Gaps in Russian Legislation

Peer-review research journal issued 7 times a year.

Publisher

Editor-in-chief

  • Vladimir Vs. Chistyakov, Professor, Publishing House «Yur-VAK», Moscow, Russian Federation

About

The editorial policy of the Publishing House «Yur-VAK» is based on the principles formulated by the Committee on Publication Ethics and complies with the Code of Ethics for Scientific Publications of non-profit organization «Committee on the Ethics of Scientific Publications». All articles published in the journal undergo double peer review, and are also checked by the Anti-Plagiarism program at the RSCI and RSL bases. Detailed review rules are presented on the website of the Publishing House «Yur-VAK» www.urvak.ru.

The journal publishes peer-reviewed scientific articles on the following scientific specialty:

  • Jurisprudence

The journal is published with the participation of:

  • Lomonosov Moscow State University
  • Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA)
  • Moscow State Institute of International Relations (University) of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia
  • Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation

Indexation

In accordance with the decision of the Presidium of the Higher Attestation Commission of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia dated 12.28.2018, the journal «GAPS IN RUSSIAN LEGISLATION» is included in the List of leading peer-reviewed scientific journals and publications in which the main scientific results of dissertations for the degree of candidate and doctor of sciences should be published (http://vak.ed.gov.ru/).

  • Russian Science Citation Index (RSCI)
  • East View Information Services
  • Ulrichsweb Global Periodicals Directory
  • CrossRef
  • Dimensions
  • Google Scholar

 

最新一期

开放存取 开放存取  受限制的访问 ##reader.subscriptionAccessGranted##  受限制的访问 订阅存取

卷 18, 编号 3 (2025)

完整期次

开放存取 开放存取
受限制的访问 ##reader.subscriptionAccessGranted##
受限制的访问 订阅存取

Theoretical and Historical Legal Sciences

The concept of "legal fact" in the theory of tort law
Vavilin M., Osipenko A.
摘要

The purpose of the study. This article examines the scientific problem of the relationship between the concepts of the theory of tort law and the concept of "legal fact". The theory of tort obligations, which was formed in the bosom of Roman law, paid more attention to the elaboration of issues of legal protection of violated rights of the parties, while the concept of "tort" has not yet been finalized. Turning to the origins of the origin of this Latin word, it should be noted another important and forgotten meaning of "mistake", and not just a misdemeanor or offense. This understanding most accurately reflects the essence of tort in civil law. An incorrect action or thought is an error in the interpretation of modern dictionaries. Introduced into scientific circulation by the Dutch lawyer Hugo Grotius, the concept of general tort has transformed into the legislation of the world. It is also contained in art. 1064 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. It should be noted that the general tort itself includes in its content a whole range of legal facts that are both civil law torts and generate torts. The article discusses the issues of understanding a legal fact as a legal situation reflected in law. Conclusions. Thus, the described approach is successful. It is proposed to classify the legal facts arising in sensitive civil law relations, depending on the presence of damage, and also the chain-sequence of generation of legal facts in tort law is derived.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):11-16
pages 11-16 views
The history of the emergence and consolidation of the concept of national security in the legislation of Russia and foreign countries: historical and legal research
Gusaim I., Petrov D., Dmitriev E.
摘要

Globalization and the rapid development of technology, the concept of national security is becoming increasingly relevant both for Russia and for many foreign countries. National security covers a wide range of issues related to the protection of the interests of the State, society and citizens from various threats, both internal and external. Historically, the concept of national security has undergone significant changes, from ancient times to the present day. The importance of studying it is undeniable, since it affects not only military aspects, but also economic, social, cultural and environmental factors that can affect the stability and development of the state. In the course of the study, the authors identified the following features of the Russian national security strategy and its differences from other countries. Our country focuses on protecting vital priorities, internal security, territorial integrity and territorial order, focusing on the comprehensive protection of the interests of the country, its citizens and society. While unfriendly countries such as the United States, Great Britain, Germany, France, the Republic of Korea and Japan focus their attention on countering external and internal threats through the prism of interference in the private lives of citizens.

