Политические факторы стабильности современного Российского общества (на примере Красноярского края)

Аннотация

Oc<1eUJe11a npo6neMa nonumu'lecKwc cjJaKmopoa pezuoHanbHOU cma6W1bHocmu . flollb3YRCb MemooaMu 3KcnepmHo zo onpoca u aHanU3a UHOUKamopoa, aamop o6'bRCHRem npupooy cma6wrbHocmu 11a npUMepe KpacHoRpcK ozo KpClJl. Oco6ClJl pOllb 6 noooep:>K:aHUU cma6wrbHOCmu omaeoeua peZUOHaJlbHblM nonumu'leCKUM UHcmumymaM .

Полный текст

B nocne.QHHe rO.!lbl B cospeMeHHOM pocc11iicKOM 06- w.ecTBe Ha6mo.Qa10TCll .Qosep11e HaceneH11l! BnacTH, noBb1llleH11e ypos1·rn )l(HJH11, KOHcon11.QaUHll BOKpyr e.Q11Horo ueHTPa ynpasnemrn 11 MHoroe .!lpyroe, cornacHo 'IeMy MO)l(HO 61>mo 61>1 JaKnJO'IHTb , 'ITO nocne Kpm11ca 90-x ycTaHoei.rnacb cTa611n1>HOCTb. TeM He Mettee, o6c .QaeMM CTa611JJbHOCTb no HarneMy MHem110 l!BfljleTCll OTHOC11TeJJbHOH. ,n:eno B TOM, 'ITO B OCHOBe pocc1odkKolt CTa- 611JibHOCT11 Jie)l(11T M11pOBM 3KOHOMJ.ll{eCKM KOH'blOHKTypa ueH Ha OCHOBHbie npHpO.!lHbie pecypCbl, a He 3<l><l>eKT11BHOe CTPaTern'IecKoe ynpaBneHHe,a no I1pJ.ll{HHe HeycTOH'IHBOCTH 3TOit KOlfblOHKTypbl, 3KOHOMH'IeCKM 11 COUHanbHM CTa6HJibHOCTb o6w.ecrea MO)l(eT 6b!Th HapyrneHa. Oco6oe Mecro np11 aHam13e crn611JibHOCT11 JaH11Ma10T nomnH•teCK He <t>aKTOpbl,nOHHMaeMbie aBTOpOM KaK noJIHTH'IeCKHe .!lBH)l(yll(He CHJibl CTa6HJJH3aUHOHHbIX npoueccoe, irnneHHe HJIH npouecc, 06ycnaeJ111ea10w.11e cHcTeMoo6paJyJOume H C11CTeMOH3MeHlllOW.He TeH.QeHUHH B o6mecTBeHHOH CHCTeMe [l; 2]. IlOJJl1TH'IeCKHM11 <t>aKTOpaMH CTa611JlbHOCTH o6w.ecTBa .RBJJ.RIOTCll nOJIHTH'IeCKHe HHCTHTYTbI, np1106peTa10w.11e cneuH<i>HKY B 3as11cHMOCTH OT 11ccne,QyeMo ro pernoHa (o6w.ecTBa) , a TaK)l(e 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTb H Jier11Tl1MHOCTb BJiaCTH, npo.RBJl.RIOW.MC.R B itCTBHllX HHCTHTYTOB 11 ypOBHe .!lOBepm1 K HHM co CTOpOHblHaceneHHll. B .naHHOH CTaTbe oTpa)l(eHbl pe3ynbTilTb1 3Mn11p11'IecKoro 11CCJie.QOBaHH.R, npoBe.QeHHOro aBTOpOM neTOM 2006 r. B KpacHOllpcKoM Kpae1 11 aHanma p.R.na HH.!lHKaropos, no3BOJl.R!Oll..\HX oueHHTb COU11aJlbHyJO CTil6HJibHOCTb. B COUHOJIOrHH no.Q HH.!l11KaTopaM11 noHHMalOTCll 3MnHpH'ICCKHe nOKaJaTeJIH npH3HaKa H3Mep.R eMoro o6'beKTa [3]. Cne.QoBaTeJJ bHO, HH.U.HKaTOpb1 cTa611n1>HOCTH o6w.eCTBa - 3TO 3MnHpHtteCKHe xapaKTepHCTHKH CTa6HJlbHOCTH. KpaTKo nepe'I11cn11M xapaKTep11cT11K11 couHanbHbIX npoueccoB, KOTOpble MOryT 6b1Tb B3.RTbl 3a OCHOBY aHaJIH3a COUHaJJbHOH CTa6HJJhHOCT11: cou11an1>Ha .R m1<t><t>epeHu 11au11.R, couHanhHa.R nom1p- HOCTb, CTpant<l>HK aU11.R o6w.ecTBa; rpa)f(.QaHcKoe o6mecTBo, nonHrn'IeCKOe Y'Iacrne; ueHHOCTl1 l{JleHOB o6w.ecTBa; OTCYTCTBHe BOOp eHHbIX, HaUHOHaJJhHblX H non11- THtteCK l1X KOH<i>JJ11KTOB ; Y'iaCTHe cy6'beKTa <Pe.nepau11H B <t>opMHposamm 610.n)f(eTa CTPaH1>1 11 .np. B Ka'IeCTBe MeTo.Qa H3Y'ieHHll poJIH noJJHTH'Ie CKHX <t>aI<TopoB B no.n,nep)l(amrn COUHaJJbHOit CTa6HJlhHOCTH B KpacHO.RpCKOM Kpae 6brn Bb16paH KattecTBeHHbllt MeTO.!l 3KcnepT Horo onpoca. B Ka'IecTBe 3KcnepTOB Bb1crynan11 CTaTYCH1>1e npe.ncTaBHTenH HaY'iHOro coo6w.ecTBa, JaKoHO.D.aTeJJhHOH 11 HCITOJlHHTeJJhHOH BJiaCTH: 3aee.Q)'IOW.He Ka<t>e.npaMH Bb1c w11x Y'Ie6HbTX 3ase.neHHH, npo<t>eccopa; .nenYTaTbl 3aKoHo.naTeJJbHoro co6paH11.R Kpall; PYKOBO.D.H- TeJJH 11 cneu11an11CTbl .nenapTaMeHTOB a.QMl1Hl1CTpau1111 Kpal!. IlepBhie CJ10)f(HJ111Ch B TaKHX o6naCTllX Hay'IHOro 3HaHHll, KaK cou11onorl1ll, I1Cl1XOJIOfH.R, qmnoco<P11ll, 3KOHOMl1Ka 11 KOH<l>JJ11KTOJIOrHll,H B CBOeit HaY'IHOH .nel!TeJJhHOCTH He MOrnl1 He o6pau aTbC.R K npo6JieMe .uaHHOro HCCne.uoBaHHll. "llTO KacaeTC.R 3KCnepTOB OT BJJaCTH, TO 3<l><l>eKTHBHOCTh HX pa60Tbl HanpllMyJO BJJH.ReT Ha o6w.eCTBeHHyJO CTa611JlbHOCTb. 