POLITICAL FACTORS OF STABILITY OF THE SOCIETY (ON THE EXAMPLE OF KRASNOYARSK REGION)

Abstract

It is considered the problem of political factors of regional stability. Using methods of expert questionnaires and analysis of indicators the author explains nature of stability on the example of Krasnoyarsk Region. Particularly the regional political institutes are considered in the support of stability.

Full Text

B nocne.QHHe rO.!lbl B cospeMeHHOM pocc11iicKOM 06- w.ecTBe Ha6mo.Qa10TCll .Qosep11e HaceneH11l! BnacTH, noBb1llleH11e ypos1·rn )l(HJH11, KOHcon11.QaUHll BOKpyr e.Q11Horo ueHTPa ynpasnemrn 11 MHoroe .!lpyroe, cornacHo 'IeMy MO)l(HO 61>mo 61>1 JaKnJO'IHTb , 'ITO nocne Kpm11ca 90-x ycTaHoei.rnacb cTa611n1>HOCTb. TeM He Mettee, o6c .QaeMM CTa611JJbHOCTb no HarneMy MHem110 l!BfljleTCll OTHOC11TeJJbHOH. ,n:eno B TOM, 'ITO B OCHOBe pocc1odkKolt CTa- 611JibHOCT11 Jie)l(11T M11pOBM 3KOHOMJ.ll{eCKM KOH'blOHKTypa ueH Ha OCHOBHbie npHpO.!lHbie pecypCbl, a He 3<l><l>eKT11BHOe CTPaTern'IecKoe ynpaBneHHe,a no I1pJ.ll{HHe HeycTOH'IHBOCTH 3TOit KOlfblOHKTypbl, 3KOHOMH'IeCKM 11 COUHanbHM CTa6HJibHOCTb o6w.ecrea MO)l(eT 6b!Th HapyrneHa. Oco6oe Mecro np11 aHam13e crn611JibHOCT11 JaH11Ma10T nomnH•teCK He <t>aKTOpbl,nOHHMaeMbie aBTOpOM KaK noJIHTH'IeCKHe .!lBH)l(yll(He CHJibl CTa6HJJH3aUHOHHbIX npoueccoe, irnneHHe HJIH npouecc, 06ycnaeJ111ea10w.11e cHcTeMoo6paJyJOume H C11CTeMOH3MeHlllOW.He TeH.QeHUHH B o6mecTBeHHOH CHCTeMe [l; 2]. IlOJJl1TH'IeCKHM11 <t>aKTOpaMH CTa611JlbHOCTH o6w.ecTBa .RBJJ.RIOTCll nOJIHTH'IeCKHe HHCTHTYTbI, np1106peTa10w.11e cneuH<i>HKY B 3as11cHMOCTH OT 11ccne,QyeMo ro pernoHa (o6w.ecTBa) , a TaK)l(e 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTb H Jier11Tl1MHOCTb BJiaCTH, npo.RBJl.RIOW.MC.R B itCTBHllX HHCTHTYTOB 11 ypOBHe .!lOBepm1 K HHM co CTOpOHblHaceneHHll. B .naHHOH CTaTbe oTpa)l(eHbl pe3ynbTilTb1 3Mn11p11'IecKoro 11CCJie.QOBaHH.R, npoBe.QeHHOro aBTOpOM neTOM 2006 r. B KpacHOllpcKoM Kpae1 11 aHanma p.R.na HH.!lHKaropos, no3BOJl.R!Oll..\HX oueHHTb COU11aJlbHyJO CTil6HJibHOCTb. B COUHOJIOrHH no.Q HH.!l11KaTopaM11 noHHMalOTCll 3MnHpH'ICCKHe nOKaJaTeJIH npH3HaKa H3Mep.R eMoro o6'beKTa [3]. Cne.QoBaTeJJ bHO, HH.U.HKaTOpb1 cTa611n1>HOCTH o6w.eCTBa - 3TO 3MnHpHtteCKHe xapaKTepHCTHKH CTa6HJlbHOCTH. KpaTKo nepe'I11cn11M xapaKTep11cT11K11 couHanbHbIX npoueccoB, KOTOpble MOryT 6b1Tb B3.RTbl 3a OCHOBY aHaJIH3a COUHaJJbHOH CTa6HJJhHOCT11: cou11an1>Ha .R m1<t><t>epeHu 11au11.R, couHanhHa.R nom1p- HOCTb, CTpant<l>HK aU11.R o6w.ecTBa; rpa)f(.QaHcKoe o6mecTBo, nonHrn'IeCKOe Y'Iacrne; ueHHOCTl1 l{JleHOB o6w.ecTBa; OTCYTCTBHe BOOp eHHbIX, HaUHOHaJJhHblX H non11- THtteCK l1X KOH<i>JJ11KTOB ; Y'iaCTHe cy6'beKTa <Pe.nepau11H B <t>opMHposamm 610.n)f(eTa CTPaH1>1 11 .np. B Ka'IeCTBe MeTo.Qa H3Y'ieHHll poJIH noJJHTH'Ie CKHX <t>aI<TopoB B no.n,nep)l(amrn COUHaJJbHOit CTa6HJlhHOCTH B KpacHO.RpCKOM Kpae 6brn Bb16paH KattecTBeHHbllt MeTO.!l 3KcnepT Horo onpoca. B Ka'IecTBe 3KcnepTOB Bb1crynan11 CTaTYCH1>1e npe.ncTaBHTenH HaY'iHOro coo6w.ecTBa, JaKoHO.D.aTeJJhHOH 11 HCITOJlHHTeJJhHOH BJiaCTH: 3aee.Q)'IOW.He Ka<t>e.npaMH Bb1c w11x Y'Ie6HbTX 3ase.neHHH, npo<t>eccopa; .nenYTaTbl 3aKoHo.naTeJJbHoro co6paH11.R Kpall; PYKOBO.D.H- TeJJH 11 cneu11an11CTbl .nenapTaMeHTOB a.QMl1Hl1CTpau1111 Kpal!. IlepBhie CJ10)f(HJ111Ch B TaKHX o6naCTllX Hay'IHOro 3HaHHll, KaK cou11onorl1ll, I1Cl1XOJIOfH.R, qmnoco<P11ll, 3KOHOMl1Ka 11 KOH<l>JJ11KTOJIOrHll,H B CBOeit HaY'IHOH .nel!TeJJhHOCTH He MOrnl1 He o6pau aTbC.R K npo6JieMe .uaHHOro HCCne.uoBaHHll. "llTO KacaeTC.R 3KCnepTOB OT BJJaCTH, TO 3<l><l>eKTHBHOCTh HX pa60Tbl HanpllMyJO BJJH.ReT Ha o6w.eCTBeHHyJO CTa611JlbHOCTb. 