As a result of the research conducted by the authors, it can be said that studying the history of the emergence and consolidation of the concept of national security in the legislation of Russia and foreign countries is an important step towards understanding modern realities and threats facing states. This research not only enriches theoretical knowledge in the field of law and international relations, but also opens up new horizons for the practical application of acquired knowledge in the field of security.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):17-34
pages 17-34 views
Digital educational platforms in modern Russian legal regulation (some features of terminology)
Pogodin A., Turov G.
摘要

The purpose of the research. In modern society, such a social phenomenon as digital educational platforms is gaining a significant place. In Russia, two social trends can be identified in the field under consideration: on the one hand, online training («motivational») courses are being distributed from individuals and, in particular, bloggers, who are negatively assessed in society both from the perspective of ethical norms and from the perspective of law, on the other hand, business entities, Interested in a high-quality product in a competitive environment, they develop their own educational platforms, providing access services to the latest or paid educational services in relevant professions in the field of information technology, design, artificial intelligence, game design, etc. The latter is in the legal field, the state seeks to regulate the specified area. Nevertheless, there are relatively few studies on the legal regulation of this social phenomenon. In order to ensure the availability of comprehensive studies on the legal regulation of digital educational platforms, it is necessary to identify cases of official use of the term by the legislator and its meaning, and, if possible, provide recommendations, which is the purpose of this study. Results. Research article identifies approaches in which digital educational platforms can be considered, examines legal definitions, provides recommendations for further research and legal work, and defines the necessary theoretical guidelines for this.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):35-43
pages 35-43 views
Customary legal values of the peoples of Russia during the Great Patriotic War (on the example of the Mordvins)
Sushkova Y.
摘要

The article highlights examples from the history of the Great Patriotic War that characterize the moral values of the peoples of Russia, among which service to the Motherland, patriotism, unity, solidarity, sacrifice, mutual help, ancestor worship. The materials are analyzed on the example of the Mordvins. Customary-legal aspects are related to the affirmation of these values as necessary conditions for the traditional legal culture. An important part of the legal and anthropological review is the contribution of individual statesmen and jurists of Mordvinian origin to the Great Victory. The article reports on such prominent representatives of the Mordvinian people as Army General Maxim Alekseevich Purkaev and corresponding member of the USSR Academy of Sciences Pyotr Semenovich Romashkin.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):44-49
pages 44-49 views
Religious policy towards "shtundobaptism" in the Russian Empire in the second half of the 19th century
Lukyanov S., Tarasova I., Shuvalov A.
摘要

The purpose of the article is to study the process of formation and spread of "stundobaptism" as a trend in "evangelical Christianity" in the Russian Empire in the second half of the 19th century. Based on a number of sources, the authors analyze the religious policy of the Imperial government towards its followers. The object of the study is the state policy in relation to "stundobaptism". The subject of the research is the normative legal acts regulating the religious policy of the government of the Russian Empire in relation to followers of "Stundobantism", materials of periodicals, archival documents. Within the framework of the research methodology using historical-legal, comparative-legal and comparative-historical methods, an analysis of the activities of the state authorities of the Russian Empire in the persecution of followers of "stundobaptism" in the second half of the XIX century was carried out. The authors point out that until the 60s of the XIX century. "Stundobaptism" was considered by the government as a "tolerant" religious trend in Protestantism along with other Protestant sects. However, from a certain point on, he began to cause concern to the state church in connection with the involvement of the Russian Orthodox population in the Shtundist communities. During the reign of Emperor Alexander III, at the initiative of the Chief Prosecutor of the Synod, K.P. Pobedonostsev, a repressive campaign was launched against the Stundists, the religious activities of the Stundist and Baptist communities were legally restricted, and their leaders were persecuted. The article reveals the methods of carrying out repressive measures by the general and political police against the Stundobaptists, indicating that these measures ultimately failed to achieve the goals pursued by K.P. Pobedonostsev.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):50-57
pages 50-57 views
Local legal regulation as a type of non-governmental legal regulation
Lebedev M.
摘要