06w.ee KOJJH'IeCTBO 3Kc nepTOB COCTaBl1Jl0 14 'IeJJOBeK (7 Y'ieHblX 11 7 npe.ncTaBHTeJleH BJlaCTH), 'ITO llBJllleTC.R penpe3eHTaTHBHblM .ZlJlll Ka'leCTBeHHOro 11ccne.nosaHHll. ,lVIll no.nTBep)f(.ZleHHll BbI.!lBHHyThix rnnoTe3 Mhl 6y.neM u11rnpoBaT1> HaH6onee xapa1<Tep H1>1e BhlCKa3hIBaHHll 3KcnepTOB OTHOCHTeJlbHO npe.D.MeTa HCCJie)J.OB aHHll (B .naHHOH CTaThe Mbl 6y.neM YKaJhIBaTb JIHWb HOMep, no.n KOTOphlM npOXO)J.HT onpaw11eaeMhlH, 11 ero np11Ha.nne)l(HOCTh K enacrn (s.) 11n11 HaY'IHOMY o6w.eCTBY (H.)). ITp11op1neTHhIM HanpasneH11eM 11ccne.nosaH11si CTano BhlllBJieH11e nOJIHT11'1eCKl1X <t>aKTOpOB, 1103BOJJlllOll..\11X pernoHy 61>n1> cTa611n1>HbTM. IT01111MaH11e crn611n1>uocrn B .QaHHOM HCCJJe.11,0BaHHH 6y.neT nOl!CHeHO HH)f(e. l.J,enecoo6paJHo cTh B1>16opa HMeHHO 3Toro penmHa o6ycnosneHa KattecTBaMH, np11n11c1>rnaeMhIMH eMy 3KCnepTHhIM (nomnonornqecKHM H COUHOJ!OrH'leCKHM) coo6mecTBOM,- B03MO)l(HOCThlO B MHHHaT!Ope npocne.nHTh 11 cnporno3HpoeaTh HeK0Top1>1e npoueccb1, xapaKTepH1>1e .ZlJlll Pocc11iicKoit <I>e.nepau.1111 B uenoM, T. e. npoeecrn attan113 cnt611n1>HOCT11 11ccne.nyeMoro pernoHa 11 3KCTPanon11poBaTh BbIBO.U.hl Ha BCe poCCHHCKOe o6w.ecTBo. KpaCHOllpCKHit KpaH caM no ce6e HHTepeceH CBOHMH oco6eHHOCTllMl1, Bhl3BaHHblMl1 orpoMHOit 3aHHMaeMOH TeppHTOpHeH, 6oraTCTBOM np11po.nHhlX pecypcoe H 11HBeCTHUHOHHOH np1rnneKaTeJ11>HOCThlO. He Mettee Ba)l(HO 11 TO, t.tTO, HCCJie,Qyll COUHaJJhHyJO CTafolJlhHOCTb, Heo6xo.QHMO o6cy)l()J.aTh He o6mecTBO B uenoM, TaK KaK ITOH.RTHe o6w.ecTBa caMo no ce6e ecTh a6cTPaKUH.R , a KOHKpeTHyJO COUHaJJhHYIO HJIH nOJl11Tl1'IeCKyJO CHCTeMy, ececTOpOHHee HCCJJe.QoeaHHe KOTOpOH Ha116onee peneeaHTHO Ha ypOBHe pernoHa. B Ka'IecTBe nonwrntteCK HX <t>aKropoe crn611n1> HOCTH pernoHa aHaJJH3Y no.QeeprnHCh nonHTH'leCKHe HHCTHryThl, KOTOp1>1e Hepa3phIBHO CBl!3aHbl c 3<l><l>eKTHBHO CThlO H nerHTHMHOCThlO BJiaCTH. IlepeXO.nll K aHaJIH3Y HH.11,HKaTOpoe CTa6HJihHOCTH, Heo6xo.nHMO OTMeTHTh, 'ITO nOJIHhle .naHHble 0 COUHaJJhHOit CTparn<t>11Kauw11 B KpacHosipcKoM Kpae OTCYTCTByJOT, o.nHaKo, ee MO)l(HO npocnemnb no c<l>epaM, B KOTOp1>1x JaH.RTO HaceneHHe, ypOBHIO .!lOXO.QOB, 6e3pa6ornue H coUHaJihHOH nonllpHocrn. YposeHh 6e3pa6ornu1>1 B pernoHe no .naHHhIM ynpasneHHll <I>e.u.epanbHOH rocy.napcTBeHHOit cny)l(61>1 JaH.RTOCTH no KpacHo.RpCKOMY Kpa!O K 2005 r. OTHOCHTeJlhHO npOWJlblX neT CHH3HJIC.R Ha 20 % 11 B cpe.ntteM no Kpa!O COCTaBHJl 3'I %, '{TO HH)f(e cpe.nm1x noKaJaTenett no CH6HpCKOMY <1>0 (3,3 %). BecmHuK Cu6upcKozo zocyoapcmBem1ozo a3poKocMu'leCKozo YHUBepcumema UMeuu aKaOeMuKa M </J. PeUJemHeBa image Ecm1 )!(e cpaBHHBaTh ypoaeHh 6e3pa6ornuh1 c 2004 r., TO OHa CHH3HJlaCh Ha 2 %. Mb! CBll3bJBaeM 31)' TeH,lleHUHIO c peanH3auHei1 pll.lla KpynHhIX HHBeCTHUHOHHhIX npoeKTOB Ha TeppHTOpHH Kprui (cM. KoHueHUHIO Kopnopaumt pa3BHTHll KpacHol!pcKoro Kpall Ha o<t>HUHMhHOM YIHrepHeT-nopTa11e «KpacHollpCKHH Kpaii» (http:// www.krskstate.ru) , 'ITO HaXO,llHT nO,llTBCp)!