06w.ee KOJJH'IeCTBO 3Kc nepTOB COCTaBl1Jl0 14 'IeJJOBeK (7 Y'ieHblX 11 7 npe.ncTaBHTeJleH BJlaCTH), 'ITO llBJllleTC.R penpe3eHTaTHBHblM .ZlJlll Ka'leCTBeHHOro 11ccne.nosaHHll. ,lVIll no.nTBep)f(.ZleHHll BbI.!lBHHyThix rnnoTe3 Mhl 6y.neM u11rnpoBaT1> HaH6onee xapa1<Tep H1>1e BhlCKa3hIBaHHll 3KcnepTOB OTHOCHTeJlbHO npe.D.MeTa HCCJie)J.OB aHHll (B .naHHOH CTaThe Mbl 6y.neM YKaJhIBaTb JIHWb HOMep, no.n KOTOphlM npOXO)J.HT onpaw11eaeMhlH, 11 ero np11Ha.nne)l(HOCTh K enacrn (s.) 11n11 HaY'IHOMY o6w.eCTBY (H.)). ITp11op1neTHhIM HanpasneH11eM 11ccne.nosaH11si CTano BhlllBJieH11e nOJIHT11'1eCKl1X <t>aKTOpOB, 1103BOJJlllOll..\11X pernoHy 61>n1> cTa611n1>HbTM. IT01111MaH11e crn611n1>uocrn B .QaHHOM HCCJJe.11,0BaHHH 6y.neT nOl!CHeHO HH)f(e. l.J,enecoo6paJHo cTh B1>16opa HMeHHO 3Toro penmHa o6ycnosneHa KattecTBaMH, np11n11c1>rnaeMhIMH eMy 3KCnepTHhIM (nomnonornqecKHM H COUHOJ!OrH'leCKHM) coo6mecTBOM,- B03MO)l(HOCThlO B MHHHaT!Ope npocne.nHTh 11 cnporno3HpoeaTh HeK0Top1>1e npoueccb1, xapaKTepH1>1e .ZlJlll Pocc11iicKoit <I>e.nepau.1111 B uenoM, T. e. npoeecrn attan113 cnt611n1>HOCT11 11ccne.nyeMoro pernoHa 11 3KCTPanon11poBaTh BbIBO.U.hl Ha BCe poCCHHCKOe o6w.ecTBo. KpaCHOllpCKHit KpaH caM no ce6e HHTepeceH CBOHMH oco6eHHOCTllMl1, Bhl3BaHHblMl1 orpoMHOit 3aHHMaeMOH TeppHTOpHeH, 6oraTCTBOM np11po.nHhlX pecypcoe H 11HBeCTHUHOHHOH np1rnneKaTeJ11>HOCThlO. He Mettee Ba)l(HO 11 TO, t.tTO, HCCJie,Qyll COUHaJJhHyJO CTafolJlhHOCTb, Heo6xo.QHMO o6cy)l()J.aTh He o6mecTBO B uenoM, TaK KaK ITOH.RTHe o6w.ecTBa caMo no ce6e ecTh a6cTPaKUH.R , a KOHKpeTHyJO COUHaJJhHYIO HJIH nOJl11Tl1'IeCKyJO CHCTeMy, ececTOpOHHee HCCJJe.QoeaHHe KOTOpOH Ha116onee peneeaHTHO Ha ypOBHe pernoHa. B Ka'IecTBe nonwrntteCK HX <t>aKropoe crn611n1> HOCTH pernoHa aHaJJH3Y no.QeeprnHCh nonHTH'leCKHe HHCTHryThl, KOTOp1>1e Hepa3phIBHO CBl!3aHbl c 3<l><l>eKTHBHO CThlO H nerHTHMHOCThlO BJiaCTH. IlepeXO.nll K aHaJIH3Y HH.11,HKaTOpoe CTa6HJihHOCTH, Heo6xo.nHMO OTMeTHTh, 'ITO nOJIHhle .naHHble 0 COUHaJJhHOit CTparn<t>11Kauw11 B KpacHosipcKoM Kpae OTCYTCTByJOT, o.nHaKo, ee MO)l(HO npocnemnb no c<l>epaM, B KOTOp1>1x JaH.RTO HaceneHHe, ypOBHIO .!lOXO.QOB, 6e3pa6ornue H coUHaJihHOH nonllpHocrn. YposeHh 6e3pa6ornu1>1 B pernoHe no .naHHhIM ynpasneHHll <I>e.u.epanbHOH rocy.napcTBeHHOit cny)l(61>1 JaH.RTOCTH no KpacHo.RpCKOMY Kpa!O K 2005 r. OTHOCHTeJlhHO npOWJlblX neT CHH3HJIC.R Ha 20 % 11 B cpe.ntteM no Kpa!O COCTaBHJl 3'I %, '{TO HH)f(e cpe.nm1x noKaJaTenett no CH6HpCKOMY <1>0 (3,3 %). BecmHuK Cu6upcKozo zocyoapcmBem1ozo a3poKocMu'leCKozo YHUBepcumema UMeuu aKaOeMuKa M </J. PeUJemHeBa image Ecm1 )!(e cpaBHHBaTh ypoaeHh 6e3pa6ornuh1 c 2004 r., TO OHa CHH3HJlaCh Ha 2 %. Mb! CBll3bJBaeM 31)' TeH,lleHUHIO c peanH3auHei1 pll.lla KpynHhIX HHBeCTHUHOHHhIX npoeKTOB Ha TeppHTOpHH Kprui (cM. KoHueHUHIO Kopnopaumt pa3BHTHll KpacHol!pcKoro Kpall Ha o<t>HUHMhHOM YIHrepHeT-nopTa11e «KpacHollpCKHH Kpaii» (http:// www.krskstate.ru) , 'ITO HaXO,llHT nO,llTBCp)!