The purpose of the research. The article examines the local level of legal regulation. Based on the theoretical and legal analysis, a description of the object, subject, purpose and features of local legal regulation is given. Based on the purpose of the phenomenon under consideration, the author defines the essence of local legal regulation and its legal boundaries. The mechanism of local legal regulation is described. Conclusions. As a result of the conducted research, the author comes to the conclusion about the importance and necessity of ensuring the effectiveness of legal regulation at the local level for the development of organizations and meeting the interests of legal entities in the field of labor. The author concludes that the local level of legal regulation is the most important function of law, which is aimed at streamlining legal relations in the world of work.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):58-62
pages 58-62 views
The subject and methodology of the natural law school
Grishin K.
摘要

This article reveals the methodological features of natural law concepts and the problem of determining the subject of their study. Based on the analysis of classical and modern works on the theory of law, as well as related sciences, the author proves that natural law theories, despite differences in methodology, are united by a common subject of study—non-legal factors affecting law ("meta-law"), considered through the prism of legal experience in order to resolve social conflicts through references to the norms of the prevailing regulatory system.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):63-77
pages 63-77 views

Public Law (State Law) Sciences

Small indigenous peoples and the state: trends and prospects of mutual relations
Bondarenko D., Nasonkin V., Babanova V.
摘要

Contemporary international legal regulation of relations between states and ethnic communities living on their territories is characterised by increased attention on the part of state authorities to these communities and the development of paternalism. The world has come to realise that the predatory expansion of more developed peoples into new territories has had a negative impact on the unique ethno-diversity of such regions, and that indigenous distinctive peoples, their minority languages, traditions and culture have begun to disappear irretrievably. This awareness led to the organisation of the International Decade of Indigenous Languages from 2022 to 2032 under the auspices of UNESCO.

The Russian Federation is a party to a number of international legal instruments and fulfils its obligations under the relevant ratified instruments. Appropriate measures are being taken to improve linguistic and educational legislation on the small indigenous minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East. At the same time, Russia is not a party to the key international legal acts that create a unified ideological basis for the regulation of the relations under consideration, moreover, it has stopped participating in some international legal documents altogether.

The article examines the foundations of legal and ideological attitude to minority ethnic communities in the world in general and in the Russian Federation in particular, and pays special attention to the lacunas in legal regulation, caused, among other things, by the fragmented participation of our country in the mechanism of international legal regulation of relations of ethnic communities, which has a negative potential.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):78-90
pages 78-90 views
Peculiarities of formation of individual pension coefficient for pensioners silver block
Zhdanov S., Rybina S., Skryachev A.
摘要

The purpose of the paper is to analyze the mechanism of legal regulation of the old-age insurance pension for such a social group as pensioners of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation and persons equated to them—pensioners of the Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia, the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, etc. in terms of compliance of the norms that determine the amount of such a pension with constitutional norms and principles. In particular, the paper analyzes the norms of those federal laws, on the basis of which the rights and freedoms of a citizen and a person are restricted in terms of determining the size of the old-age insurance pension (without including the fixed payment) and the formation of an individual pension coefficient for those retirees of the power block, who during their service carried out activities, not prohibited by law, on the basis of civil law contracts, etc. (teaching, authoring, etc.). (teaching, author's contracts, remuneration for the results of intellectual activity), under which compulsory payments to the Russian Pension Fund were made.

According to the results of the analysis, a conclusion is made (and this is the first problem identified) with regard to the fixed payment as part of the old-age insurance pension, which is not included in the amount of the above-mentioned pension assigned to military pensioners, pensioners of the Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia, the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia and the like. Thus, it is concluded that the constitutional principles of law do not apply equally and fully to all subjects of pension relations.