(,lleHHe B CJ!OBax 3KCnepTOB: «Ham Kpali CTaHOBHTCJI Bee 6onee CTa- 6HJibHblM. H .llJlll 3Toro eCTh 061.eKTHBHhie noKaJareJIH. Kor,lla Mb! roBOpHM 06 HHBeCTHUHOHHOH npHBJieKaTeJibHOCTH pernoHa, TO OtteHb COJIH.llHhie HHBeCTOpbl B nepB)'IO ottepe,llb paccMaTPHBalOT B03MO)!(HOCTb BJIO)!(eHHll CBOHX HHBeCTHUHH C TO'IKH 3peHHJI 3KOHOMHtteCKOH CTa- 6HJlhHOCTH. Haw Kpaii no peiiTHHry 3a nocne.llHHe .llBa ro.lla no.llHllJ!Cll Ha napy czyneHeK BBepx, T. e. Ha,lle)!(HOCTh 3KOHOMHtteCKru!, 6y.lleM rOBOpHTh, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb nepe.ll TeMH HHBeCTOpaMH , KOTOpble 6y,llyT H e BKJia,llb!Ba!OT pecypCbl B Ham Kpaii, n03BOJlll!OT HM C,lle- 11an, TaKOH BblBO.ll. 3TO npH3HaHO Ha TpeTheM pOCCHHCKOM HHBeCTHUHOHHOM <t>opyMe, KOTOpblH npoBO.llHJ!Cll B HarneM ropo.lle» (3KcnepT J-12 1, H.). . ,A.nll Toro 4T06bl He CJlO)!(HJlaCh o6paTHall CHl)'aUHll - ,lle<t>HUHTa pa60THHKOB, KpaH yttaCTByeT B nporpaMMe 1 cpe.nHero KJiacca. Ou Hepa3pbIBHO CBJl3aH c COUHMbHOi1 CTa6HJibHOCTblO H MO)!(eT no npaay C"IHTaTbCR 0.llHHM H3 8a)f(HhlX <t>aKTOpOB CTa6HJibHOCTH, a ero HaJIHttHe JIBJIReTCll HH.llHKaTOpOM o6mecTBeHHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH . Ilo coUHaJlhHOH CTPaTH<l>HKaUHH MO)!(HO CY.llHTb 0 COCTORHHH o6mecTBa, ypOBHe ero pa3BHTHJI H CTa6HJIH3aUHOHHbIX npoueccax. Pa3BHToe cTa6HJibHoe o6rnecTBo npe.nnonaraeT MaJI)'IO "IHCJieHHOCTb 6e.llHOro u 6oraToro HaceneHHll, H 60JiblllOH npoueHT rpa)l(,llaH co cpe.llHHM .llOXO.llOM H ypoaHeM )f(H3HH. Cnpoc Ha cneuuanHCTOB c BhICIIIHM o6- pa3oeaHHeM B npOMbHUJieHHOM ceKTope, .llOCTOHHru! onnaTa TaKoro TPY.lla no3BOJlllT 3Ha"IHTeJibHO no.ll.llep)f(aTb u ,lla)f(e yaeJIH"IHTb cpe.llHHH KJiacc, B TOM "IHCJie H 3a C"leT MHrpaUHH. Ilpo6JieMy OTTOKa KBanu<t>uuupoBaHHbIX MOJIO.llblX cneuHanHCTOB H3 pernoHa npH3BaHa pernHTh nporpaMMa «3onoToi1 Ka.npoBhlH pe3epB KpacHoiipcKoro Kpall». HanHttHe 3<l><l>eKTHBHbIX anacTHbIX HHCTHl)'UHOHanbHbIX MexaHH3MOB JIBJIJleTCJI OCHOBOH CTa6HJibHOCTH, no- 3BOJIJIIOIUCH o6mecTBy pa3BHBaThCR, He Bb!XO.!lR 3a npe.llCJlbl CTPYKTYPHOH ycToiittHBocrn cHcTeMbI KaK ue11oro (2), nOCKOJlbKY caMa npHpO,lla nOJIHTH"leCKHX HHCTHT)'TOB HeceT B ce6e cTa611nu3au110HHh1e MexaHH3MbJ. K nonHTHnepece11eHHJ1 cooretteCTBeHHHKOB . KpacHollpCKHH Kpaii qecKHM HHCTHl)'TaM OTHOCJITCJI HHCTHT)'Tbl BJiaCTH H yttaeorne11 B caMyio 611aronpHllTHYJO no co,lleHCTBHIO nepeceJlll!OIUHMCll B MHrpaUHH KaTeropH!O A H, CJle,llOBaTeJihHO, yttaCTHHKaM 6y,llyT KOMneHCHpOBaHh l 3aTPaTbl Ha npoe3,ll, Bh1nnatteHo e,llHHOBpeMeHHOe noco6ue H 6y.lleT npe.llJlo)!(eHo apeH.llOBaTh KBaprnpy HJIH aczynan. e nporpaMMhI unoTettuoro Kpe.llHTOBaHHll . HeKOTOph1e paiioHhI roTOBhI npe.llOCTaBHTh 3eMeJlbHhlH yttaCTOK no.ll CTPOHTeJihCTBO co6cTBeHHoro .llOMa. KpacHollpCKHH Kpai:f, TaKHM o6pa30M, J1BJIJ1eTCJ1 nepcneKTHBHhIM H HllBCCTHUHOHHO np1rnneKaTeJlhHblM perHOHOM c nocTOJIHHO pacryIUHM ypOBHeM )!(H3HH HaceneHHJI, 11 TeH.neHUHll poCTa .llOXO.llOB HaceneHHJI B CBeTe rpll.nym11x npoeKToB .llOJI)!