serealnui_sbornik/vse-vupyski/v11/108-122.pdf (accessed 08/05/2022)
  22. Sergun, E.P. Conceptual foundations for the prevention of domestic violence in the Russian Federation / E.P. Sergun // Legal culture. 2017. N 4. - P. 81
  23. Sergun, E.P. Problems of legal regulation of the prevention of domestic violence in the Russian Federation / E.P. Sergun // Bulletin of the Russian Law Academy. 2017. N 4. - P. 71
  24. Timoshina, E.M. Theoretical and legal foundations of the concepts of "family violence" and "family violent crime" [Electronic resource] / E.M. Timoshina // Russian investigator. 2022. N 1. - Access mode: ATP "Consultant Plus"
  25. Schwabauer, A.V. Legal Opinion on the Draft Law “On the Prevention of Domestic Violence in the Russian Federation” / A.V. Schwabauer // Family and Fatherland. 2019. N 4. - P. 6
  26. Yausheva, A.D. Consequences of the decriminalization of beatings in the context of domestic violence [Electronic resource] / A.D. Yausheva // Administrative law and process. 2021. N 12. - Access mode: SPS "Consultant Plus"
  27. Mayaud Y. Infractions contre les personnes // Revue de science criminelle et de droit pénal compare. 2019. - N 3. - Режим доступа: https://www.cairn.info/revue-de-science-criminelle-et-de-droit-penal-compare-2019-3-page-613.htm
  28. Tarhini R. Le sort de la femme, auteur ou victime d’infractions sexuelles et/ou familiales en droit penal comparé français et libanais. Droit. Université Nancy 2, 2011. P. 367-368. - Режим доступа: https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-01749093

补充文件

附件文件
动作
1. JATS XML
下载
##common.cookie##