(,lleHHe B CJ!OBax 3KCnepTOB: «Ham Kpali CTaHOBHTCJI Bee 6onee CTa- 6HJibHblM. H .llJlll 3Toro eCTh 061.eKTHBHhie noKaJareJIH. Kor,lla Mb! roBOpHM 06 HHBeCTHUHOHHOH npHBJieKaTeJibHOCTH pernoHa, TO OtteHb COJIH.llHhie HHBeCTOpbl B nepB)'IO ottepe,llb paccMaTPHBalOT B03MO)!(HOCTb BJIO)!(eHHll CBOHX HHBeCTHUHH C TO'IKH 3peHHJI 3KOHOMHtteCKOH CTa- 6HJlhHOCTH. Haw Kpaii no peiiTHHry 3a nocne.llHHe .llBa ro.lla no.llHllJ!Cll Ha napy czyneHeK BBepx, T. e. Ha,lle)!(HOCTh 3KOHOMHtteCKru!, 6y.lleM rOBOpHTh, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb nepe.ll TeMH HHBeCTOpaMH , KOTOpble 6y,llyT H e BKJia,llb!Ba!OT pecypCbl B Ham Kpaii, n03BOJlll!OT HM C,lle- 11an, TaKOH BblBO.ll. 3TO npH3HaHO Ha TpeTheM pOCCHHCKOM HHBeCTHUHOHHOM <t>opyMe, KOTOpblH npoBO.llHJ!Cll B HarneM ropo.lle» (3KcnepT J-12 1, H.). . ,A.nll Toro 4T06bl He CJlO)!(HJlaCh o6paTHall CHl)'aUHll - ,lle<t>HUHTa pa60THHKOB, KpaH yttaCTByeT B nporpaMMe 1 cpe.nHero KJiacca. Ou Hepa3pbIBHO CBJl3aH c COUHMbHOi1 CTa6HJibHOCTblO H MO)!(eT no npaay C"IHTaTbCR 0.llHHM H3 8a)f(HhlX <t>aKTOpOB CTa6HJibHOCTH, a ero HaJIHttHe JIBJIReTCll HH.llHKaTOpOM o6mecTBeHHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH . Ilo coUHaJlhHOH CTPaTH<l>HKaUHH MO)!(HO CY.llHTb 0 COCTORHHH o6mecTBa, ypOBHe ero pa3BHTHJI H CTa6HJIH3aUHOHHbIX npoueccax. Pa3BHToe cTa6HJibHoe o6rnecTBo npe.nnonaraeT MaJI)'IO "IHCJieHHOCTb 6e.llHOro u 6oraToro HaceneHHll, H 60JiblllOH npoueHT rpa)l(,llaH co cpe.llHHM .llOXO.llOM H ypoaHeM )f(H3HH. Cnpoc Ha cneuuanHCTOB c BhICIIIHM o6- pa3oeaHHeM B npOMbHUJieHHOM ceKTope, .llOCTOHHru! onnaTa TaKoro TPY.lla no3BOJlllT 3Ha"IHTeJibHO no.ll.llep)f(aTb u ,lla)f(e yaeJIH"IHTb cpe.llHHH KJiacc, B TOM "IHCJie H 3a C"leT MHrpaUHH. Ilpo6JieMy OTTOKa KBanu<t>uuupoBaHHbIX MOJIO.llblX cneuHanHCTOB H3 pernoHa npH3BaHa pernHTh nporpaMMa «3onoToi1 Ka.npoBhlH pe3epB KpacHoiipcKoro Kpall». HanHttHe 3<l><l>eKTHBHbIX anacTHbIX HHCTHl)'UHOHanbHbIX MexaHH3MOB JIBJIJleTCJI OCHOBOH CTa6HJibHOCTH, no- 3BOJIJIIOIUCH o6mecTBy pa3BHBaThCR, He Bb!XO.!lR 3a npe.llCJlbl CTPYKTYPHOH ycToiittHBocrn cHcTeMbI KaK ue11oro (2), nOCKOJlbKY caMa npHpO,lla nOJIHTH"leCKHX HHCTHT)'TOB HeceT B ce6e cTa611nu3au110HHh1e MexaHH3MbJ. K nonHTHnepece11eHHJ1 cooretteCTBeHHHKOB . KpacHollpCKHH Kpaii qecKHM HHCTHl)'TaM OTHOCJITCJI HHCTHT)'Tbl BJiaCTH H yttaeorne11 B caMyio 611aronpHllTHYJO no co,lleHCTBHIO nepeceJlll!OIUHMCll B MHrpaUHH KaTeropH!O A H, CJle,llOBaTeJihHO, yttaCTHHKaM 6y,llyT KOMneHCHpOBaHh l 3aTPaTbl Ha npoe3,ll, Bh1nnatteHo e,llHHOBpeMeHHOe noco6ue H 6y.lleT npe.llJlo)!(eHo apeH.llOBaTh KBaprnpy HJIH aczynan. e nporpaMMhI unoTettuoro Kpe.llHTOBaHHll . HeKOTOph1e paiioHhI roTOBhI npe.llOCTaBHTh 3eMeJlbHhlH yttaCTOK no.ll CTPOHTeJihCTBO co6cTBeHHoro .llOMa. KpacHollpCKHH Kpai:f, TaKHM o6pa30M, J1BJIJ1eTCJ1 nepcneKTHBHhIM H HllBCCTHUHOHHO np1rnneKaTeJlhHblM perHOHOM c nocTOJIHHO pacryIUHM ypOBHeM )!(H3HH HaceneHHJI, 11 TeH.neHUHll poCTa .llOXO.llOB HaceneHHJI B CBeTe rpll.nym11x npoeKToB .llOJI)!