(Ha coxpaHHThCR. Ho Heo6xO.llHMO OTMeTHTh, '!TO pOCT .llOXO.llOB He OTMeHReT npo6neMy coUHaJlbHOH nom1pHOCTH . bOJlblllHHCTBO 3KCnepTOB Bb!pa- 3HJIH TPeBory OTHOCHTeJlbHO 3TOro BOnpoca: «He CKpOIO, 4TO eCTb otteHb MHOro <t>aKTopoB, KOTOpbie He .lla!OT 60JiblllOrO OCHOBaHHJI B ttaCTH CTa6HJlhHOCTH. JTO BCeM 113aecTHoe otteHb cepbe3Hoe paccnoeHHe B HarneM o6mecTBe no HMyiuecTBeHHhlM noKaJaTeJillM, Kor.na 6onee TPeTH HaceneHHJI Hawero Kpall <t>aKTH"leCKH )f(HBeT 3a qepTOH 6e.nHoCTH. H B ::irnx ycnoBHRX paccttHThIBaTh Ha BhICOKHH ypoBeHb CTa6HJibHOCTH He npHXO.llHTCll, ec11H .llaJlblile 6y.lleT coxpaHRTbCJI TaKaJI o6CTaHOBKa (3KCnepT N'!! 1, H.). Ec11u paccMaTPHBaTh TaKHe Ba)f(HeiirnHe npo6neMhI H yrpo3hl CTa6HJibHOCTH, KaK MaJI)'IO nJIOTHOCTb HaceneHHR , 6e3pa6ornuy, COUHaJlbH)'IO noniipHOCTb H np., TO B perHOHe OHH npucyrcTB)'IOT. Bonpoc, pernHT nu Kypc pa3- BHTHll pernoHa, npe.llJIO)!(eHHhIH a.nMHHHCTpauHeii KpacHoiipcKoro Kpaii, .naHHbie npo6neMhI, HJIH eme 6onhme yc11JIHT pa3pbIB Me)f(.llY 6oraThIMH H 6e.llHhIMH, ocTaeTCJI OTKpb!TbIM. Ilpe,llnOJiaraeM, "ITO COUHaJlbHbie npo611eMbl MOryr pa3pernHTbCR c <t>opMHpOBaHHeM H no.ll.llep)f(KOH CTHR. B Kpae 3a .llOnrne rO.llbI c<t>opMHpoaanncb H .nei1CTB)'IOT TaKHe HHCTHT)'Tbl BJiaCTH, KaK 3aKOHO,llaTeJihHOe co6paHHe Kpacuol!pCKoro Kprui, BKJI10"la10mee 52 .llenyTaTa, H a.llMHHHCTPaUHll, COCTOJl!Uru! H3 COBeTa H ,llenapTaMeHTOB. Oco6oro BHHMaHHJI 3aCJIY)f(HBaeT HHCTHT)'T ry6epuaTOpcTBa. 3aKOHO.llaTeJibHOe co6paHHe .llelkTByeT B Kpae c 1993 r., 3a 3TO BpeMJI COCTaB H 'IHCJieHHOCTb npe.llbIJJ.Yll.IHX TPex C03hIBOB 3Ha"IHTeJibHO MeHiinucb. Ha 2 nocne.nm1x Bb16opax B 3aKOHO.llaTeJibHoe co6paHHe (3AKC) H3 npoIIIe.llWHX napTHH JIBHOe 60JlblllHHCTBO cocTaBHJ1a «E.llHHall Poccmrn (49,0 % - 25 .llenyraToa). TaK)!(e HMCIOTCJI KIIP<l> (15,7 % - 8), «CnpaBe.llJIHBM PocCHJI)) (9,9 % - 5), JI,I:(IlP (5,8 % - 3) " enc (3,9 % - 2). Yf3 51 ,llenyraTa B 3AKC npOillJIH 8 He3aBHCHMhIX , Bbl.llBHH)'ThIX H36HpaTeJlJIMH OKpyroB, no KOTOpbIM npoxo.llHJIH ,llaHHbie ,llenynThl (15,7 %). TaKoe COOTHOllleH11e noMHMO acero npoqero roBopHT o BCTPOeHHO CTH KpacHOllpCKoro Kpal! B CHCTeMY BepTHKaJIH BJiaCTH. Ecnu oueHHBaTb 3<l><l>eKTHBHOCTb 3aKOHO.llaTe JibHOro co6paHHll, TO 3aKOHOTBOptteCKaJI ,llellTeJibHOCTb Be,lleTCJI B Kpae Ha BblCOKOM ypOBHe no cpaBHCHHIO c .llpyrHMH pernoHaMH CTpaHbl, XOTJI 3KCnepTbl OT HaYKH BH.nRT Mano nOJlb3bl OT 3Toro opraHa, Ha3bIBaJI ero <<roaopHJJhHeH ». TaK, yMeCTHO npHBeCTH TaKOe BblCKa3bIBaHHe : «Be.llYIUal! pOJJb, KOHe"IHO, y HcnoJJHHTeJJbHOii anacTH. MecTHall 3aKOHO.llarenhHru! anacTb BJJHlleT cna6o. 0Ha He KOMneTeHTHa, noTOMY ttTo MacrnTa6 pa3BopattHaa10mHXCJ1 3,necb co6h1THi1 cymecTBeHHO Bbllle KOMneTeHUHH MeCTHOi:I 3aKOHO,llaTCJlbHOH BJJaCTH» (3KCnepT N'!! 11, H.). HHbie 3KcnepTHbie oueHKH .llaBanHCb HHCTHT)'TaMH 11cnonHHTeJJbHoH: anacrn. YIHrepecHo, 4TO ecnH Ha <t>e.nepanbHOM ypOBHe HHCTHT)'T npe3H,llCHTCTBa llBJllleTCll 3aJIOroM c-ra6HJlhHOCTH, TO B KpacHollpCKOM Kpae a co3HaHHH image I f1pH onpoce 3KCnepTOB B Jl.CKa6pe 2007 - JIJIBape 2008 rr. 6bll!a nonyqeHa HH<jlOpMaUHll 0 TOM,'!TO Ha .naHHbli-i MOMCHT 6bll! nepecenen ncero I '!enoaeK HJ 2 283, He C'IHTaJI 6 849 'IIICHOB ceMhH. 