Structure of Public Danger: Correlation of the Corpus Delicti and Criminal Harm

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

Purpose of the study. The article deals with the problems of establishing the criminal law nature of public danger as a fundamental material feature of the general concept of a crime. The essence of the feature under consideration is characterized by two parameters: character and degree. The solution of the question of in what elements and signs of the corpus delicti the harm caused by the crime is expressed, determines the formation of the structure of the nature and degree of public danger. As a result, it becomes possible to build a theoretical model of the concept and structure of public danger, as well as to address the issue of intersectoral differentiation: whether the sign of public danger is characteristic only of crimes, or is inherent in offenses of other branches of law. The aim of the study is to build a theoretical model of the structure of public danger based on the correlation of the harm caused by the crime with the elements and signs of the corpus delicti. Findings. The harm caused by the crime is the result of the realization of public danger. With regard to the structure of the crime, a socially dangerous act (for formal and truncated crimes) or socially dangerous consequences (for material crimes), as signs of the objective side, are the amount of harm that is caused to the object of the crime. Thus, the structure of the nature of public danger and the degree of public danger is represented by two elements: the object and the objective side of the corpus delicti. The quantitative expression of the harm caused by a crime, or the threat of its infliction, is found in the objective side of the corpus delicti and the mandatory (socially dangerous act or socially dangerous consequences that have occurred) and optional features (time, place, method, environment of the commission of the crime) that characterize it, which form the degree of social danger. The object of the crime and its features determine the severity of the harm caused by the crime and form the structure of the nature of the public danger. At the same time, the nature and degree of public danger are closely interrelated. The significance of the committed act and the resulting socially dangerous consequences, which are structural components of the degree of social danger, is determined by the immediate object and the features that characterize it - forming the nature of public danger. The nature and degree of public danger of a crime of a certain type, provided for in the disposition of the criminal law norm, have a typical content. With regard to a specific crime, it becomes possible to indicate the committed socially dangerous act, the exact size of the socially dangerous consequences that have occurred and optional signs of the objective side (the degree of public danger), as well as the value of the direct, additional, optional objects and subject of the crime (the nature of public danger).

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Roman Alexandrovic Komyagin

Saratov State Law Academy

Email: roman.komyagin@mail.ru
lecturer of criminal and penitentiary law department Saratov, Russian Federation

References

  1. Actual problems of appropriation of rights: a course of lectures: textbook. manual for undergraduates of law schools. In 3 vols. T. 1 / ed. L.V. Lobanova. Volgograd., 2012. 280 p.
  2. Beccaria Ch. About cases and cases / transl. and enter. Art. MM. Isaev. M., 1939. 464 p.
  3. Gerasimov A.M. Public danger of the incident and its establishment // Criminal legal phenomenon and the role in the prevention of crime (3rd Saratov criminal law readings): collection of articles based on scientific-practical materials. conference / under general. ed. ON THE. Lopashenko, A.V. Golikov. Saratov: Publishing House of FGBOU VO "Saratov State Law Academy", 2018. 432 p.
  4. Gerasimov A.M. Public danger and its significance in the field of criminal law. Bulletin of the Saratov State Law Academy. No. 4 (123). 2018. S. 136-143.
  5. Gerasimov A.M. Social danger of crime: concept, structure, essential characteristics. The world of legal science. 2018. No. 8. S. 45-56.
  6. Durmanov N.D. The concept of crime. M., 1948. 315 p.
  7. Klenova T.V. Social danger - the true property of a crime // Forensic Library. 2013. No. 2 (7). pp. 136-144.
  8. Kozlov A.P. Author's course of criminal law. Part General. Book. 1. M.: Yurlitinform, 2018. 751 p.
  9. Kudryavtsev V.N. Sociological aspect of crime // Questions of combating crime. 1993, No. 18. S. 3-16.
  10. Kuznetsova N.F. Crime and crime. M., 1969. 232s.
  11. Lopashenko N.A. Reflections on criminal law. Principles of criminal law. Criminal law. Crime, misdemeanor and elements of crime. Author's course: monograph. - M.: Yurlitinform, 2020. 440s.
  12. Maltsev V.V. The problem of reflection and evaluation of social behavior in criminal law. Diss. doc. legal Sciences. M., 1993. 424p.
  13. Pavlukhin A.N. Socially dangerous behavior and its criminal wrongfulness / Pavlukhin A.N., Nesterov P.N., Eriashvili N.D. / ed. Pavlinova A.N. - M.: Unity-dana: law and law, 2007. 111p.
  14. Prozumentov L.M. Criminalization and decriminalization of acts. Tomsk: Publishing House Vol. un-ta, 2012. 142p.
  15. Crime and administrative offense. Textbook / Shishov O.F. - M.: VUZI Publishing House, 1967. 67 p.
  16. Prokhorov V.S. Crime and responsibility: monograph. L.: Publishing house of Leningrad State University, 1984. 136p.
  17. Crime as a legal category in the science and legislation of Russia: the history of development and features of the current state: monograph / Epifanova E.V.; Under scientific Ed.: Momotov V.V. - M.: Yurlitinform, 2013. 400 p.
  18. Rybak A.Z. Public danger of an act as a legal category. Lawyer-Pravoved., 2010. No. 2. S. 4-5.
  19. Sabitov R.A. Social danger as a criterion for criminalization // Actual problems of criminalization and decriminalization of socially dangerous acts. Omsk, 1980. S. 17-28.
  20. Smirnov A.M. The doctrine of socially dangerous forms of a criminal act: a monograph. - M.: Yurlitinform, 2016. 208 p.
  21. Soloviev A.N. The concept of crime: theoretical, legislative and law enforcement aspects. Diss. … cand. legal Sciences. Volgograd, 2000. 235 p.
  22. Solodkov I.A. Social danger of a crime and its criminal-legal dimension. Diss.… Cand. legal Sciences. Saratov, 2013. 223 p.
  23. Sotskov F.N. Public danger of an act in the criminal law of Russia. Abstract diss. for the competition st-no cand. legal Sciences. M., 2009. 28 p.
  24. Fefelov P.A. Criminal law concept of combating crime: Fundamentals of the general theory. Ekaterinburg, 1999. 251 p.
  25. Criminal law of Russia. Course of lectures: In 6 volumes. T. 1: Book. 1 / Bytko Yu.I., Lopashenko N.A., Razgildiev B.T.; Ed.: Razgildiev B.T. - Saratov., 2004. 320 p.
  26. Criminal law of Russia. Course of lectures: in 6 volumes. T. 2: Book. 1 / Bytko Yu.I., Lopashenko N.A., Razgildiev B.T.; Ed.: Razgildiev B.T. - Saratov., 2004. 648 p.
  27. Encyclopedia of criminal law: The concept of crime. V. 3 / Gontar I.Ya., Zinchenko I.A., Kozlov A.P., Kuznetsova N.F., and others; Rep. Ed.: Malinin V.B. - S.-Pb.: Ed. Professor Malinin, 2005. 522 p.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML

This website uses cookies

You consent to our cookies if you continue to use our website.

About Cookies