(Ha coxpaHHThCR. Ho Heo6xO.llHMO OTMeTHTh, '!TO pOCT .llOXO.llOB He OTMeHReT npo6neMy coUHaJlbHOH nom1pHOCTH . bOJlblllHHCTBO 3KCnepTOB Bb!pa- 3HJIH TPeBory OTHOCHTeJlbHO 3TOro BOnpoca: «He CKpOIO, 4TO eCTb otteHb MHOro <t>aKTopoB, KOTOpbie He .lla!OT 60JiblllOrO OCHOBaHHJI B ttaCTH CTa6HJlhHOCTH. JTO BCeM 113aecTHoe otteHb cepbe3Hoe paccnoeHHe B HarneM o6mecTBe no HMyiuecTBeHHhlM noKaJaTeJillM, Kor.na 6onee TPeTH HaceneHHJI Hawero Kpall <t>aKTH"leCKH )f(HBeT 3a qepTOH 6e.nHoCTH. H B ::irnx ycnoBHRX paccttHThIBaTh Ha BhICOKHH ypoBeHb CTa6HJibHOCTH He npHXO.llHTCll, ec11H .llaJlblile 6y.lleT coxpaHRTbCJI TaKaJI o6CTaHOBKa (3KCnepT N'!! 1, H.). Ec11u paccMaTPHBaTh TaKHe Ba)f(HeiirnHe npo6neMhI H yrpo3hl CTa6HJibHOCTH, KaK MaJI)'IO nJIOTHOCTb HaceneHHR , 6e3pa6ornuy, COUHaJlbH)'IO noniipHOCTb H np., TO B perHOHe OHH npucyrcTB)'IOT. Bonpoc, pernHT nu Kypc pa3- BHTHll pernoHa, npe.llJIO)!(eHHhIH a.nMHHHCTpauHeii KpacHoiipcKoro Kpaii, .naHHbie npo6neMhI, HJIH eme 6onhme yc11JIHT pa3pbIB Me)f(.llY 6oraThIMH H 6e.llHhIMH, ocTaeTCJI OTKpb!TbIM. Ilpe,llnOJiaraeM, "ITO COUHaJlbHbie npo611eMbl MOryr pa3pernHTbCR c <t>opMHpOBaHHeM H no.ll.llep)f(KOH CTHR. B Kpae 3a .llOnrne rO.llbI c<t>opMHpoaanncb H .nei1CTB)'IOT TaKHe HHCTHT)'Tbl BJiaCTH, KaK 3aKOHO,llaTeJihHOe co6paHHe Kpacuol!pCKoro Kprui, BKJI10"la10mee 52 .llenyTaTa, H a.llMHHHCTPaUHll, COCTOJl!Uru! H3 COBeTa H ,llenapTaMeHTOB. Oco6oro BHHMaHHJI 3aCJIY)f(HBaeT HHCTHT)'T ry6epuaTOpcTBa. 3aKOHO.llaTeJibHOe co6paHHe .llelkTByeT B Kpae c 1993 r., 3a 3TO BpeMJI COCTaB H 'IHCJieHHOCTb npe.llbIJJ.Yll.IHX TPex C03hIBOB 3Ha"IHTeJibHO MeHiinucb. Ha 2 nocne.nm1x Bb16opax B 3aKOHO.llaTeJibHoe co6paHHe (3AKC) H3 npoIIIe.llWHX napTHH JIBHOe 60JlblllHHCTBO cocTaBHJ1a «E.llHHall Poccmrn (49,0 % - 25 .llenyraToa). TaK)!(e HMCIOTCJI KIIP<l> (15,7 % - 8), «CnpaBe.llJIHBM PocCHJI)) (9,9 % - 5), JI,I:(IlP (5,8 % - 3) " enc (3,9 % - 2). Yf3 51 ,llenyraTa B 3AKC npOillJIH 8 He3aBHCHMhIX , Bbl.llBHH)'ThIX H36HpaTeJlJIMH OKpyroB, no KOTOpbIM npoxo.llHJIH ,llaHHbie ,llenynThl (15,7 %). TaKoe COOTHOllleH11e noMHMO acero npoqero roBopHT o BCTPOeHHO CTH KpacHOllpCKoro Kpal! B CHCTeMY BepTHKaJIH BJiaCTH. Ecnu oueHHBaTb 3<l><l>eKTHBHOCTb 3aKOHO.llaTe JibHOro co6paHHll, TO 3aKOHOTBOptteCKaJI ,llellTeJibHOCTb Be,lleTCJI B Kpae Ha BblCOKOM ypOBHe no cpaBHCHHIO c .llpyrHMH pernoHaMH CTpaHbl, XOTJI 3KCnepTbl OT HaYKH BH.nRT Mano nOJlb3bl OT 3Toro opraHa, Ha3bIBaJI ero <<roaopHJJhHeH ». TaK, yMeCTHO npHBeCTH TaKOe BblCKa3bIBaHHe : «Be.llYIUal! pOJJb, KOHe"IHO, y HcnoJJHHTeJJbHOii anacTH. MecTHall 3aKOHO.llarenhHru! anacTb BJJHlleT cna6o. 0Ha He KOMneTeHTHa, noTOMY ttTo MacrnTa6 pa3BopattHaa10mHXCJ1 3,necb co6h1THi1 cymecTBeHHO Bbllle KOMneTeHUHH MeCTHOi:I 3aKOHO,llaTCJlbHOH BJJaCTH» (3KCnepT N'!! 11, H.). HHbie 3KcnepTHbie oueHKH .llaBanHCb HHCTHT)'TaMH 11cnonHHTeJJbHoH: anacrn. YIHrepecHo, 4TO ecnH Ha <t>e.nepanbHOM ypOBHe HHCTHT)'T npe3H,llCHTCTBa llBJllleTCll 3aJIOroM c-ra6HJlhHOCTH, TO B KpacHollpCKOM Kpae a co3HaHHH image I f1pH onpoce 3KCnepTOB B Jl.CKa6pe 2007 - JIJIBape 2008 rr. 6bll!a nonyqeHa HH<jlOpMaUHll 0 TOM,'!TO Ha .naHHbli-i MOMCHT 6bll! nepecenen ncero I '!enoaeK HJ 2 283, He C'IHTaJI 6 849 'IIICHOB ceMhH. 