2 B1>16op&1 B 3aKOHo.naTenbHOe co6paHHe 'leTBepToro (nepaoro a o6oe.nHHCHHOM KpacHollpCKOM Kpae) coJbma npownH a KpacHoJ1pcKe 15 anpem1 2007 r. 205 <l>wioco</Jwi u COtfUOJIOZUJl image 3KcnepTOB coseT H .uenapraMeHTbI TPaHc<t>opMHpOBaJJHCb BJiaCTH H, cne.uoeaTeJibHO, ee nerHTHMHOCTH. )l(enaH11e , B etJ.HH}'lO «KOMaH.UY XnonoHHHa» 1 3<t><t>eKTHBHOH pa6oBJiaCTH JierHTHMHpoBaTbCll nopo)l(.llaeT HMe!Ol.t\YJOCll MOTOH KOTOpOH 3KCnepTbl H3 Hay<IHOro coo6mecTBa o6'bJICHl!IOT cra6HJibHYIO CHzyaUHIO B Kpae: «Cero,UHJI He CTOJibKO o6ecne•msaeT 3TY cTa6HJibHOCTb JIH'IHOCTb X110- noHHHa AJieKCaH.upa feHHa,UbeBH'la , CKOJlbKO KOMaH,Ua TeX JIJO,UeH, KOTOpbie c10.ua HanpaeJieHbl, 'laCTH'IHO Ha- 6paHbl H3 MeCTHbIX. B OCHOBHOM OHH see Ha CBOHX MecTax» (3KcnepT N!! 9, B.). Cneii.yeT paccMOTPeTb cnaraeMb1e 3<P<t>eKTHBHOCTH H JierHTHMHOCTH pernOHaJJbHOH BJiaCTH. 3Ha'IHMbIMH B .uaHHOM eonpoce, nOMHMO npoqero, l!BJIJllOTCR aBTOpHTeT ry6epHaTopa H ero JIOl!JlbHOCTb ueHTpy, '!TO BJIHJleT Ha peweHHe MHornx aonpocoa, .urui<e TaKHX, KaK onpe.ueneHHe Kpall n11oma.UKOH .UJIJI peaJJH3aUHH H.lleH C03,UaHHR HauHOHaJJbHoro yHHBepcHTera. Tio.nTBep)l(.ueHHe 3TOMY MbI Haxo.nHM a oueHKe 3Kcnepra N2 l(H.): «IlpeTeH.neHTOB 6bIJIO MHOro, B TOM 'IHCJie HoBOCH6HpCK , 11PKYTCK, ToMCK , HO, He B nocJie,UHIOIO O'lepe.ub, no.u BJIHJIHHeM aaTOpHrera Hawero ry6epHaTOpa eonpoc 3TOT 61>1J1 peweH B noJib3Y KpacHOl!pcKa». He TOJibKO 3TOT CJI)"laH roaopHT 06 Hcnon1>3oBaHHH Kpall .llJIJI anpo6aUHH H JierHTHMaUHH pa3HOro po.ua HOBOBBe,UeHHH. 3Ha'IHMblMH BexaMH, onpe.ueJIHBWHMH .UaJJbHeAwy10 nonHTHKY pernoHa H HaMeTHBWHMH KYPC .llJlll cj>e.uepaUHH, CTaJJH <t>aKTl-fl{eCKOe HaJHa'!eHHe ry6epHaTOpa H o6'be.UHHeHHe KpacHollpCKoro Kpall, 3eeHKHAcKoro H Tai1Mb1pcKoro aeTOHOMHbIX oKpyroa. B KpacH011pcKoM Kpae Mb! MO)l(eM Ha61110.uaTb 3<t>¢eKTHBHYJO peaJJH3aUHIO JierHTHMaUHH nOJIHTH'leCKOrO pe)l(HMa B CTpaHe, Kor.ua ycHJIHBaeTCll aepTHKaJib BJiaCTH H BbICTpaHaaeTCJI ¢e.uepanH3M c CHJibHbIM ue1npanbHbIM ynpaaneHHeM. Bb1COKaJ1 JIBKa Ha pe¢epeHtJ.YM H o.uo6peHHe co CTOpOHbI rpruK.UaH o6'be,UHHeHHR 3aeHKHH, TaHMbipa H KpacHo.11pcKoro Kpall o6ycnoaneHbI nonHoueHHbIM HCnoJJb30BaHHeM a,UMHHHCTPaTHBHOro pecypca,Ha'IHHaJI OT BCTPe'I 3aMeCTHTeneA ry6epHaTopa c PYKOBO.UHTeJIJIMH o6mecTBeHHbIX opraHH3aUHH H o6'bllCHeHHJI HM nOJJb3bl OT 06'be,UHHeHHJI .no nepcOHaJibHblX HanOMHHaHHH 0 pecj>epeHii.yMe. PeweHHe 06 o6oe.uHHeHHH eczymUio B CHJIY c JIHBap.11 2007 r. H e npHHl!Ta nporpaMMa COUHaJibH0- 3KOHOMH'leCKOro pa3BHTHJI HOBOro cy6beKTa <t>e.uepauHH .no 2010 r. fipHopHTeTHblM HanpaaneHHeM 3Toro .uoKyMeHra JIBJJJleTCJI pa3BHTHe COUHaJJbHOH c¢epbl qepe3 npOMbIWJJeHHbIH ceKTop. B 'laCTHOCTH, a pernoHe peanH- 3yeTCJ1 npoeKT «KoMnJJeKcHoe pa3BHrne HH)l(Hero Tipttattrapbll», ueJJbJO KOToporo J1BJJJ1eTcJ1 co3,UaHHe Ha 06- WHpHoii MaJJOHaCeJJeHHOH TeppHTOpHH HOBOrO npOMbIWJJeHHOro paAoHa B BocTO'IHOii Ctt6Hp11. HecOMHeHHo , rnaBHbIH n03HTHBHbIH 3¢¢eKT OT o6'be,UHHeHHR .UOJJ)l(eH npOllBl1TbCJI B 6yii.ymeM B HHTerpauHH 3KOHOMHKH H ocBOeHHH MHOrO'll1CJJeHHblX pecypcoe. Kpati npHMe'laTeJJeH He TOJibKO TeM, '!TO 3.Uecb 3¢¢eKT11BHO peanHJyJOTCR KpynHble mrneCTHU.110HHbie npoeKTbI, HO H caoetl MOJIO,Ue)l(HOii noJIHTl1KOH . E)f(ero.UHbie KOHKypcbI, TaKl1e KaK «KM-<l>oPYM», «30JIOTOH Ka,UpOBbIH pe3epB» H «fy6epHaTopCKHH 6an», CTp011TeJibHble OTpll.llbl H npoqee npHBJieKaJOT BHl1MaH11e MOJIO,lle)l(H K pernoHaJJbHOH anacTH H o6mecTBeHHOH )l(lf3HH Kpall. CTeneHb COTPY.UHH'ICCTBa MOJIO,Ue)l(H c noJIHTH'leCKHMH HHCTHTYTaMH l!BJIJICTCJI Ba)l(HblM nOKaJaTeJieM .uoaepHll HaceJieHl1JI image 1 TaKoe 060JHa'le1rne BCTpe'!ae-rcl! y 90 % 3KcnepTOe. JIO,Ue)f(HYIO nOJIHTHKy. 