In this connection, it should be noted that another problem has been identified for the power bloc pensioners: when determining the individual pension coefficient, it does not include those insurance contributions transferred in accordance with the tax legislation by the insurers of insurance contributions to the individual personal account of the insured person in the system of mandatory pension insurance in cases when the insured person, being engaged in military (equated to it) service, received profit in the framework of the performance of work and services under civilian contracts. Therefore, in order to restore social justice, it is self-evident that it is necessary to amend the current pension legislation with regard to the fixed payment (in particular, Article 16 of the Federal Law 400), as well as to initiate a review by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of the law enforcement practice with regard to the part of military pensioners whose individual pension coefficient does not include insurance premiums paid for them during their military service. This applies to pensioners of the entire power bloc. In our opinion, a number of law enforcers incorrectly apply the rules of legal technique, when they mix phenomena of different physical nature - space and time (insurance record and insurance premiums), legal facts, and on this basis draw a cause-and-effect relationship between them, and maybe even—go beyond their competence, intruding into the sphere of rulemaking - when they introduce into the norm of paragraph 4 of Article 13 FZ-400 non-existent. Paragraph 4 of Article 13 of the Federal Law 400, a disposition that does not exist there.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):91-98
pages 91-98 views

Private Law (Civil) Sciences

Family protection and defense: conceptual foundations and problems of provision
Letova N.
摘要

Purpose of the study. The article examines the problems of theory and practice associated with the lack of precise definitions of such concepts as "protection" and "defense" of the family, which does not allow specifying the mechanisms aimed at their provision through the application of industry norms, in particular family ones.

It has been determined that family protection and defense are among the categories of different orders, the identification of which is unacceptable, a clear differentiation of which will ensure the protection of the institution of the family, its members, which will be aimed at implementing the key areas of the state family policy.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):99-106
pages 99-106 views
On the issue of programs for people of "silver age": the legal aspect
Vasilyeva O., Novitskaya L.
摘要

Supporting the elderly is one of the key tasks of modern society. There are several reasons for this. First, older people represent a significant part of the population, and their needs and interests should be taken into account when developing social policy. Secondly, support for the elderly helps to strengthen social solidarity and reduce social inequality. Thirdly, it helps to maintain active longevity and improve the quality of life of the elderly. The authors of the article analyzed social policy and programs for older people, identified the problems of legal regulation and suggested solutions. The main goal of the legal policy aimed at supporting the elderly is to create conditions for their active participation in society and full integration into it. The subject of the research is the analysis of the legal foundations of programs for people of the "silver" time. The following research methods were used in this study: analysis of statistical and regulatory documents to identify the state of legal regulation of people of the "silver" age; modeling, which makes it possible to make a forecast of development; generalization, which makes it possible to identify problems, propose solutions and draw conclusions. The purpose of the research article is to study the theoretical foundations of the implementation of programs for people of the "silver" age, to identify the main problems.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):107-112
pages 107-112 views
Comparative legal analysis of the concept of "insider" under the laws of the Russian Federation, the USA and the European Union
Molotnikov A., Seyidli U.
摘要

The aim of the paper is to analyze the legal category of "insider" under the laws of the Russian Federation, the United States, and the European Union. The authors conclude that one of the central reasons for the lack of an effective mechanism to combat the illegal use of insider information in Russia lies in the unsuccessful definition of the category of "insider" by the legislator. Effective efforts to combat the misuse of insider information are impossible without the legislative changes that would clarify the most basic legal category, on which the responsibility for the above-mentioned offense relies—the category of "insider".