2 B1>16op&1 B 3aKOHo.naTenbHOe co6paHHe 'leTBepToro (nepaoro a o6oe.nHHCHHOM KpacHollpCKOM Kpae) coJbma npownH a KpacHoJ1pcKe 15 anpem1 2007 r. 205 <l>wioco</Jwi u COtfUOJIOZUJl image 3KcnepTOB coseT H .uenapraMeHTbI TPaHc<t>opMHpOBaJJHCb BJiaCTH H, cne.uoeaTeJibHO, ee nerHTHMHOCTH. )l(enaH11e , B etJ.HH}'lO «KOMaH.UY XnonoHHHa» 1 3<t><t>eKTHBHOH pa6oBJiaCTH JierHTHMHpoBaTbCll nopo)l(.llaeT HMe!Ol.t\YJOCll MOTOH KOTOpOH 3KCnepTbl H3 Hay<IHOro coo6mecTBa o6'bJICHl!IOT cra6HJibHYIO CHzyaUHIO B Kpae: «Cero,UHJI He CTOJibKO o6ecne•msaeT 3TY cTa6HJibHOCTb JIH'IHOCTb X110- noHHHa AJieKCaH.upa feHHa,UbeBH'la , CKOJlbKO KOMaH,Ua TeX JIJO,UeH, KOTOpbie c10.ua HanpaeJieHbl, 'laCTH'IHO Ha- 6paHbl H3 MeCTHbIX. B OCHOBHOM OHH see Ha CBOHX MecTax» (3KcnepT N!! 9, B.). Cneii.yeT paccMOTPeTb cnaraeMb1e 3<P<t>eKTHBHOCTH H JierHTHMHOCTH pernOHaJJbHOH BJiaCTH. 3Ha'IHMbIMH B .uaHHOM eonpoce, nOMHMO npoqero, l!BJIJllOTCR aBTOpHTeT ry6epHaTopa H ero JIOl!JlbHOCTb ueHTpy, '!TO BJIHJleT Ha peweHHe MHornx aonpocoa, .urui<e TaKHX, KaK onpe.ueneHHe Kpall n11oma.UKOH .UJIJI peaJJH3aUHH H.lleH C03,UaHHR HauHOHaJJbHoro yHHBepcHTera. Tio.nTBep)l(.ueHHe 3TOMY MbI Haxo.nHM a oueHKe 3Kcnepra N2 l(H.): «IlpeTeH.neHTOB 6bIJIO MHOro, B TOM 'IHCJie HoBOCH6HpCK , 11PKYTCK, ToMCK , HO, He B nocJie,UHIOIO O'lepe.ub, no.u BJIHJIHHeM aaTOpHrera Hawero ry6epHaTOpa eonpoc 3TOT 61>1J1 peweH B noJib3Y KpacHOl!pcKa». He TOJibKO 3TOT CJI)"laH roaopHT 06 Hcnon1>3oBaHHH Kpall .llJIJI anpo6aUHH H JierHTHMaUHH pa3HOro po.ua HOBOBBe,UeHHH. 3Ha'IHMblMH BexaMH, onpe.ueJIHBWHMH .UaJJbHeAwy10 nonHTHKY pernoHa H HaMeTHBWHMH KYPC .llJlll cj>e.uepaUHH, CTaJJH <t>aKTl-fl{eCKOe HaJHa'!eHHe ry6epHaTOpa H o6'be.UHHeHHe KpacHollpCKoro Kpall, 3eeHKHAcKoro H Tai1Mb1pcKoro aeTOHOMHbIX oKpyroa. B KpacH011pcKoM Kpae Mb! MO)l(eM Ha61110.uaTb 3<t>¢eKTHBHYJO peaJJH3aUHIO JierHTHMaUHH nOJIHTH'leCKOrO pe)l(HMa B CTpaHe, Kor.ua ycHJIHBaeTCll aepTHKaJib BJiaCTH H BbICTpaHaaeTCJI ¢e.uepanH3M c CHJibHbIM ue1npanbHbIM ynpaaneHHeM. Bb1COKaJ1 JIBKa Ha pe¢epeHtJ.YM H o.uo6peHHe co CTOpOHbI rpruK.UaH o6'be,UHHeHHR 3aeHKHH, TaHMbipa H KpacHo.11pcKoro Kpall o6ycnoaneHbI nonHoueHHbIM HCnoJJb30BaHHeM a,UMHHHCTPaTHBHOro pecypca,Ha'IHHaJI OT BCTPe'I 3aMeCTHTeneA ry6epHaTopa c PYKOBO.UHTeJIJIMH o6mecTBeHHbIX opraHH3aUHH H o6'bllCHeHHJI HM nOJJb3bl OT 06'be,UHHeHHJI .no nepcOHaJibHblX HanOMHHaHHH 0 pecj>epeHii.yMe. PeweHHe 06 o6oe.uHHeHHH eczymUio B CHJIY c JIHBap.11 2007 r. H e npHHl!Ta nporpaMMa COUHaJibH0- 3KOHOMH'leCKOro pa3BHTHJI HOBOro cy6beKTa <t>e.uepauHH .no 2010 r. fipHopHTeTHblM HanpaaneHHeM 3Toro .uoKyMeHra JIBJJJleTCJI pa3BHTHe COUHaJJbHOH c¢epbl qepe3 npOMbIWJJeHHbIH ceKTop. B 'laCTHOCTH, a pernoHe peanH- 3yeTCJ1 npoeKT «KoMnJJeKcHoe pa3BHrne HH)l(Hero Tipttattrapbll», ueJJbJO KOToporo J1BJJJ1eTcJ1 co3,UaHHe Ha 06- WHpHoii MaJJOHaCeJJeHHOH TeppHTOpHH HOBOrO npOMbIWJJeHHOro paAoHa B BocTO'IHOii Ctt6Hp11. HecOMHeHHo , rnaBHbIH n03HTHBHbIH 3¢¢eKT OT o6'be,UHHeHHR .UOJJ)l(eH npOllBl1TbCJI B 6yii.ymeM B HHTerpauHH 3KOHOMHKH H ocBOeHHH MHOrO'll1CJJeHHblX pecypcoe. Kpati npHMe'laTeJJeH He TOJibKO TeM, '!TO 3.Uecb 3¢¢eKT11BHO peanHJyJOTCR KpynHble mrneCTHU.110HHbie npoeKTbI, HO H caoetl MOJIO,Ue)l(HOii noJIHTl1KOH . E)f(ero.UHbie KOHKypcbI, TaKl1e KaK «KM-<l>oPYM», «30JIOTOH Ka,UpOBbIH pe3epB» H «fy6epHaTopCKHH 6an», CTp011TeJibHble OTpll.llbl H npoqee npHBJieKaJOT BHl1MaH11e MOJIO,lle)l(H K pernoHaJJbHOH anacTH H o6mecTBeHHOH )l(lf3HH Kpall. CTeneHb COTPY.UHH'ICCTBa MOJIO,Ue)l(H c noJIHTH'leCKHMH HHCTHTYTaMH l!BJIJICTCJI Ba)l(HblM nOKaJaTeJieM .uoaepHll HaceJieHl1JI image 1 TaKoe 060JHa'le1rne BCTpe'!ae-rcl! y 90 % 3KcnepTOe. JIO,Ue)f(HYIO nOJIHTHKy. 