11HCTHTYTbl y<1aCTl1JI MOryT HaJbIBaTbCR TaKOBblMH JIHIIlb ¢opMaJJbHO 113-3a ynpaBJIJleMOCTH co CTOpOHbl BJiaCTH H 6e3blHHUHaTHBHOCTH caMHX HapO,UHblX Mace, .UOKa- 3aTeJibCTBOM 'lero MO)f(eT C HTb pe¢epeHtJ.YM 06 o61>el1HeHHH KpacHoJ1pcKoro Kpall, 3aeHKHH H TaiiM1>1pa. Tip11 3TOM npecJie,UOBaJJHCb TaK11e ue1111,KaK, BO-nepBblX, ,llaJJbHeifwall OTC'fPOHKa H HaJiruKHBaHHe aepTHKaJJH BJiaCTH 3a C'leT peii.yuHpOBaHHll cy6oeKTOB ¢e.uepau11H, '!TO Il03BOJIReT C,UeJiaTb perHOHbl 6011ee ynpaBJI.lleMblMH, BOBTOpblX, 0611er'leHHe pa60Tbl npOMbIWJieHHOrO ceKTopa B CBJl3H c peaJIH3yeMOH npOKJia,UKOH He¢renpoao.ua H ocBOeHHeM TipHattraphR , B-TPeThHX, yc1111eHHe ,UOTaUHOHHblX ceeepHbIX pernoHOB 3a C'ieT pernoHa-.uoHopa . 3KcnepT1>1 a ceoHX oueHKax pe¢epeH,UYMa 111160 o.uo6pl!JIH H.lle!O 06'be,UHHeHHll, JIH60 OTHOCHJIHCb K 3TOMy HeHTPaJibHO. 11 Te, 11 .upyrne ccbIJiaJIHCb Ha TO, '!TO panbwe Kpatl 6b!JI e,UHHhIM, a npo113owe.uwee a 1992 r. paJbe.UHneHHe HeraTHBHO CKaJaJIOCb Ha pa3BHTHl1 pernoHa, Hapyw11B Hapa60TaHHbie CBJ1311. fipHBO.UHM HaH6011ee xapaKTepHhie oueHKH 3KcnepToa: «00oe,UHHeH11e xopowo .llJIJI 11HBecTOpOB 11 .llJlll Tex , KTO XO'leT pa3BOpa'111BaTb 6H3HCC Ha Tepp11rop1111 Kpall. YMeHhWaeTCl! KOJil1'1eCTBO cornacosaHl1H, HHCTaHuHA H 3TO ecer.ua 611aro, a, cne.uoaaTeJibHO, 11 06nerqaeTCJ1 HlleecTHUHOHHblH pe)l(11M H BCJie,U 3a 3KOHOMH'leCKHMH no- 3HTHBaMH npH,UeT H omymeHHe CTa611JibHOCTH» (::>KcnepT N!! 6, B.); <<3To O'leBl1,llHblH 3KOHOMl1'1eCKl1H pOCT H npHTOK HHBeCTHU1111, 3a KOTOpblMH nocne.uyeT pocT 610)DKeTa» (3KcnepT N2 7, a.). JIHWb 0,llHH 3KCnepT,npe,UCTaBJIR!Oll.(HH BJJaCTb (N!! 14), OTMCTl1JI npe)l(.ueapeMeHHOCTb KaKHX-JI1160 nporH030B H BbIBO.UOB OTHOCHTeJibHO npOH30we.uwero 06be,UHHeHl1ll: «fipoueccbI .uonroapeMeHHbie 11 nocne.ucTBHJI .uonro eme CKaJbIBaJOTCJI . 51 .nyMaJO, 'ITO noKa paHo roeopHTb. Cetlqac y Hae 11.ueT nepexo.UHbIH nepHO.ll, HO ecJIH roeopHTb 06 06'be,U11HeHHl1 TeKymHX npo6neM, TO 3,UeCb n0311Tl1BHOro MaJIO». Cpe.ntt p11cKoe HaJ1>rnaeTcJ1 npHcoe.ll.HHeHHe K HMe!Oll.lHMCJI npo6JieMaM ceeepHblX OKpyrOB. fIOMHMO a,UMHHHCTPaTHBHblX pecypcoa, ynOMllll)'TblX paHee, cpe.ucTBa Maccoaoti HH¢opMaUH11 TaK)l(e no npaay C'IHTaTbCJI pecypcoM,HCUOJib3YeMblM BJiaCTblO ,llJlll y.uep)f(aHl1ll ceoero CTazyca. PernoHaJihHbie cpe.ucTBa MaccoBOH HH¢opMaUHH He HBJIJllOTCJI caMOCTOl!TeJibHOH CHJI011 B )f(H3HH o6mecraa, a ueJIHKOM H IlOJIHOCTblO nO}lKOHTPOJibHbl enacrH. 3KcnepTbI o6bl!CHJIJOT cnoJKHBWYJOCll CHzyaumo OTC)'TCTBl1eM caMOCTOJITeJibHblX <t>HHaHCOBbIX 11CTO'IHHKOB ,llJIJI <l>HHaHCHpOBaHHJI onn03HUHOHHblX MHeHHH H napn1ii: «3.n.ech HeB03MOJKHO HMeTb raJezy HJIH pa.uHOCTaHUHJO Hano.uo6He «3xa MocKBbI» c He3aettcHMhIM ¢11HaHcHpoaaHHeM. Tio3TOMY co6cTBeHHO roeopll, ¢aKTop CTa6HJibHOCTH O.UHH - nOJIHaJI 3aBHCHMOCTb BCeH 3Jil1Thl 11 acew HH¢opMau110HHOH CTPYKTYPl>I OT enacTH» (3KcnepT N2 6). ,z:{eHCTBHR HHCTHTYTOB y<1aCTHJI MO)f(HO npOHJIJIIOCTpHpOBaTb Ha npHMepe .usyx KpynHhlX Kopnopau.1111 .ueHCTBYJOillHX Ha Tepp11ropHH Kpal! - PYCAJia H «HopHnbcKoro HHKCJIJI)). BecmHUK Cu6upcKozo zocyoapcmfJ eHHOW a3pOKOCMu11ecKozo yHu6epcumema UMeHu aKaOeMUKa M <P. Pezu emHefJa Eopi,6y Me)l(,ll,)' HHMH MO)f{HO 6bIJIO Ha6moJJ.aTb Ha ry- 6epHaTOpCKHX s1>16opax B 2002 r., KOrJJ.a