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):113-118
pages 113-118 views
Unauthorized distribution of digital content
Vartanov A., Protopopova O.
摘要

The article examines the problem of unauthorized distribution of digital content, which has become an acute socio-economic and legal conflict on a global scale. Particular attention is paid to the analysis of the legislative framework of the Russian Federation in the field of copyright protection and the identification of key problems of law enforcement in the digital environment. The authors identify significant gaps and discrepancies between legislative measures "on paper" and their real effectiveness in the context of rapidly developing digital technologies. The work provides a detailed analysis of the existing mechanisms of liability for copyright infringement in the digital space in the Russian Federation, emphasizing their limitations in modern conditions. Particular attention is paid to the consideration of cultural and economic factors contributing to the spread of digital piracy in Russia, including the historically established attitude to intellectual property and the economic availability of legal content. In the final part of the article, the authors come to the conclusion that in order to achieve progress in the fight against digital piracy, a comprehensive approach is needed, including not only improving legislation and strengthening law enforcement measures, but also active educational work on intellectual property issues, the development and popularization of convenient and accessible legal streaming platforms, as well as the introduction of modern technical solutions for the protection of copyrights in the digital environment.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):119-127
pages 119-127 views
Legal aspects of the application of insurance tariffs in CTP
Duvanov N., Pence E.
摘要

This study aims to analyze the legal basis for the use of tariff coefficients in CTP, assess their legality and validity, as well as identify possible problems and ways to solve them. The research examines scientific papers, as well as regulations governing the application of tariff coefficients in CTP.

The paper analyzes the relationship between the powers of insurance companies, whose goal is to maximize profits and minimize costs, and the rights of policyholders, for whom objectivity and fairness are important in determining the amount of the insurance premium based on the available history of vehicle operation, insurance history and other factors.

In conclusion, the paper provides ways to resolve conflicts of interests, on the one hand, between professional participants in the insurance market, insurers, and on the other hand, potential policyholders who are less protected.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):128-135
pages 128-135 views
Judicial discretion as a factor making an impact on the process of issuing court rulings
Agaronyan E.
摘要

The essence and procedural significance of the institution of judicial discretion as an inner conviction used by judges while issuing court rulings are analyzed in the article. It is found out that discretion is an important element determining the process of considering and resolving civil cases. Objective - to analyze the definition of legal category «judicial discretion», to identify the limits, scientific and practical purpose of discretion in the process of adopting court decisions. Methodology: methods of scientific knowledge of a general nature-logic and systemic analysis, synthesis, as well as private law methods of knowledge-legal and technical, comparative law. Results: the meaning of procedural legal category «judicial discretion» is defined by the author of the article, as well as the theoretical and practical value of this institute in the question of its application by judges while issuing court rulings in the context of the dispensation of justice in civil cases. Conclusions: it is defined that judicial discretion is a tool used by court while considering and resolving civil cases in essence, which determines the outcome of the trial. It is emphasized that judicial discretion is directly connected with the procedural activity which determines the level of objective interest in the correct, substantial resolution of the civil case and issuing legal and reasonable court ruling.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):136-141
pages 136-141 views
The legal provision negatory protection of proprietary rights to land plots
Barashkov E.
摘要

The article deals with the issues of legal provision of negatory protection in the civil legislation, analyzes the problems of practice of application of the action in rem not related to deprivation of possession of a land plot in Russian courts.

The purpose of the article is to analyze theoretical and practical problems of legal provision of negatory protection in Russian law, as well as to develop proposals aimed at improving legislation and judicial practice.

Conclusions. Within the framework of the conducted research, it was revealed that the violation of subjective proprietary right is allowed in the form of inaction, which is confirmed by relevant court practice. The study of law enforcement practice allows us to conclude that preventive negatory claims in the presence of a real threat of violation of a proprietary right are satisfied very rarely, despite the presence of relevant clarifications of higher courts. The author states that in modern judicial practice there is no unified approach to the issue of burden sharing proving the wrongfulness of the violation. Based on the conducted research, the author believes that the current version of Article 304 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation should be amended to eliminate existing gaps in the regulation of legal relations in the field of protection of ownership and other proprietary rights to land plots. Among other things, the article investigates in detail the problem of choosing the appropriate method of protection in case of unlawful seizure of a part of a land plot. The author concludes that the practice of Russian courts in this matter is contradictory. In connection with this circumstance, the author proposes to make appropriate amendments to Article 301 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation in order to eliminate legal uncertainty.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):142-149
pages 142-149 views