11HCTHTYTbl y<1aCTl1JI MOryT HaJbIBaTbCR TaKOBblMH JIHIIlb ¢opMaJJbHO 113-3a ynpaBJIJleMOCTH co CTOpOHbl BJiaCTH H 6e3blHHUHaTHBHOCTH caMHX HapO,UHblX Mace, .UOKa- 3aTeJibCTBOM 'lero MO)f(eT C HTb pe¢epeHtJ.YM 06 o61>el1HeHHH KpacHoJ1pcKoro Kpall, 3aeHKHH H TaiiM1>1pa. Tip11 3TOM npecJie,UOBaJJHCb TaK11e ue1111,KaK, BO-nepBblX, ,llaJJbHeifwall OTC'fPOHKa H HaJiruKHBaHHe aepTHKaJJH BJiaCTH 3a C'leT peii.yuHpOBaHHll cy6oeKTOB ¢e.uepau11H, '!TO Il03BOJIReT C,UeJiaTb perHOHbl 6011ee ynpaBJI.lleMblMH, BOBTOpblX, 0611er'leHHe pa60Tbl npOMbIWJieHHOrO ceKTopa B CBJl3H c peaJIH3yeMOH npOKJia,UKOH He¢renpoao.ua H ocBOeHHeM TipHattraphR , B-TPeThHX, yc1111eHHe ,UOTaUHOHHblX ceeepHbIX pernoHOB 3a C'ieT pernoHa-.uoHopa . 3KcnepT1>1 a ceoHX oueHKax pe¢epeH,UYMa 111160 o.uo6pl!JIH H.lle!O 06'be,UHHeHHll, JIH60 OTHOCHJIHCb K 3TOMy HeHTPaJibHO. 11 Te, 11 .upyrne ccbIJiaJIHCb Ha TO, '!TO panbwe Kpatl 6b!JI e,UHHhIM, a npo113owe.uwee a 1992 r. paJbe.UHneHHe HeraTHBHO CKaJaJIOCb Ha pa3BHTHl1 pernoHa, Hapyw11B Hapa60TaHHbie CBJ1311. fipHBO.UHM HaH6011ee xapaKTepHhie oueHKH 3KcnepToa: «00oe,UHHeH11e xopowo .llJIJI 11HBecTOpOB 11 .llJlll Tex , KTO XO'leT pa3BOpa'111BaTb 6H3HCC Ha Tepp11rop1111 Kpall. YMeHhWaeTCl! KOJil1'1eCTBO cornacosaHl1H, HHCTaHuHA H 3TO ecer.ua 611aro, a, cne.uoaaTeJibHO, 11 06nerqaeTCJ1 HlleecTHUHOHHblH pe)l(11M H BCJie,U 3a 3KOHOMH'leCKHMH no- 3HTHBaMH npH,UeT H omymeHHe CTa611JibHOCTH» (::>KcnepT N!! 6, B.); <<3To O'leBl1,llHblH 3KOHOMl1'1eCKl1H pOCT H npHTOK HHBeCTHU1111, 3a KOTOpblMH nocne.uyeT pocT 610)DKeTa» (3KcnepT N2 7, a.). JIHWb 0,llHH 3KCnepT,npe,UCTaBJIR!Oll.(HH BJJaCTb (N!! 14), OTMCTl1JI npe)l(.ueapeMeHHOCTb KaKHX-JI1160 nporH030B H BbIBO.UOB OTHOCHTeJibHO npOH30we.uwero 06be,UHHeHl1ll: «fipoueccbI .uonroapeMeHHbie 11 nocne.ucTBHJI .uonro eme CKaJbIBaJOTCJI . 51 .nyMaJO, 'ITO noKa paHo roeopHTb. Cetlqac y Hae 11.ueT nepexo.UHbIH nepHO.ll, HO ecJIH roeopHTb 06 06'be,U11HeHHl1 TeKymHX npo6neM, TO 3,UeCb n0311Tl1BHOro MaJIO». Cpe.ntt p11cKoe HaJ1>rnaeTcJ1 npHcoe.ll.HHeHHe K HMe!Oll.lHMCJI npo6JieMaM ceeepHblX OKpyrOB. fIOMHMO a,UMHHHCTPaTHBHblX pecypcoa, ynOMllll)'TblX paHee, cpe.ucTBa Maccoaoti HH¢opMaUH11 TaK)l(e no npaay C'IHTaTbCJI pecypcoM,HCUOJib3YeMblM BJiaCTblO ,llJlll y.uep)f(aHl1ll ceoero CTazyca. PernoHaJihHbie cpe.ucTBa MaccoBOH HH¢opMaUHH He HBJIJllOTCJI caMOCTOl!TeJibHOH CHJI011 B )f(H3HH o6mecraa, a ueJIHKOM H IlOJIHOCTblO nO}lKOHTPOJibHbl enacrH. 3KcnepTbI o6bl!CHJIJOT cnoJKHBWYJOCll CHzyaumo OTC)'TCTBl1eM caMOCTOJITeJibHblX <t>HHaHCOBbIX 11CTO'IHHKOB ,llJIJI <l>HHaHCHpOBaHHJI onn03HUHOHHblX MHeHHH H napn1ii: «3.n.ech HeB03MOJKHO HMeTb raJezy HJIH pa.uHOCTaHUHJO Hano.uo6He «3xa MocKBbI» c He3aettcHMhIM ¢11HaHcHpoaaHHeM. Tio3TOMY co6cTBeHHO roeopll, ¢aKTop CTa6HJibHOCTH O.UHH - nOJIHaJI 3aBHCHMOCTb BCeH 3Jil1Thl 11 acew HH¢opMau110HHOH CTPYKTYPl>I OT enacTH» (3KcnepT N2 6). ,z:{eHCTBHR HHCTHTYTOB y<1aCTHJI MO)f(HO npOHJIJIIOCTpHpOBaTb Ha npHMepe .usyx KpynHhlX Kopnopau.1111 .ueHCTBYJOillHX Ha Tepp11ropHH Kpal! - PYCAJia H «HopHnbcKoro HHKCJIJI)). BecmHUK Cu6upcKozo zocyoapcmfJ eHHOW a3pOKOCMu11ecKozo yHu6epcumema UMeHu aKaOeMUKa M <P. Pezu emHefJa Eopi,6y Me)l(,ll,)' HHMH MO)f{HO 6bIJIO Ha6moJJ.aTb Ha ry- 6epHaTOpCKHX s1>16opax B 2002 r., KOrJJ.a OT PYCAJia KaHJJ.HJJ.aTOM 6hIJI Bhl.ll.BHttyT npeJJ.CeJJ.aTeJlb 