OT PYCAJia KaHJJ.HJJ.aTOM 6hIJI Bhl.ll.BHttyT npeJJ.CeJJ.aTeJlb 3aKOHOJJ.aTeJlbHOro co6paHHll Kpall A. B. Yee, a OT «HopHHKeJJll» 6hIBWHH ron-MeHe.ll.)f{ep :noii KOMilaHHH, ry6epHaTOp TaHMblpCKOfO AO A. r. XJIOilOHHH. )J;eHCTBHJI cl>eJJ.e panbHOH BJlaCTH B OTHOllieHHH CJIO)f{HBWeHC.11 Ha TOT MOMeHT cHryal..l,HH, a, KaK H3BeCTHo, npe3HJJ.eHT PoccHH B. B. IlYTHH IlO.ll..ll.ep)f{an A. r. XnonOHHHa, n03BOJl!llOT .D.YMaTb,"!TO peanbHall nOJIHTH"leCKall 6opi,6a CBO.ll.HTC.11 K 6opi,6e 3JIHT Me)f{.D.Y co6ou 3a pecypci,1 BhIXOJJ.a Ha KpeMJJh . Iloc11e.uoBaTe111>Hoe BJJH.RHHe u,eHTPa Ha pernoH KOHCOJIH.UHpyeT nOJIHTH"leCKHe HHCTHTYTbl BOKpyr OJJ.HHX u.eneH, "!TO n03BOJI.ReT HM 6h1Tb 6onee 3<l>cl>eKTHBHblMH . )J;pyrHMH CJIOBaMH, nOJIHTH"leCKHM HHCTHryTaM Heo6xoJJ.HMO npH.uep)f{HBaTbC.11 OJJ.HOH noJIHTH"leCKOH JIHHHH. Ou,eHKY 3TOMY .uaeT 3KcnepT .N2 13 (s.): «Cra6HJIH3aU.Hll - Bell.l,h B3aHMOYB.R 3aHHall H npou.ecc CTa6HJIH3al.l,HH 3aBHCHT OT pa60Tbl Bcex noJIHTHlleCKHX HHCTHryTOB B eJJ.HHOH ynp!!)f{Ke H OTCYTCTBHH npoTHBOpe"IHH». J.h BCero CKa- 3aHHoro Bh!We MO)f{HO CJJ.eJiaTh BblBOJJ., llTO nOJIHTH"leCKHe HHCTHryTbl B COBOKynHOCTH c 3cl>cl>eKTKBHOCTblO H JJerHTHMHOCTblO BJJaCTH 3a.ua10T JJ.HHaMHKY CTa6HJIH3aU.HOHHblM npou.eccaM B o6mecTBe. AHanH3 nonHTH"leCKHX cl>aKTopoB 11 HHJJ.HKaropoB CTa6HJlbHOCTH nOKa3an, '!TO COU.HanbHall c11rya1.1,HJ1 B Kpae HeJJ.OCTaTO"IHO CTa6HJibHa, "!TO CTaBHT nOJJ. yrpo3y CTa- 6HJlbHOCTb perHOHa B u.enoM. 06paTHMCll K 3KCnepTHblM ou.eHKaM no .uaHHOMY eonpocy. Eon1>U1HHCTBO 3Kcnepros paccMaTPHBanH Kpaii KaK CTa6HJlhHblH c nonpaBKOH Ha TO, llTO 3Ta CTa6HJibHOCTb OTHOCHTeJlbHall: «B npHHU.Hne no poccHHCKHM MepKaM KpacHollpcKHH Kpau BXOJJ.HT B "IHCJIO CTa6HJibHblX perHOHOB . ,$1 61>1 CKa3an, "!TO perHOH JIBJJl!eTCJI OTHOCHTeJlhHO CTa6HJibHblM. y Hae B PoCCHH HH"lero cm6HJJbHoro ceiiqac HeT. Ho Kpaii no poccHliCKHM MepKaM cra6HJJbHblM JIBJilleTC.11)) (3KCnepT .N!! JO, H.). HeK0Top1>1e 3KcnepTb1 Bec1>Ma KareropHllHO no3HU.HOHHpoeanH perHOH KaK Hecra6HJlbHblH'. - «COU.HaJibHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH HeT, KOHe"IHO,KaK H BO eceii PoccHH. IloToMy "ITO, TaK )Ke KaK H BO Bceii PoccHH JJ.Hcnponop1..1,H.11 )f{YTKall no JJ.OXOJJ.aM HaceneHHll, no pacnpeJJ.eneHHIO 610JJ.)l(eTHb1x cpeJJ.CTB. B TOM •rncne H 06- mect>e.uepan1>Horo 610.u)f{eTa. )J;Hcnponopu.Hll 6011bwa.11 OlleHb no HHcl>paCTPYKTYPe . CpaBHHTh esponelicKyro qacTb••• TaK "ITO .D.aneKo .ll.O cTa6HJJhHOCTH. 11oToMy "ITO no.u CTa6HJlbHOCTblO Mb! Il0.ll.pa3yMeBaeM HeKHH CTaH.uapT. ,D;o rex CTaH.D.apTOB, KOTOp1>1e nponaraH.ll.HPYIOT HaM, O"leHb .ll.aJieKO» (3KCnepT .N2 6, B.). - «HbIHewH.11.11 c11ryau.H.11 B PocCHH npe.D.CTaBJI.ReT co- 6of:i BJiaCTb KOMnpa.D.OpCKO-Macl>H03HOH 6yp a3HH nJJIOC .D.eHH.ll.YCTPHaJIH 3au.m1 11 .D.e6HJJH3aU.H.R sceii CTPaH1>1. HH ll.HY npo6neMy, B TO llHCJie H B paMKax o6'b!IBJJeHHblX npoeKToB, pernHTh nocne.uoBaTeJ11>HO HeJih3ll B ycnoBHJIX cymecTBYIQ u.tHX OTHOWeHHH)) (3KCnepT .N!! 5,H.). I10Ka3aTeJJbHO, llTO npe.ucTaBHTeJIH HCilOJIHHTeJlbHOH snacTH qaru.e, "!eM npe.D.cTaBHTenH HayqHoro coo6mecTBa H snacrn 3aKOHO.ll.aTeJibHOH, CKJIOHHbI onpeJJ.eJillTb pernoH cTa6HJJbHhIM. Bepo.RTHee scero, xapaKTepH3Yll pernoH, OHH .ua10T ou,eHKY CBOeH pa6oTe, TaK KaK CTa6HJlbHOCTb o6mecTBa B 60JibllieH CTeneHH 3aBHCHT OT 3<l>cl>eKTHBHOCTH HX pa60Tbl. Bo3spamaRcb K pa3rosopy o cou,HanbHOH cTparncl>HKaU.HH, MO)l(HO CKa3aTh, "!TO Ha JJ.aHHb!H MOMeHT CTa6HJlbHOCTb pemoHa H BCeH PoCCHH JJ.ep)f{HTC.11 He Ha cpeJJ.HeM KJiacce B npHBblllHOH HHTepnpeTal.l,HH JJ.aHHOro nOH!ITHJI, TaK KaK OH MaJIOll!