Criminal Law Sciences

The conceptual and categorical apparatus of criminal law and its development problems
Serebrennikova A.
摘要

The forms of categories of criminal law are based on the conceptual and categorical apparatus of criminal law, that is, on a logically ordered system of categories and conditions of criminal law and represents a methodological toolkit for describing and studying phenomena and criminal processes. Criminal law and its conceptual and categorical apparatus are characterized by the following features: it contains criminal law concepts; it is interdisciplinary; it has criminal content; it is subject to strict categorization rules.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):150-153
pages 150-153 views
Criminal law and criminal procedure problems of investigation of crimes in the field of public procurement
Torbin Y.
摘要

The field of procurement for state and municipal needs is quite complex from the point of view of legal regulation, since it is subject to many legal regulations, both general and special. These are the norms of criminal law, which provide for criminal liability, in particular, for bribery in procurement activities. The most controversial issue is the distinction between Articles 204, 290, 291 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation and Article 200.5 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. The establishment of the powers of special persons is particularly difficult. During the investigation of crimes, as the author believes, it is necessary to study many important documents (orders, regulations and various orders) that will establish the powers of the relevant persons, and, consequently, correctly distinguish these crimes.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):154-160
pages 154-160 views
Problems of Countering Extremism in modern realities
Shkhagapsoev Z.
摘要

Extremist ideas and views are a serious problem for the Russian Federation in the process of aggravation of the geopolitical conflict with Ukraine, external sanctions pressure and active anti-Russian propaganda carried out by foreign states. Despite the fact that anti-extremist activities are given close attention by the state, some of its areas are characterized by systemic problems and this significantly reduces the effectiveness of this functioning as a whole. The purpose of the presented study is to identify current problems of combating extremism in the Russian Federation, taking into account modern realities and determining ways to solve them. The author comes to the conclusion that by now all the necessary legal acts in this area have been adopted, which are regularly amended in order to take into account new challenges and threats of the spread of extremist manifestations. The greatest number of problems were identified in the implementation of preventive and preventive activities, the main ones being organizational, informational, resource, etc. The ways to solve these problems are determined, requiring coordinated activities of government bodies and civil society institutions in these areas. The focus is on the prospects for the development of forecasting of extremist manifestations, identified as a direction in accordance with the new Strategy for Countering Extremism in the Russian Federation in order to improve the effectiveness of anti-extremist activities in general. In this context, the need for competent authorities to develop and implement uniform methods and assessments of existing risks of the spread of extremist behavior is emphasized.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):161-167
pages 161-167 views
Problems of judicial control over investigative actions in relation to a lawyer
Smolin A., Shigurov A.
摘要

Purpose of the study. The practical demand for the institution of judicial review requires the legislator to solve its problems, which include the gaps and inconsistencies of the current legislation in this area, which leads to violations of the rights of participants in criminal proceedings. It is especially important to regulate in detail in the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation the procedural order of judicial review of investigative actions in relation to a lawyer, since this is a guarantee of the protection of attorney-client privilege. The article examines a number of current problems of legal regulation of preliminary judicial review of investigative actions in relation to a lawyer. Conclusions. The authors propose to exclude from Article 450.1 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation the mandatory condition for conducting an inspection, search, seizure in relation to a lawyer: a criminal case initiated against the lawyer or his/her involvement as an accused. It creates unreasonable obstacles to the seizure of material evidence that is important for the criminal case. At the same time, the article emphasizes the importance of preserving the guarantees of protection of attorney-client privilege arising from the positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation: mandatory preliminary judicial review, participation of a representative of the Bar Association and restriction of access of participants in investigative actions to attorney proceedings. The article considers the problem of inconsistency in regulating the subject of judicial review of investigative actions carried out in relation to a lawyer in Part 3 of Article 8 of the Federal Law "On Advocacy and the Bar in the Russian Federation" and the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation. The violations of the rights of a lawyer in this area identified by the authors indicate the need to bring Articles 29, 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation in line with the requirements of the above-mentioned law and the legal positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):168-174
pages 168-174 views
The nature and procedure for the implementation of prosecutorial supervision over law enforcement activities
Khabibulin A., Eremyan A.
摘要