3aKOHOJJ.aTeJlbHOro co6paHHll Kpall A. B. Yee, a OT «HopHHKeJJll» 6hIBWHH ron-MeHe.ll.)f{ep :noii KOMilaHHH, ry6epHaTOp TaHMblpCKOfO AO A. r. XJIOilOHHH. )J;eHCTBHJI cl>eJJ.e panbHOH BJlaCTH B OTHOllieHHH CJIO)f{HBWeHC.11 Ha TOT MOMeHT cHryal..l,HH, a, KaK H3BeCTHo, npe3HJJ.eHT PoccHH B. B. IlYTHH IlO.ll..ll.ep)f{an A. r. XnonOHHHa, n03BOJl!llOT .D.YMaTb,"!TO peanbHall nOJIHTH"leCKall 6opi,6a CBO.ll.HTC.11 K 6opi,6e 3JIHT Me)f{.D.Y co6ou 3a pecypci,1 BhIXOJJ.a Ha KpeMJJh . Iloc11e.uoBaTe111>Hoe BJJH.RHHe u,eHTPa Ha pernoH KOHCOJIH.UHpyeT nOJIHTH"leCKHe HHCTHTYTbl BOKpyr OJJ.HHX u.eneH, "!TO n03BOJI.ReT HM 6h1Tb 6onee 3<l>cl>eKTHBHblMH . )J;pyrHMH CJIOBaMH, nOJIHTH"leCKHM HHCTHryTaM Heo6xoJJ.HMO npH.uep)f{HBaTbC.11 OJJ.HOH noJIHTH"leCKOH JIHHHH. Ou,eHKY 3TOMY .uaeT 3KcnepT .N2 13 (s.): «Cra6HJIH3aU.Hll - Bell.l,h B3aHMOYB.R 3aHHall H npou.ecc CTa6HJIH3al.l,HH 3aBHCHT OT pa60Tbl Bcex noJIHTHlleCKHX HHCTHryTOB B eJJ.HHOH ynp!!)f{Ke H OTCYTCTBHH npoTHBOpe"IHH». J.h BCero CKa- 3aHHoro Bh!We MO)f{HO CJJ.eJiaTh BblBOJJ., llTO nOJIHTH"leCKHe HHCTHryTbl B COBOKynHOCTH c 3cl>cl>eKTKBHOCTblO H JJerHTHMHOCTblO BJJaCTH 3a.ua10T JJ.HHaMHKY CTa6HJIH3aU.HOHHblM npou.eccaM B o6mecTBe. AHanH3 nonHTH"leCKHX cl>aKTopoB 11 HHJJ.HKaropoB CTa6HJlbHOCTH nOKa3an, '!TO COU.HanbHall c11rya1.1,HJ1 B Kpae HeJJ.OCTaTO"IHO CTa6HJibHa, "!TO CTaBHT nOJJ. yrpo3y CTa- 6HJlbHOCTb perHOHa B u.enoM. 06paTHMCll K 3KCnepTHblM ou.eHKaM no .uaHHOMY eonpocy. Eon1>U1HHCTBO 3Kcnepros paccMaTPHBanH Kpaii KaK CTa6HJlhHblH c nonpaBKOH Ha TO, llTO 3Ta CTa6HJibHOCTb OTHOCHTeJlbHall: «B npHHU.Hne no poccHHCKHM MepKaM KpacHollpcKHH Kpau BXOJJ.HT B "IHCJIO CTa6HJibHblX perHOHOB . ,$1 61>1 CKa3an, "!TO perHOH JIBJJl!eTCJI OTHOCHTeJlhHO CTa6HJibHblM. y Hae B PoCCHH HH"lero cm6HJJbHoro ceiiqac HeT. Ho Kpaii no poccHliCKHM MepKaM cra6HJJbHblM JIBJilleTC.11)) (3KCnepT .N!! JO, H.). HeK0Top1>1e 3KcnepTb1 Bec1>Ma KareropHllHO no3HU.HOHHpoeanH perHOH KaK Hecra6HJlbHblH'. - «COU.HaJibHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH HeT, KOHe"IHO,KaK H BO eceii PoccHH. IloToMy "ITO, TaK )Ke KaK H BO Bceii PoccHH JJ.Hcnponop1..1,H.11 )f{YTKall no JJ.OXOJJ.aM HaceneHHll, no pacnpeJJ.eneHHIO 610JJ.)l(eTHb1x cpeJJ.CTB. B TOM •rncne H 06- mect>e.uepan1>Horo 610.u)f{eTa. )J;Hcnponopu.Hll 6011bwa.11 OlleHb no HHcl>paCTPYKTYPe . CpaBHHTh esponelicKyro qacTb••• TaK "ITO .D.aneKo .ll.O cTa6HJJhHOCTH. 11oToMy "ITO no.u CTa6HJlbHOCTblO Mb! Il0.ll.pa3yMeBaeM HeKHH CTaH.uapT. ,D;o rex CTaH.D.apTOB, KOTOp1>1e nponaraH.ll.HPYIOT HaM, O"leHb .ll.aJieKO» (3KCnepT .N2 6, B.). - «HbIHewH.11.11 c11ryau.H.11 B PocCHH npe.D.CTaBJI.ReT co- 6of:i BJiaCTb KOMnpa.D.OpCKO-Macl>H03HOH 6yp a3HH nJJIOC .D.eHH.ll.YCTPHaJIH 3au.m1 11 .D.e6HJJH3aU.H.R sceii CTPaH1>1. HH ll.HY npo6neMy, B TO llHCJie H B paMKax o6'b!IBJJeHHblX npoeKToB, pernHTh nocne.uoBaTeJ11>HO HeJih3ll B ycnoBHJIX cymecTBYIQ u.tHX OTHOWeHHH)) (3KCnepT .N!! 5,H.). I10Ka3aTeJJbHO, llTO npe.ucTaBHTeJIH HCilOJIHHTeJlbHOH snacTH qaru.e, "!eM npe.D.cTaBHTenH HayqHoro coo6mecTBa H snacrn 3aKOHO.ll.aTeJibHOH, CKJIOHHbI onpeJJ.eJillTb pernoH cTa6HJJbHhIM. Bepo.RTHee scero, xapaKTepH3Yll pernoH, OHH .ua10T ou,eHKY CBOeH pa6oTe, TaK KaK CTa6HJlbHOCTb o6mecTBa B 60JibllieH CTeneHH 3aBHCHT OT 3<l>cl>eKTHBHOCTH HX pa60Tbl. Bo3spamaRcb K pa3rosopy o cou,HanbHOH cTparncl>HKaU.HH, MO)l(HO CKa3aTh, "!TO Ha JJ.aHHb!H MOMeHT CTa6HJlbHOCTb pemoHa H BCeH PoCCHH JJ.ep)f{HTC.11 He Ha cpeJJ.HeM KJiacce B npHBblllHOH HHTepnpeTal.l,HH JJ.aHHOro nOH!ITHJI, TaK KaK OH MaJIOll!