-fCJleH H 3aqacTY1Q He HHTepecyeTCJI noJIHTH"lecKof:i )f{H3Hhl0 CTPaH1>1, a Ha 60J11>UIHX Maccax HaceneHHll,qi,e o6pa3oBaHHe H JJ.OXOJJ.bl 3aqaCTY!O JJ.aneKH OT TPe6osaHHf:i , npeJJ.'h.RBJI.ReM1>1x K cpeJJ.HeMy KJJaccy. I1011HTH"!ecKall anaTHll cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca ycTpa11saeT KaK BJJaCTb, TaK H npeJJ.CTaBHTeneli' KJiacca. 110JIHTHKH 6ecKOHTPOJihHO 3aHHMa!OTC!I, lleM XOTRT ITO.LI. JJ03YfffOM «noJIHTHKOH JJ.OJI:lKHbl 3aHHMaTbCR npoct>ecCHOHaJib[)), a cl>HHaHCOBO ycnemHall qacTb cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca csoH 3acnyrn npHnHCblBaeT ce6e,a He nOJJHTH'!eCKOMY KypCy. B poccHHCKOH .D.eHCTBHTe111>Hocrn 06c JJ.aT1> BJIHRHHe .uaHHOH rpynnhl Ha IlOJIHTH"leCKHe H COU.HanbHb ie npou.eccbl 6eccM1>1cneHHO JJ.O Tex nop, noKa "IHCJJeHHOCTh cpeJJ.Hero KJiacca He COCTaBHT 60JJbllIHHCTBO H noKa He 3apa6ora10T MexattH3MhI rpaJKJJ.aHcKoro o61l.1,ecTBa. A noKa s Pocc1rn 60111>Uiall qacTh )f{HTenett HaxOJJ.RTC.R 3a qepTOH 6eJJ.HOCTH H BeJIHKa IlOJIRpHOCTb Me)f{.ll.Y Kpaf:iHHMH IlOKa- 3aTeJI.RMH CTPaTHcl>HKaU.HH poccHHCKoro 061J.1.eCTBa IlpoBe.UeHHOe HCCJieJJ.OBaHHe Il03BOJll!eT Ha npHMepe KpaCHORpCKOro Kpall nOJJ.TBepJJ.HTb Haw Te3HC 06 OTHOCHTeJibHOH CTa6HJibHOCTH pOCCHHCKOro 061J.1,eCTBa H BblCOKOf:i 3Ha"IHMOCTH nOJJHTH'leCKHX cl>aKTopoB JJ.JI.11 cra6HJibHOCTH COBpeMeHHOro poCCHHCKOfO o6mecTBa. IlpH 3TOM KpacHol!pcKHH Kpaf:i HaxOJJ.HTC.R B 6onee 6naronpHRTHOH o6cmuosKe "leM MHorne JJ.pyrne cy6'beKTbl ct>eJJ.epau.HH. B TO )f{e speM.11 col.l,HanbHall cHryau,HR, CJJO)f{HBWMC.R s CTPaHe, HaKJia.ui,rnaeTCR Ha HCCJie.11.YeM1>1f;i pernott, '!TO Il03BOJilleT C"IHTaTb ero OTHOCHTeJJbHO CTa6HJibHblM. EcTb sepO!!THOCTb, "!TO TaKM CTa6HJJbHOCTb HeceT B ce6e yrpo- 3y B OTJJ.aneHHOM 6yJJ.YI1.1,eM. )J;pyrnMH CJIOBaMH,CTa6HJlbHOCTh, CKJiaJJ.blBa!Oll.lMCJI nepe"IHCJieHHblMH MeTO.UaMH, .uaeT 6blCTPbie pe3yJibTaTbl B C03tI,aHHH ycTOH'IHBOCTH, HO co speMeHeM OHa )f{e MO)l(eT BblCTYilHTb .uecrafolJIH3aTOpOM H3-3a HCllepnaHHJI npHpOJJ.HhlX pecypcos, HapacTaHHR Hetx.OBOJlbCTBa co CTOpOHbl HaceneHHJI, "lbH noJJHTHqecKHe B3rJillJJ.bl, CHCTeMa ueHHOCTeH H JJ.OXOJJ. He YKJia.UblBalOTCR B ct>opMHpyeMyro Mo.neni, cTa6HJJbHOCTH. Oco- 6eHHO OCTPO 3Ta npo6neMa MO)f{eT npOl!BHTbC.11 B CBJl3H c rpRJJ.yll.l,HM 3neKTopan1>HhlM U.HKJJO M. Ha tx.aHHblH MOMeHT npetx.OTBpamaTb yrpo3y CTa6HJihHOCTH pOCCHHCKOro 06- mecTBa He06XO.llHMO c IlOMOll.l,blO C03.ll.aHHJI 6naronpHllTHblX ycnoeHH JJ.Jill yseJIHlleHHll cpe.nHero KJiacca H Manoro 6H3Heca qepe3 3KOHOMH"leCKHe H npaBOBble Mepbl, KOHueHTPal..l,HIO Ha IlOJIHTHlleCKHX ct>aKTOpax CTa6HJlblWCTH , oco6eHHO Ha pa3BHTHH nOJIHTH"leCKHX HHCTHryTOB, rpaJKtx.aHCKOro o61l.1,ecTBa 11 CTPaTerH'le CKOM ynpaBnemrn. TaKHM o6pa30M,o6c .naR ct>opMHposaHHe rpaJKJJ.aHCKoro o6mecTBa B pocCHHCKO H JJ.eHCTB HTeJlbHOCTH, BaJKHO OTMeTHTb BbICOKYJO 3HallHMOCTb aKTHBHOCTH He CTOJibeO BJiaCTHblX HHCTHryTOB, CKOJlbKO caMHX rpaJKJJ.aH, Ha KOTOpblX Jie)f{HT BblCOKa.R OTBeTCT BeHHOCTb nepe.u 6y