The purpose of the study. The presented article is devoted to a comprehensive study of both the essence and meaning, as well as the procedure for implementing prosecutorial supervision over law enforcement activities in the Russian Federation. The author reveals important theoretical and legislative aspects of the implementation of supervisory powers by the prosecutor's office for the purpose of a comprehensive and all-encompassing implementation of the protection of law and order. The author also conducted a study and in-depth analysis of the normative legal regulation of issues of implementing prosecutorial supervision over law enforcement activities. Conclusions. As a result of the study, the author comes to the conclusion that competent and effective implementation of prosecutorial supervision over the implementation of law enforcement activities is an important aspect of ensuring law and order in the state. The author highlights the most significant principles and problems associated with the implementation of prosecutorial supervision over law enforcement activities, on the basis of which he proposes various ways to solve them based on an integrated approach. The author concludes that prosecutorial supervision is a complex and indispensable aspect of the effective implementation of law enforcement activities.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):175-180
pages 175-180 views
Criminological and ideological factors of youth radicalization in the context of neo-Nazi movements: preventive measures and legal aspects
Volkova O., Drozdova E.
摘要

This article offers a comprehensive analysis of youth radicalization within the framework of neo-Nazi movements, with an emphasis on criminological determinants and ideological recruitment mechanisms. Radicalization is approached as a multifactorial socio-legal phenomenon arising from a complex interplay of personal, social, cultural, and informational factors. Special attention is given to family dysfunction, social disintegration, identity crisis, and the influence of xenophobic and far-right ideologies, including their dissemination through digital media. Based on an examination of Russian legislation and law enforcement practice, key legal instruments for combating extremism and preventing radicalization are identified. The article also presents recommendations for improving preventive measures, considering youth vulnerability, current ideological communication channels, and regional particularities. The study concludes that building youth resilience to hate-based ideologies requires coordinated efforts by state institutions, educational organizations, civil society, and law enforcement bodies.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):181-185
pages 181-185 views
The role and place of artificial intelligence in modern society: from terminological uncertainty to the legal regulation of its use in law enforcement activities
Maydykov A., Ogurtsov A., Konashenkov S.
摘要

This article examines the challenges associated with the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in law enforcement. It analyzes key limitations and risks arising from the use of algorithmic systems, including technical shortcomings, legal uncertainty, potential bias in machine learning models, and the need to protect personal data. The study also explores the compatibility of existing regulatory frameworks with technological advancements and the prospects for their adaptation.

The research aims to:

  • Analyze modern approaches to AI regulation in law enforcement at national and international levels;
  • Identify legal, technical, and social barriers hindering AI implementation;
  • Explore potential ways to mitigate legal risks related to automated decision-making;
  • Propose recommendations for improving AI legislation and ensuring its safe application.

The results provide an assessment of the current state of AI regulation in law enforcement and offer directions for its further development.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):186-196
pages 186-196 views
The issues of ensuring the rights of the victim and the accused (suspect) in pre-trial criminal proceedings
Mamedov R.
摘要

This article is devoted to theoretical and practical issues of the relationship between the rights of the victim and the accused (suspect) during the preliminary investigation. The work substantiates the impossibility of granting victims and accused the same procedural rights, since they have opposite goals in the criminal process. The rights of the accused will always be given more attention due to his vulnerable position in a criminal case. The author believes that both the victim and the accused have enough rights to protect their interests today. The author believes that both the victim and the accused currently have sufficient rights to protect their interests. It is necessary to increase the guarantees for the implementation of these rights by developing additional effective mechanisms to ensure the rights of these participants in criminal proceedings during the preliminary investigation.