-fCJleH H 3aqacTY1Q He HHTepecyeTCJI noJIHTH"lecKof:i )f{H3Hhl0 CTPaH1>1, a Ha 60J11>UIHX Maccax HaceneHHll,qi,e o6pa3oBaHHe H JJ.OXOJJ.bl 3aqaCTY!O JJ.aneKH OT TPe6osaHHf:i , npeJJ.'h.RBJI.ReM1>1x K cpeJJ.HeMy KJJaccy. I1011HTH"!ecKall anaTHll cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca ycTpa11saeT KaK BJJaCTb, TaK H npeJJ.CTaBHTeneli' KJiacca. 110JIHTHKH 6ecKOHTPOJihHO 3aHHMa!OTC!I, lleM XOTRT ITO.LI. JJ03YfffOM «noJIHTHKOH JJ.OJI:lKHbl 3aHHMaTbCR npoct>ecCHOHaJib[)), a cl>HHaHCOBO ycnemHall qacTb cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca csoH 3acnyrn npHnHCblBaeT ce6e,a He nOJJHTH'!eCKOMY KypCy. B poccHHCKOH .D.eHCTBHTe111>Hocrn 06c JJ.aT1> BJIHRHHe .uaHHOH rpynnhl Ha IlOJIHTH"leCKHe H COU.HanbHb ie npou.eccbl 6eccM1>1cneHHO JJ.O Tex nop, noKa "IHCJJeHHOCTh cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca He COCTaBHT 60JJbllIHHCTBO H noKa He 3apa6ora10T MexattH3MhI rpaJKJJ.aHcKoro o61l.1,ecTBa. A noKa s Pocc1rn 60111>Uiall qacTh )f{HTenett HaxOJJ.RTC.R 3a qepTOH 6eJJ.HOCTH H BeJIHKa IlOJIRpHOCTb Me)f{.ll.Y Kpaf:iHHMH IlOKa- 3aTeJI.RMH CTPaTHcl>HKaU.HH poccHHCKoro 061J.1.eCTBa IlpoBe.UeHHOe HCCJieJJ.OBaHHe Il03BOJll!eT Ha npHMepe KpaCHORpCKOro Kpall nOJJ.TBepJJ.HTb Haw Te3HC 06 OTHOCHTeJibHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH pOCCHHCKOro 061J.1,eCTBa H BblCOKOf:i 3Ha"IHMOCTH nOJJHTH'leCKHX cl>aKTopoB JJ.JI.11 cra6HJibHOCTH COBpeMeHHOro poCCHHCKOfO o6mecTBa. IlpH 3TOM KpacHol!pcKHH Kpaf:i HaxOJJ.HTC.R B 6onee 6naronpHRTHOH o6cmuosKe "leM MHorne JJ.pyrne cy6'beKTbl ct>eJJ.epau.HH. B TO )f{e speM.11 col.l,HanbHall cHryau,HR, CJJO)f{HBWMC.R s CTPaHe, HaKJia.ui,rnaeTCR Ha HCCJie.11.YeM1>1f;i pernott, '!TO Il03BOJilleT C"IHTaTb ero OTHOCHTeJJbHO CTa6HJibHblM. EcTb sepO!!THOCTb, "!TO TaKM CTa6HJJbHOCTb HeceT B ce6e yrpo- 3y B OTJJ.aneHHOM 6yJJ.YI1.1,eM. )J;pyrnMH CJIOBaMH,CTa6HJlbHOCTh, CKJiaJJ.blBa!Oll.lMCJI nepe"IHCJieHHblMH MeTO.UaMH, .uaeT 6blCTPbie pe3yJibTaTbl B C03tI,aHHH ycTOH'IHBOCTH, HO co speMeHeM OHa )f{e MO)l(eT BblCTYilHTb .uecrafolJIH3aTOpOM H3-3a HCllepnaHHJI npHpOJJ.HhlX pecypcos, HapacTaHHR Hetx.OBOJlbCTBa co CTOpOHbl HaceneHHJI, "lbH noJJHTHqecKHe B3rJillJJ.bl, CHCTeMa ueHHOCTeH H JJ.OXOJJ. He YKJia.UblBalOTCR B ct>opMHpyeMyro Mo.neni, cTa6HJJbHOCTH. Oco- 6eHHO OCTPO 3Ta npo6neMa MO)f{eT npOl!BHTbC.11 B CBJl3H c rpRJJ.yll.l,HM 3neKTopan1>HhlM U.HKJJO M. Ha tx.aHHblH MOMeHT npetx.OTBpamaTb yrpo3y CTa6HJihHOCTH pOCCHHCKOro 06- mecTBa He06XO.llHMO c IlOMOll.l,blO C03.ll.aHHJI 6naronpHllTHblX ycnoeHH JJ.Jill yseJIHlleHHll cpe.nHero KJiacca H Manoro 6H3Heca qepe3 3KOHOMH"leCKHe H npaBOBble Mepbl, KOHueHTPal..l,HIO Ha IlOJIHTHlleCKHX ct>aKTOpax CTa6HJlblWCTH , oco6eHHO Ha pa3BHTHH nOJIHTH"leCKHX HHCTHryTOB, rpaJKtx.aHCKOro o61l.1,ecTBa 11 CTPaTerH'le CKOM ynpaBnemrn. TaKHM o6pa30M,o6c .naR ct>opMHposaHHe rpaJKJJ.aHCKoro o6mecTBa B pocCHHCKO H JJ.eHCTB HTeJlbHOCTH, BaJKHO OTMeTHTb BbICOKYJO 3HallHMOCTb aKTHBHOCTH He CTOJibeO BJiaCTHblX HHCTHryTOB, CKOJlbKO caMHX rpaJKJJ.aH, Ha KOTOpblX Jie)f{HT BblCOKa.R OTBeTCT BeHHOCTb nepe.u 6y