This article aims to focus attention not on the number of individual rights in criminal proceedings, but on ensuring the implementation of existing rights. The lack of existing guarantees is one of the main problems of the legal status of a participant in criminal proceedings. The lack of existing guarantees is one of the main problems of the legal status of a participant in criminal proceedings. The provisions of the article are also aimed at eliminating in the professional thinking of the investigator (inquiry officer) incorrect ideas about the rights and freedoms of man and citizen, at introducing liability of these officials for violations of personal rights committed in the pre-trial stages of criminal proceedings, which may subsequently affect the rendering of a legal and fair sentence.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):197-204
pages 197-204 views
Novelties of the criminal law in the field of countering the financing of extremist activities
Kameneva A.
摘要

This paper examines the current trends in the development of criminal-legal regulation of countering the financing of extremist activities, which is one of the priority areas of strengthening the sovereignty of the state. Financing of extremist activities is a threat to the national security of the Russian Federation, including the fact that as a result of such criminal activity provides a material component for the subsequent formation of radical views and actions aimed at destabilizing the state system and social relations. The issues of countering the financing of extremist activities are of particular relevance in modern conditions due to the current external geopolitical situation. In this regard, the national legislation is constantly being improved, implementing a comprehensive and preventive approach to countering extremism and its financing, including emphasizing the strengthening of criminal responsibility within the criminal-legal mechanism of countering the financing of extremist activities.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):205-211
pages 205-211 views
Responsibility for inducing activities that pose a danger to life: comparative systematization
Fayzalizoda F.
摘要

The presented article highlights the importance of interstate cooperation between the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tajikistan on combating ordinary crime, and draws attention to the fact that this can be fruitfully implemented only if there is a mutual exchange of scientific ideas in the field of improving criminal legislation. Attention is focused on the fact that one of the most pressing and poorly developed issues is the harmonization of criminal liability for crimes related to inciting one or another socially destructive behavior. The purpose of this study is to form a system of knowledge about a group of norms of Russian and Tajik criminal legislation that establish responsibility for inducing activities that pose a danger to life. In conclusion, the author's system of relevant crimes is presented, their fundamental difference from other crimes criminalizing inflammatory actions, and the conclusion is made about the importance of a logical method of systematization in criminal law.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):212-218
pages 212-218 views
Criminalistic signs of the victim's fear of a crime in criminal cases of crimes against sexual freedom and sexual integrity
Solovyov A.
摘要

The purpose of the study. The article examines the essence of the phenomenon of violent crimes against sexual freedom and sexual integrity through the prism of the emotion of fear as an object of forensic research. The paper examines specific examples of judicial and investigative practice, which analyze the behavior and interaction of subjects of criminal situations, as well as patterns of formation of traces corresponding to their behavior. The relationship between detectable traces, behavior, and the emotion of fear, which determines it, forms signs of fear. Conclusions. The emotion of fear of a victim of a crime is a criminalistic sign of the reality of a criminal event, which is the subject of investigation in criminal cases of crimes against sexual freedom and sexual integrity. At the same time, the signs of the emotion of fear of the victims of this crime are expressed in its traces, characterizing information about both the object of their fear and their behavior. These include: information about the identity of the perpetrator, his physical development, material traces of changes in the situation of the scene during the struggle, various biological traces, especially those found in the underground contents, the presence and condition of barriers and locking devices, ideal traces, which also include the presence of acquired mental disorders that are causally related to criminal actions.

Gaps in Russian Legislation. 2025;18(3):219-224
pages 219-224 views